After Soleimani Killing Suddenly the U.S. is Alone
Tom Luongo
AGAINST THE BLITZ WOLF — RUSSIAN REINFORCEMENTS FOR IRAN’S DEFENCE IN WAR AGAINST ALL
John Helmer
Iran loathes Pompeo’s Chabahar gift
M. K. Bhadrakumar | retired diplomat with the Indian Foreign Service
On The Idiotic Partisan Debate Over Regime Change In Iran Or Syria
Caitlin Johnstone
The Axis Of Resistance Announces The Project That Will Avenge Qassem Soleimani
Trump moves to unite the Middle East! (irony)
Col. W. Patrick Lang, US Army (ret.)
The Grayzone
Iraqi PM reveals Soleimani was on peace mission when assassinated, exploding Trump’s lie of ‘imminent attacks’
Max Blumenthal
The Intercept
TV Pundits Praising Suleimani Assassination Neglect to Disclose Ties to Arms Industry
Lee Fang
Is the Chairman of the JCS freaking out (answer: he should and he is!)
The Saker
Chaos: Pentagon Denies "Poorly Worded" Iraq Withdrawal Letter, Esper Says "No Decision To Leave Iraq, Period"
Tyler Durden
Pentagon asserts the U.S. will not target Iranian cultural sites [contradicting the president]
Catherine Garcia
Alternet
Trump’s Defense secretary just completely contradicted the president’s threat to commit war crimes
Cody Fenwick
Zero Hedge
China Replaces Top Hong Kong Official; Appoints "Strongman" In Signal To Protesters
Tyler Durden
Catherine Garcia
Alternet
Trump’s Defense secretary just completely contradicted the president’s threat to commit war crimes
Cody Fenwick
China Replaces Top Hong Kong Official; Appoints "Strongman" In Signal To Protesters
Tyler Durden
So what is going on in the Pentagaon?
ReplyDeleteSo the story is that military leaders presented Trump with an array of options, and no one expected him to pick this option, the most extreme. They were then shocked when he did. The Trump team couldn't even get on the same "imminent threat"-page prior to the attack.
After the Iraqi parliament votes for us to leave, that not "poorly worded" letter gets sent to Iraq, by "accident", informing Iraq of our departure.
I find it difficult to imagine a "mistake" like that that happening.
A) Why was the letter drafted in the first place?
B) Once drafted, is it even possible that someone did a sort of inter-governmental "reply-all"-style mistake? (I needed Bob in the next office over to proof-read this letter I supposedly had no reason at all to write and I accidentally clicked the Iraqi Defense Minister instead, whoops)
C) If it's it's not, in fact, "a mistake", what was the purpose? Exactly what signal does it send?
What would a US adversary be reading from this? The entire thing sounds clownish.
It seems there's significant dissension inside the Pentagon.
The prevailing assumption is that the Trump administration is unwilling to go to war against Iran. They are willing to engage in tit-for-tat. A dangerous strategy, but not as dangerous as having decided to go to war upon the next pretext.
ReplyDeleteTrump could spin this by claiming he got the US out of Iraq. Maybe he forgot that a letter to that effect had been drafted.
When presenting an array of options to a monkey, never include a banana.
Trump wants to get out of the ME he ran on it and won and his base supports him on this... he's working on it but its not a slam dunk (needs to get Iran to negotiate which they are not doing... maybe without the Salami guy they will now negotiate.. ).. and there are other GOP and Military elements that support the current unending low intensity conflict that he has to work...
ReplyDeleteThat said if Iran hits us presently (injures/kills US persons) he's going to hit back disproportionately... he's a self-described "counter puncher"... "get even!"... "eye for an eye!" etc... plus he knows we can kill them all in 2 or 3 days if we have to which is a solid fallback...
Not hard to figure out...
Not hard to figure out...
ReplyDeleteAn analysis worthy of someone with no pubes..
The accidental letter is a strange one. Maybe it doesn't have the significance I think it has, but it was drafted in the first place.
ReplyDeleteThe US lost in Iraq and Syria, maybe killing Solemani was just our face-saving maneuver to allow to withdraw. But I'll believe that when I see it.
If Trump would smart, which he's no signs of being, he'd pull the US out and he'd claim triple victory. Victory against ISIS, victory against Iran, and he brought the troops home. Of course only bringing the troops home part would be true, but the truth matters exactly zero. Taking credit for shit we didn't do is sort of our thing.
But Trump's history is one of being a conman and serial bungler so he'll fuck this up somehow too, all it'll take is for one neocon to call him weak.
Matt's analysis holds no water.
ReplyDeleteIf Trump wanted out of the ME he could have done so on day one, but, he surrounded himself with neocons. Instead, he childishly withdrew from the JPCOA, which the Iranians continued to abide by. If he just had to stroke his ego, he could have just changed the name of the agreement to "The Donald J Trump Make Middle East Peace Again Peace Treaty" told his cult supporters it's the best agreement since sliced bread and they would have eaten that shit up.
But no, he makes a bigger mess.
OK, so the letter sent by "mistake" *definitely* was not sent by mistake.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/us-iran-soleimani-tensions-intl-01-07-20/h_153c5ecb7783d2e04b32766637d2d8cb
----
The prime minister said he received two versions of the letter — one in Arabic and another in English.
"The Arabic translation in one of the paragraphs contradicted the English one," he said in the cabinet meeting.
"When we told them the Arabic text is different from the English, they sent us another version that matched the English version," Abdul Mahdi explained.
"This is not a paper that fell out of a photocopy machine or something that came by accident. They told us this is a draft but this is what a received. How do we act as a state?" he said.
-------
So what kind of message is this?
A message of resistance from inside the State Department?
ReplyDeleteLetter drafted by Gen. William Seely, a US commander in Iraq.
ReplyDeleteYeah Bob, I sort of thought a similar thing. The apparent shock and the initial signalling of capitulation to Iraq's wishes coming out of the Pentagon may have been a way to say "Yeah, we know, we done fucked up. Yeah, we know, we have a petulant child as a leader". But who knows. That general behind Trump during his most recent address sure looked uncomfortable.
ReplyDeleteIt seems the Iranians have reset the chessboard. We have the Saudi disaster in Yemen, the humiliating Saudi oil vulnerability and the reports the Saudi's were entering into discussions with Tehran (the whole reason Soleimani was in Bahgdad). And now the Iranians, in their shrewd, face saving action, have shown they can hit targets hundreds of miles outside their borders with precision. Total war would have very high costs for the entire globe. It's in no one's interest.
Opportunities exist now, but we know how the Americans aren't agreement capable. So who knows.