(Commentary posted by Roger Erickson)
Options for Europe – Part 2
Great history review here by Bill. Much of the historical thinking he reviews held equally well for economic policy deliberations in the USA as well, and still does.
That history drives home the point that we should never let theoretical economists anywhere near national policy?
And we should also never let any single lobby, in this case banking, dominate policy?
Policy agility requires consensus? Otherwise, you end up with a constrained policy space. If populations could keep that simple idea in mind when approaching group policy, theoretical economists would be kept in check.
Coordinate narrow factions - ignorant by definition - through appropriate checks and balances? James Madison's anthropomorphic, 1776 summary of system science still awaits application of appropriately adjusted methods, for constantly changing situations.
To explore group options, we need far less discussion of theory, and far faster evaluation of new, more indirect methods?
For every intractable cultural task, there is a solution, and that solution will always involve invention of methods allowing yet another level of indirect, cultural adaptations?
Members of diverse system-science fields have been saying that for decades. Centuries, in some cases. Call it statistical process control, or ecology, or autocatalysis, or evolution. Call it what you want - even political economics - ... just DO something to adapt group methods at the same pace that change occurs? For Desired Outcomes to stay the same, EVERYTHING has to change? Constantly? To adapt to changing situations, we need citizens with situational awareness and the audacity to change anything that needs to change.
Can we please start retaining that simple fact throughout K-12 education? That's how we can damp the frequency of Ayn Rand acolytes (and sanity-lite's) like Paul Ryan, or 99% of our Congresspeople. They reflect our electorate, after all, which reflects the mal-adaptive operation of our K-12 school curriculum.
We as a people are what we let our Congress practice. And our Congress is what our citizens practice during training and education.