Showing posts with label Anthony Thirlwall. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Anthony Thirlwall. Show all posts

Friday, October 6, 2017

Ramanan — Anthony Thirlwall On How He Became A Kaldorian


Some  links.

The Case for Concerted Action
Anthony Thirlwall On How He Became A Kaldorian
V. Ramanan

Wednesday, February 10, 2016

Bill Mitchell — Balance of payments constraints

The late Canadian economist Harry Johnson, who came at the subject from the Monetarist persuasion, was correct when he wrote in 1969 (reference below) that “The adoption of flexible exchange rates would have the great advantage of freeing governments to use their instruments of domestic policy for the pursuit of domestic objectives, while at the same time removing the pressures to intervene in international trade and payments for balance-of-payments reasons.” How does this square with those who believe that even currency-issuing governments are constrained in their fiscal flexibility by an alleged balance of payments constraint. So-called progressive economists, particularly, are enamoured with the idea that Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) is flawed because it doesn’t recognise the fiscal limits imposed by the need to maintain a stable external balance. In this blog, we trace the arguments.…
The post everyone has been waiting for.

Bill Mitchell – billy blog
Balance of payments constraints
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

Ramanan responded in the comments here at MNE and developed his argument in a separate post. With "free trade" to the fore these days owing to the flurry of new trade agreements, this is a debate worth having.

The Case for Concerted Action
Neochartalism, Balance Of Payments And Mainstream Economics
V. Ramanan

My view is that there is a political dimension to trade as well as an economic one. Economics focuses in efficiencies such as comparative advantage. But from the political point of view, as well as engineering, efficiency about means and effectiveness is about goals. Efficiency serves effectiveness. This means that efficiency must be balanced with resilience.

A balance must be struck between autarchy and dependence, for example. In addition, history testifies that more growth of developed countries is benefitted by so-called free trade, whereas the growth of emerging countries has been enhanced by protecting infant industries. This was the case between Britain and the US in the 19th century, for example.

Friday, August 28, 2015

Matias Vernengo — Thirlwall à la Godley

Arguably Godley had a version of Thirlwall's Law in his model too. As noted by Zezza: "the ideas underlying the ‘New Cambridge Hypothesis,’ which assumed... that the private sector would adjust rather quickly to a shock, to restore its desired income/assets ratio." In this sense, in the long run in a steady state Godley assumed that the net acquisition of financial assets would be zero. This would be a stock version of the flow equilibrium between investment and savings, the private balance.
Naked Keynesianism
Thirlwall à la Godley
Matias Vernengo | Associate Professor of Economics, Bucknell University

Tuesday, March 11, 2014

Philip Pilkington — Thirlwall’s Law in Historical Context

What lessons can we draw from this? Well, for one we can say once again that: there are no true Laws in economics. Economics, to repeat a point I never tire of making, is an historical discipline. And if we don’t understand political and institutional arrangements we will understand nothing of relevance or importance. Insights such as Thirwall’s Law (which is not a law at all…) are of secondary importance when faced with the realities of actually existing economic institutions....
Those who wield such supposed Laws and insist on their timelessness and Absolute Truth are likely to make rather poor economic analysts. (I’m not referring to Thirlwall in this regard who, so far as I can see, recognises the contingencies involved in what he is saying). Such relationships need to be approached with an understanding that historical/institutional constellations come first and equations such as Thirlwall’s can only be made to generate insights within the framework of analysis provided by a given historical/institutional constellation.
Fixing the Economists
Thirlwall’s Law in Historical Context
Philip Pilkington

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

Philip Pilkington — Why MMT is Right and the Dreamers are Wrong – Kaldor Versus the Kaldorians

Nicholas Kaldor was one of the most famous economists of the 20th century. He was considered by many to be the direct heir to John Maynard Keynes as he was not only an extremely accomplished theoretical economist but also played a key role in the construction of British economic policy after World War II and was an all-round politically savvy individual – he ended his life, like Keynes, with a Lordship.
We mention this because if you read his writings you note that there were really two Kaldors. One was the Kaldor of the halls of Cambridge University. This was the Kaldor of abstract mathematical models of how capitalist economies function (some of the finest ever produced, mind you). The other Kaldor was the Kaldor that actually analysed economic problems and proposed solutions – while keeping firmly in mind the political situation of whatever time he was giving advice.
Naked Capitalism
Philip Pilkington: Why MMT is Right and the Dreamers are Wrong – Kaldor Versus the Kaldorians

Economics v. political economy.

Phil and Ramanan debate in the comments.