Showing posts with label conventional macroeconomics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label conventional macroeconomics. Show all posts

Thursday, September 6, 2018

Arjun Jayadev and J. W. Mason — Mainstream Macroeconomics and Modern Monetary Theory: What Really Divides Them?

Abstract
An increasingly visible school of heterodox macroeconomics, Modern Monetary Theory (MMT), makes the case for functional finance – the view that governments should set their fiscal position at whatever level is consistent with price stability and full employment, regardless of current debt or deficits. Functional finance is widely understood, by both supporters and opponents, as a departure from orthodox macroeconomics. We argue that this perception is mistaken: While MMT’s policy proposals are unorthodox, the analysis underlying them is entirely orthodox. A central bank able to control domestic interest rates is a sufficient condition to allow a government to freely pursue countercyclical fiscal policy with no danger of a runaway increase in the debt ratio. The difference between MMT and orthodox policy can be thought of as a different assignment of the two instruments of fiscal position and interest rate to the two targets of price stability and debt stability. As such, the debate between them hinges not on any fundamental difference of analysis, but rather on different practical judgements – in particular what kinds of errors are most likely from policymakers.
Arjun Jayadev and J. W. Mason
August 22, 2018
John Jay College - CUNY 
Department of Economics Working Paper 2018-8

Also available at INET

Monday, August 11, 2014

Simon Wren-Lewis — On Macroeconomic Forecasting

Macroeconomic forecasts produced with macroeconomic models tend to be little better than intelligent guesswork. That is not an opinion – it is a fact. It is a fact because for decades many reputable and long standing model based forecasters have looked at their past errors, and that is what they find. It is also a fact because we can use models to generate standard errors for forecasts, as well as the most likely outcome that gets all the attention. Doing so indicates errors of a similar magnitude as those observed from past forecasts. In other words, model based forecasts are predictably bad. 
The sad news is that this situation has not changed since I was involved in forecasting around 30 years ago. During the years before the Great Recession (the Great Moderation) forecasts might have appeared to get better, but that was because most economies became less volatile. As is well known, the Great Recession was completely missed. Forecasting has not improved, because our ability to explain variables like consumption or investment has not improved. 
Does that mean that macroeconomics is not making any progress? I do not want to get sidetracked on this issue, but it could just be that as macroeconomists understand the economy as it was a little better, the nature of the economy also changes because of factors like financial innovation or technical progress. Does this mean macroeconomics is useless? No, in much the same way as medicine cannot predict year by year how your health changes but is quite good at responding to these changes.
Frank admission, but false analogy with medicine. Conventional economic remedies are more like nostrums than medicine — if not snake oil based on ideology rather than science.
The rather boring truth is that it is entirely predictable that forecasters will miss major recessions, just as it is equally predictable that each time this happens we get hundreds of articles written asking what has gone wrong with macro forecasting. The answer is always the same - nothing. Macroeconomic model based forecasts are always bad, but probably no worse than intelligent guesses.
☺

Mainly Macro
On Macroeconomic Forecasting
Simon Wren-Lewis | Professor of Economics, Oxford University

Friday, June 20, 2014

Noah Smith — Kartik Athreya responds to my review

Kartik Athreya, via email, responds to my review of his book, which is gratifying given the time I spent on it! Here is his response:Noahpinion
Kartik Athreya responds to my review
Noah Smith | Assistant Professor of Finance, Stony Brook University

Thursday, July 25, 2013

Matias Vernengo — Krugman is right: "Macroeconomics is all wrong"


Excellent takedown of Paul Krugman along with conventional macro, in just a couple of paragraphs.

Naked Keynesianism
Krugman is right: "Macroeconomics is all wrong"
Matias Vernengo | Associate Professor of Economics, University of Utah