Showing posts with label currency issuer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label currency issuer. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 12, 2018

Steve Roth — Actually, Only Banks Print Money


Actually, not really. Only governments have "printing presses" and other attempts to "print money" are called counterfeiting. Steve Roth knows this, of course, so he must being using "printing money" in another sense. Banks don't have printing presses in the basement, literally or figuratively. Governments that issue their currencies as government liabilities do.

Banks increase M1 money supply by adding assets as receivables to their balance sheets as receivables  and booking corresponding liabilities as payables. The reverse shows up on the borrower's balance sheet. Both sets of books are in balance, with net zero on the respective balance sheet. Credit and debit entires match. Now the bank has an asset on its balance sheet and the customer has a credit in a deposit account. So even though the net is zero in the financial system, purchasing power increases in nongovernment owing to the increase in M1 money supply as a result of the deposit in the customer's deposit account.

Why is this not a form of "printing money" then, as Steve Roth claims?

When a central bank issues the government's currency it creates liabilities on its balance sheet and assets on the balance sheets of banks as deposits at the central bank. Assets increase in nongovernment as a whole without a corresponding liability in nongovernment. There is a change in aggregate nongovernment financial assets.

When banks create a deposit by extending a loan, there is no change in aggregate net financial assets in nongovernment. The net is zero. When central banks deficit spend, there is. The net is the amount of the deficit.

A currency is the unit of account that which the government sets and which it accepts as payment of obligations it imposes on nongovernment, chiefly taxes but also tariffs, fees and fines. When banks settle accounts with the government as proxies for customers, they have to settle in the government's liabilities, either cash or bank reserves in the central bank payments system. This is what "printing money" implies. 

All currency users including banks have to obtain the currency as government liabilities, and the only source is government issuance of the currency through spending or lending, since only government can create government liabilities. In modern monetary production economies, governments delegate this power to their central bank as the government's financial agent. 

The currency sovereign's ability to create its own liabilities is unlimited. The constraint is the availability of real resources for sale in the currency, since over-issuance risks inflation. Correspondingly, under-issuance risks contraction and ultimately deflation.

For example, when a taxpayer pays taxes to the government that issues the currency, one of two things happen. Either the taxpayer pays in cash at a government office, or tenders payment through a bank, e.g., a paper check or electronic check. If cash, that cash is deducted from currency in circulation, reducing M1. 

If by check, the check has to clear in the government's payment system. In this case, the government charges the bank's account in the payments system and the bank corresponding charges the customer's account at the bank. If there are insufficient funds in the customer's account, then the bank bounces the check and the funds are not deducted from the banks' account at the central bank. This illustrates the huge difference in kind between the "money" banks generate through credit issuance in M1, and the "money" that the government issues through its financial agent, the central bank.

What happens if the bank doesn't have enough funds in its account at the central banks to cover its obligations? Either the bank borrows in the interbank market at the policy rate set the central banks sets, or the central bank just lends the funds to the bank so the payment system to clear. But the bank is charged a penalty rate set above the policy rate to discourage this, and a bank that abuses the "discount window" risks its standing and ultimately its position in the payments system.

Again, a pseudo-problem arises from using "money" without a proper technical definition, or else not paying attention to the existing definitions. Similar problems arise with other key financial and economic terms, such "the interest rate," "capital," and "saving."

SteveRoth is correct that loans creating deposits adds to the M1 money supply, but this is not currency issuance in the customary meaning of the phrase. Government's issuance of liabilities in the government's unit of account is not the same as banks creation of its own liabilities in the government's unit of account, which the bank cannot issue, being currency users and not issuers. 

If banks could "print money" in the sense of issue currency as the government creates its own liabilities by marking up accounts on its spreadsheet, banks' risking would not risk insolvency owing to default on loans they extend. This is not the case. Conversely, government bonds are default-risk free since the government can always issue currency to cover its obligations to security holders.

However, because bank credit increases M1, which adds to purchasing power in nongovernment, bank lending can affect the price level and spur inflation. Similarly, contraction in bank lending that is not offset is deflationary.

Steve Roth also thinks that issuance of government securities to offset deficits, which is mandatory in the US, sterilizes those funds so that they don’t add to money in the sense of M1. This is not the case. The funds that government injects increase M1 since currency is issued by crediting deposit account, which adds to M1. 

Taxes subtract from both M1and also aggregate nongovernment financial assets. Payment for purchase of newly issued government securities decreases M1, but those government liabilities are simply switched from deposit accounts in the payments system to time deposits at the central bank. The amount of nongovernment net financial assets remain the same in aggregate.

Moreover, government securities are the most liquid form of financial asset after cash, short term bills are essentially cash equivalents, and government securities are the best form of collateral, spending is not affected by draining the monetary base as deposit accounts at the central bank to time deposits at the central bank. 

Issuance of government securities does not sterilize deficit spending. There are other reasons to issue government securities, but this is not one of them. Chiefly, government securities issuance drains the monetary base, facilitating the central bank hitting its target when not paying interest on excess reserves and not choosing to set the policy rate to zero. Government securities also provide interest-bearing default-free risk instruments for the financial community and nongovernment savers. Issuance of government securities is not necessary operationally. It is a policy choice, hence political.

Ok, this looks like semantics and logic-chopping. But it is not. It’s just as important to create conceptual models that are correct as it is formal models. This means weeding out the weasel words, clarifying concepts and getting description right. Some formalism in needed in this regard, but it is not econometric but double-entry accounting. This requires thinking in terms of T-accounts, and that needs to be check by writing it out.



Asymptosis
Actually, Only Banks Print Money
Steve Roth

Monday, February 12, 2018

Friday, January 26, 2018

Seth Sandronsky — Gov. Brown, Meet Mr. Keynes


Non-sequitur. Sandronsky criticizes Jerry Brown for being anti-Keynesian and then admits that US states don't have the same fiscal space as the general government.
Why then does Gov. Brown ignore Keynes’ insights on government or state spending to spur the economy? One reason is that state governments are unable to run deficits in the way that Uncle Sam can. Another is that Gov. Brown is reserving state revenue to repay Wall St. creditors in a downturn. The state issues bonds that these elites hold and push policies that favor their class interests. This is no conspiracy theory, just the everyday workings of public policy in a capitalist society.
Counterpunch
Gov. Brown, Meet Mr. Keynes
Seth Sandronsky, a Sacramento journalist and member of the freelancers unit of the Pacific Media Workers Guild

Tuesday, October 31, 2017

TASS — Russia underestimates new package of US sanctions — think tank


Ha ha. What former finance minister Alexey Kudrin thinks is a bug is actually a feature.

Sanctions will result in Russia having to rely one its power as a sovereign currency issuer, which it should have been using from day one.
According to ex-minister, the country will be forced to widen the use of the national currency in payments. "This sanctions story creates huge risks for transactions in more stable currencies. This will trigger the use of the ruble even if it turns out more expensive," he said.
Russia should look east to China rather than looking west. China has this figured out.

TASS
Russia underestimates new package of US sanctions — think tank

Wednesday, June 14, 2017

Bill Mitchell — When economists ignore the elephant called reality and applicability

I have sat through many economic seminars in my time where there is a sense of suspended reality necessary so the presenter can run through the exercise of bringing their latest research idea to the academic community. This suspended reality normally relates to the a priori assumptions made to condition the exercise and the framework within with the exercise is conducted. It typically involves ignoring the elephant in the room called reality and applicability. The ruse goes like this – assume a, b and c (where none of these assumptions capture the most important aspect of the object of study); then use these analytical tools (none of which reflect how the actual mechanisms being studied operate); and QED we show this. I no longer go to seminars like this – life is too short....
Bill Mitchell – billy blog
When economists ignore the elephant called reality and applicability
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

Thursday, May 4, 2017

Matthew C. Klein — If you like the euro, why not just call for a global gold standard?

Members of the single currency are forced to issue obligations in a currency none of them can print. They made the choice to sacrifice their monetary sovereignty in exchange for lower costs of trade and greater cross-border financial flows. For the many members hoping to piggyback off Germany’s postwar record of stability, joining the euro would also mean eliminating the risk premiums associated with excessive inflation and devaluation. These were the same arguments that were made about the virtues of the gold standard in the 19th century....
When currency issuers become currency users.

FT Alphaville (may require free registration)
If you like the euro, why not just call for a global gold standard?
Matthew C. Klein
ht Lambert Stether at Naked Capitalism

Monday, January 2, 2017

Bill Mitchell — Foreign sales of US government debt are largely irrelevant

… there was an article in Bloomberg media (December 30, 2016) – Beware the Foreign Exodus From Treasuries – stirring up fear about the recent sales of foreign-held US government debt. I guess it was a slow news day or something because there is very little in the story that is relevant to assessing whether the US government can run an appropriate fiscal policy stance. The fact is that the foreign sales of US government debt are largely irrelevant for the US government’s capacity to maintain its net spending program. 
The sales are in US dollars and only the US government itself issues those dollars. To think that a foreign purchaser of a US Treasury debt liability are ‘providing dollars’ to the US government is to completely misunderstand the nature of the transaction. This blog considers the current data and explains how to think correctly about these matters. The question that financial commentators really should be asking is why should the US government extend that corporate welfare (risk-free bonds with income flow) to domestic bond-buyers and foreign governments/private investors. 
There is no financial reason (in terms of facilitating fiscal policy) for the bond issuance. It is just a form of welfare spending which helps the top-end-of-town....
[Introduced paragraphing by topic sentence to improve online readability.]

Bill Mitchell – billy blog
Foreign sales of US government debt are largely irrelevant
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

Thursday, October 13, 2016

Bill Mitchell — Currency-issuing governments can keystroke their outstanding debt into oblivion

It is always a good sign when some fiscal deficit terrorist or another bleeds in the media that they’re not getting enough attention. Yesterday (October 12, 2016), the Forbes magazine published an Op Ed (although I wouldn’t call the content educational in any way) by a commentator with the Twitter username @bthebudgetguy – The Deficit Was A Big, Big Loser In Sunday Night’s Debate Between Trump And Clinton. It is not the first time the author has entertained this theme. His bleat? That the current political farce that Americans call the Presidential election campaign is ignoring the state of the fiscal balance. Oh my! What a travesty. The two liars, masquerading as Presidential candidates, have the audacity to talk about other irrelevant things and leave the most irrelevant thing I can think of neglected. But what this tells me is that the millions that the likes of the Peter Peterson Foundation and its ilk have spent on trying to scare Americans witless about the fiscal debt and the US public debt situation has been wasted. That is something to celebrate in fact.…
The glaring reality of a currency-issuing government in a Fiat monetary system. The simple fact that the likes of the Peter Peterson Foundation try to obscure in their venal and expensive deficit terrorism – which if you believe @thebudgetguy hasn’t been particularly effective anyway.
Say it again out aloud – “central banks are ultimately owned by governments”.
Say it again out aloud – any public bonds on central bank balance sheets amount to the government owning its own debt. One computer keystroke turns the positive accounting balance for that debt into a zero balance with no consequences of importance whatsoever…
Bill Mitchell – billy blog
Currency-issuing governments can keystroke their outstanding debt into oblivion
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

Wednesday, October 12, 2016

Ellis Winningham — Introductory Series: The Monetary System – US Currency

Today, for this introductory series on the monetary system, we’re going to discuss US paper currency: what it is, where it comes from, who enforces counterfeiting laws, and what the punishment for counterfeiting is. But, before we get to all of that, let’s begin with a review of some lies that the media, politicians and orthodox economists peddle to the general public.…
Ellis Winningham — MMT and Modern Macroeconomics
Introductory Series: The Monetary System – US Currency
Ellis Winningham

Thursday, September 29, 2016

Simon Wren-Lewis — Why was austerity once so popular?


A pretty good one. It argues indirectly for the need to educate voters that the currency issuer is the mirror image of the currency users, so their accounting statements are complementary rather than similar. Government deficits are non-government income and government debt is non-government net financial wealth in aggregate.

Mainly Macro
Why was austerity once so popular?
Simon Wren-Lewis | Professor of Economics, Oxford University

Tuesday, September 27, 2016

Ellis Winningham — “Affordability” for the US Government is Never a Question of “Money”

“Affordability” for national governments like the US, UK, Canada, Japan, Australia is always in terms of real resources (iron ore, agricultural capacity, water supply, labor supply, etc.) and never “money”. If you still do not understand this concept, you will soon. Forty years of neoliberalism and nonsensical mainstream economic policy errantly focused on the finances of these governments, which do not possess hard financial constraints, while ignoring their real productive capacities, leaving vast resources idle. Persistent recessions, high unemployment rates, expanding income inequality, high private debt levels and financial instability have been the end results of these policies and so, political unrest is rising as world populaces are no longer willing to tolerate these deplorable conditions. At the root of the problem is the erroneous belief that these governments can run out of “money”. That incorrect viewpoint causes you to miss the reality: US Dollars are infinite. Real resources are finite.…
Simple argument to pass along your out of paradigm family, friends and acquaintances.

Ellis Winningham — MMT and Modern Macroeconomics

Sunday, July 5, 2015

For the umpteenth time: the U.S. CANNOT become Greece!!


How many times do we have to hear this crap from know-nothing, lazy, journalists or right wing ideologues?

Here's yet another moron, some dude named Michael D. Tanner (mtanner@cato.org, Twitter) of--where else--the Cato Institute--who who wrote this column in the rag sheet, NY Post, today, saying that we'd better be careful, because the U.S. can become the next Greece.

Most Americans look at the rerun of the Greek euro crisis with something between smug amusement and condescending disapproval. When will those profligate Greeks get their economic house in order and stop looking to others to bail them out?
But, should people living in glass economic houses really throw stones?
After all, just like Greece, the United States government has been living beyond its means, running up an enormous debt that will eventually need to be repaid.

Nothing...NOTHING...in this article that explains the MASSIVE distinction between the U.S. and Greece, the former being a currency issuer and the latter being a currency USER.

There is not one single example in all of history of a currency issuing nation that has all its debts denominated in that currency and where the currency floats freely, that was forced to involuntarily default. NONE.

Any claims to the contrary are either pure ignorance, vicious dogma or, an intentional effort to deceive or incite fear.

It's crap.

Thursday, April 9, 2015

Ann Pettifore — Is there no such thing as public money, only taxpayers money, as PM asserts? Was £375bn of QE raised from taxpayers?


Lump of money fallacy.
We disagree with the ‘there is no money’ mantra. Within a sound financial and monetary system, there need never be a shortage of money to meet society’s needs. There may be limited resources, and limited brainpower but there need never be a shortage of money. In this briefing I set out to explain why.....
Debtonation
Is there no such thing as public money, only taxpayers money, as PM asserts? Was £375bn of QE raised from taxpayers?
Ann Pettifore

Also put up by Ann today:

Eurozone QE: Better ways to boost the economy and employment

New Publication on Islamic Finance

Friday, February 27, 2015

Geoff Coventry — When good analogies go bad

We've all heard it.

"If I ran my business like the government I'd be bankrupt".

It sounds so intuitive; so moral. It would be irresponsible for a government to keep spending more than is earns. And for many governments, it really is true - all those cities, states, and the nations that do not issue their own currency (like Greece). Yep - they all have to get the money they spend because they are all users of a currency.
But what about nations that issue their own currency? After-all, that's most sovereign nations.

Let's go back to our analogy. We said if I ran my business like the government... stop right there. What business issues its own money? Businesses are currency users just like cities, but the United States is a currency issuer. In what way can a business ever run like a currency issuer?
 
Yep, some analogies are just bad. So bad, in fact, that they can mislead whole nations into thinking something false is true, and something true is false. Or, to put it in moral terms, they lead us to believe that something very destructive to our economy is actually the only righteous solution, and that the very thing that could help society and people is deemed irresponsible and even evil.

That's what happens when good analogies go bad....
It's the people's money
When good analogies go bad
Geoff Coventry

Monday, June 9, 2014

Classical, Class-Based, Orthodox Macroeconomics Explained In One Sentence

  (Commentary posted by Roger Erickson)





Squeezing us c urrency-users"works" because we supposedly spend more of the imaginary income we don't get, since the currency-issuer is not spending currency into existence, since it hasn't yet taxed us to get back the currency it hasn't issued to us.

Capiche?


Call it Farcecardian Equivalence.

Ricardian agents (if there are any) steer clear of Australia

Once you read this essay by Bill Mitchell, you'll never again be able to keep a straight face while listening to an economist, nor take their orthodoxy seriously. Bill skewers them all, and his expose just keeps getting better throughout.

The game's up. The Dismal Nobel Farce winners have no equivalence.

Sunday, February 16, 2014

This has to be the dumbest shit John Mauldin ever wrote!

John Mauldin writes some pretty dumb shit, but this is by far the dumbest piece he's ever written. He lumps every type of economic system and paradigm together--fixed exchange, currency issuer, currency user, debt in foreign currency, debt in sovereign currency, public debt, private debt, etc and then makes the outrageous claim that we're approaching some kind  of "singularity" as in, point of no return, without making any distinction at all between the risks (or lack thereof) embodied in each system.

You get a sense of what you are about to read when he starts out with this beauty...

"Like a car, an economy has lots of moving parts; everyone thinks they know how to drive it when they're in the back seat; and it crashes too often. But on a more serious note, the analogy of a car works especially well when you think of where large parts of the global economy are."
Read more:

Wow! If you are not impressed by that little tad of genius I don't know what will get your juices flowing.

Anyway, read the whole thing if you have the stomach for it. Remember, this guy has a HUGE following, which include hedge fund traders and policy makers.

Monday, December 23, 2013

Paul Krugman — Bits and Barbarism

Back in 1936 ... Keynes argued that increased government spending was needed to restore full employment. But then, as now, there was strong political resistance... So Keynes whimsically suggested ... the government bury bottles full of cash in disused coal mines, and let the private sector spend its own money to dig the cash back up. ..
Keynes ... went on to point out that ... gold mining was a lot like his thought experiment. Gold miners were, after all, going to great lengths to dig cash out of the ground, even though unlimited amounts of cash could be created at essentially no cost with the printing press. ...
Talk to gold bugs and they’ll tell you that ... governments ... can’t be trusted not to debase their currencies. The odd thing, however, is that ... such debasement is getting very hard to find. …
...we are for some reason digging our way back to the 17th century.
Economist's View
Paul Krugman: Bits and Barbarism
Posted by Mark Thoma

Edging closer to being in paradigm.