Showing posts with label coercion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label coercion. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 11, 2015

Sandwichman — The Strange Cult of Henry George

Interesting quote from a Libertarian about abolishing property tax as necessary to secure freedom.

Libertarians hold that taxes are simply a substitute for the direct confiscation of property that governments used to impose. Taxation, even with representation is a fig leaf for that.

This is relevant to the Chartalist and MMT view that taxes drive state money by creating a demand for it, allowing governments to transfer private resources to public use, and that the tax power is coercive, enforced by state power.

Libertarianism is based on freedom from coercion.

The radical right libertarian position — anarcho-capitalism — is to end coercion by making private property rights absolute. Governance is through natural spontaneous order.

The radical left libertarian position — anarcho-socialism — is to abolish private property rights and return to the commons. Governance is by consensus.

Both see their view as the fair way to deal with this issue.

Econospeak
The Strange Cult of Henry George
Sandwichman

Thursday, April 17, 2014

Sandwichman — Ants at the Piketty Picnic: What's Wrong with "Inequality"?


Sandwichman follows up on Peter Radford.
Why do people want to get rich? Sure, they want nice stuff, but more fundamentally they want to be freed from the coercive everyday insecurity of being poor. How do the wealthy stay rich and get even richer? They use the political power that their wealth accords to keep the game rigged in their favor....
Inequality is a positive fact; coercion is a normative claim. So let's all talk about inequality as if it has nothing to do with coercion. Let's not talk about the elephant in the room. What elephant?
So what's wrong with "inequality"? Framing the debate to be about "inequality" misses the point that the real problem is coercion.
Democracy gives the less well off the power to coerce the wealthy into sharing the wealth  — if they use it. The rich use their social, political and economic power to prevent this, in effect coercing the less well off to remain so.

One of the key arguments is that a rising tide lifts all boats. Another is meritocracy and just deserts. Both are based on unreasonable assumptions as heterodox economic analysis shows as well as analysis of social and political thinkers and social scientists.

Capitalism results in accumulation of capital at the top unless policy is brought to bear to prevent this.

Econospeak
Ants at the Piketty Picnic: What's Wrong with "Inequality"?
Sandwichman


Saturday, July 6, 2013

Corey Robin — Not Even a Bourgeois Freedom: Freedom of Contract in John Roberts’s America

For the free-market right, that’s the end of the discussion: Workers are free. No one’s forcing them to work. If they don’t like a job, they can leave it.
For the socialist left, it’s more complicated. Workers are not in fact free, the left argues, but the source of their unfreedom is not to be found in the usual guise. The most important constraint upon the freedom of contract is not the discrete or formal acts of coercion by power-holders (what political scientists sometimes call the first face of power), which are embodied in law and enforced by the state. Rather, it is systemic inequality and disparities of power between labor and capital....
Corey Robin
Not Even a Bourgeois Freedom: Freedom of Contract in John Roberts’s America

The phrase, "systemic inequality and disparities of power between labor and capital," says it in a nutshell. It's about institutional power, which is masked by the bogus narrative of individualism as the basis of economic liberalism.

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Learning How to OpenSource Domestication - From Remaining Tribes

commentary by Roger Erickson

"In his seminal study Science of Coercion, Christopher Simpson observed that communication might be understood as both the conduit for and the actual substance of human culture and consciousness."

Ya think?

Group intelligence in every organized system, neural network, social species, tribe and human culture is always and only held in the body of group discourse. Further, it's achievements are expressed through coordinated group activities. That's the definition of a social species, culture, or any organized system where components operate out of physical contact with one another.  Actually, it's true even if the components ARE in physical contact.  They still have to communicate.

In continuously evolving nations, overly centralized control of newly emerging communication methods is always a brief worry, but one that is self-correcting in surviving nations, as we'll see. It's really our national survival that always under selective pressure, not just inadequately distributed ownership of communication methods.

The first link above leads to a singularly bitter and disillusioned post that mingles multiple topics, and decries "domestication" of some people by others. Given the source - surviving tribal groups - the bitterness & disillusionment are easily understood, even to those of us that lost our own tribal affiliations and identity a thousand or more years ago. Nevertheless, the post remains germane to currency operation topics discussed here at MNE

There are links between all of the following inter-dependent - NOT fully independent - processes ... including unit cohesion, ability to accelerate return on coordination, currency operations, and methods for resisting the dis-coordinating propaganda of self-defeating Class Warfare.

We all know that increasingly agile and scalable group activities require sophisticated and unpredictably dynamic transaction chains. And growing the agility of those transaction chains has inescapably led to existing, fiat currencies as notation for many [but not all] of the dynamic activities within a cohesive nation. Those not fully committed to either cohesion or return on coordination naturally resist this, but offer no alternate form of social evolution - at least not any capable of producing anywhere near the adaptive rate we already need.

It's always true that social evolution involves domesticating members of a social species. Necessary diversity in the continuous, halting steps of any growing culture will always bring up kabuki theater about who is domesticating whom.   Such kabuki noise is unavoidable and a necessary part of the diverse processes evaluated in our selection markets.  It will always feature delusions of grandeur among some members of all social species - regardless of whether that false grandeur is labeled phenotypic strength, royalty or the 1% elite.

The fact remains that domestication in an evolving social species will either involve everyone domesticated by one another - serving net return on coordination - or that culture or species will soon be replaced.  In the long run, we will either all hang together, or we will certainly hang separately.

The only thing separating a multi-tribal nation from a cohesive tribe are emerging methods for increasing the quality of distributed decision-making. Without such methods, return on coordination cannot outstrip the cost of coordination, and the nation that fails to develop such methods will not endure. From that perspective, distribution of a fiat currency should be an automatic stabilizer, incidental to the diverse inventions of an entire populace. Anything less grows our Output Gap, not our capabilities.

Variance in any process is never the root of our problems. Rather, failure to accelerate search for yet another layer of indirection is always our root problem. The only way to continuously leverage increasing options is to exquisitely tune more of our old processes - using increasingly diverse and indirect feedback to tune more appropriate tolerance limits on our growing number of activities.

Therefore, some degree of confusion in any and all governments and NGOs will always be present. Rather than complain that we're still alive in this changing world, our only choice is to continue looking for new levels of indirection.  That's the only way we can continue shaping our own coordination practices, in order to achieve the outcomes we aim for.