Showing posts with label economics and humanities. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economics and humanities. Show all posts

Thursday, August 28, 2014

Noah Smith — Economics Isn't Science or Literature


Economics as rhetoric, and math as a rhetorical device. After all economics is about policy, strategy and tactics in an uncertain world rather than general description and experimental testing, as in natural science. Like lit, it's about story telling, but with a purpose. I'd say this is a pretty honest appraisal by an economist also trained in physics.

As someone trained in philosophy, economics strikes me as closest to philosophy. Both philosophy and and economics build their foundations on assumptions that look like general descriptions but actually function as norms and criteria in the construction of worldviews.

Philosophers attempt to defend their foundations by logical reasoning, while economists add mathematical reasoning to the mix, giving its stories about what is inherently uncertain and unknowable the appearance of greater precision. In other words, sophistry rather than science, especially when traceable to conflict of interest and special pleading, as it often is when money, power and property are involved.

Bloomberg View
Economics Isn't Science or Literature
Noah Smith

Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Bill Mitchell on a roll this week


I don't usually link to Bill Mitchell's billy blog, or NEP or Mosler Economics-The Center of the Universe, since I assume that those interested in MMT follow these. However, I do call attention to especially pertinent pieces having a wider scope that others may be interested in. Here are three links to Bill's recent posts that are of general interest.

Bill is located in Australia and his analysis is often related to what is going on the there. But the principles are universally applicable. So just skip over the local data if it is not interest to you.

Bill Mitchell — billy blog

What have mainstream macroeconomists learn’t? Short answer: nothing
(about the recent BIS paper of Claudio Borio)

The humanities is necessary but not sufficient for social transformation

Government budgets bear no relation to household budgets