Showing posts with label exploring real options. Show all posts
Showing posts with label exploring real options. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

How To Avoid Colossal Mistakes - like Orthodox Economics?

Commentary by Roger Erickson

It's actually tragically comical that we're still having this same discussion, 2000+ years after Sun Tzu, Buddha or Socrates.

The answer is simple. We avoid making foolish, arrogant presumptions on a grand scale. Examples are legion, so let's just list a few, recent tokens.

First we slaughter 40,000 elephants (passenger pigeon, bison, Grand Banks etc)?
Now, we're decimating and exhausting the US middle class.

Will we recognize our error - again - soon enough this time? We never have. Bookies overwhelmingly have the USA disappearing within 100 years.

What COULD we be doing, in known practice, to improve our survival odds? More common sense, less presumptions? That's how we could avoid big mistakes. Yet we rarely focus quite enough on the long term. We're conservative at heart, and won't change until an alternative is proven beyond all doubt. So-called "conservatives" maintain an evolutionary recovery path, and "liberals" explore those emerging evolutionary options which are eventually adopted by surviving mixes of both camps. Why on earth they ever fight over the unavoidable partnership is beyond me, but there must be a sound evolutionary reason for it. Perhaps squabbling groups are slightly more agile when it comes to keeping our center of cultural gravity closer to a meandering survival path? Our fall back method for maintaining distributed feedback is distributed squabbling? We can do far better than that. Argument is just crude vs sophisticated negotiation.

Whatever the reason, here's what always seems to happen.

A situation with, say, N variables, grows into a situation with N+y variables.

No matter how much we know about the original N variables, if we miss the fact that the degrees of freedom have expanded from all permutations of N variables, to all permutations of N+y variables ... we have gross uncertainty, not just knows risks, and are highly likely to completely miss any newly optimal paradigm!

Sound familiar? That's basically the reason why all species evolve limited lifespans, and spawn new generations de novo, for new situations. That's how biological species avoid prolonged bias.

Human nomads did this just fine for >100K years ... until we developed "cultures" and started demanding stable "traditions." Almost all cultural traditions are suicide as situations change - but which rare ones aren't? We can only discover THAT by trial & error. 

Biologically, we're honest about mixing, and we respect the awesome adaptive power of Sexual Recombination. Why then, are we so biased against Cultural Recombination? Quite literally, we need to be screwing more cultural traditions, and remixing our cultural cuisine as rapidly and thoroughly as possible. Someone's mis-educating our kids to think otherwise, and it's killing us. Humans used to be able to go anywhere and become anything - within one generation. Then we got infected with mass culture and mass religion, which we had no naturally acquired cultural immunity to. Any survivors, however, will be increasingly immune to mass cultural pathogens.

Further, why on earth are we so ideologically biased against selecting from our own, intrinsic Options Recombination palette? We have an options cuisine unparalled in human history, and we're being picky, insisting on sticking to meat & potato policy options?

@#$%^&! Who cares about inane debates between orthodox economic theorists, who wouldn't know real-world operations if they tripped over one? They sound like cowardly, irrelevant, already dead rabbits pompously philosophising over YOUR, not just their accepted fate. DeLong & Krug-bunnies? Just switch the channel off and turn away. Nothing to see here. Go back to exploring your real world operations. Before it's too late, and the habit is lost.


Back to reality, and our task of changing methods fast enough to keep up with changing options. We can't accelerate human generational turnover fast enough, so we may have to make humans and human culture more agile, so each generation can go through many more changes within one lifetime. Or do something unexpected.

Psychologically, no adult generation is never prepared for the emerging rate of change that it, itself generates! But whatever they start with ... is all that our kids know! Piece of cake, for embryos, for kids and for continuous cultural-embryogenesis. Mostly, we need to teach kids & grandkids existing key principles, plus how to arduously select extremely rare, newly emerging, key principles.  Then we need to get us and most of our traditions the hell out of their way.

Mathematically, and in peasant logic, it's simple. Instead, we've royally screwed up our mass education ideology. We're actually working hard to educate people to be less, not more, adaptive. Worse yet, most of the world desperately wants to emulate the USA as is!

Some of us will survive this, but there's no telling whom. Do you love your kids? How about the kids in your neighborhood? What could you tell people, fast enough, to make a difference for very many of them? How about this as a start?

"It's not about balancing fiat [whatever THAT means]. It's about exploring emerging real options."