Showing posts with label fiscal union. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fiscal union. Show all posts

Friday, November 30, 2018

Michel Heijdra, et al — A more stable EMU does not require a central fiscal capacity

A central fiscal capacity is a recurring topic in discussions on reform of the Economic and Monetary Union, but no consensus on the usefulness and necessity of a such a capacity has been reached. This column, part of the Vox debate on euro area reform, argues that the potential stability benefits of a central fiscal capacity can be achieved through stronger financial market risk sharing and more effective use of fiscal stabilisers, without any additional fiscal risk sharing....
To conclude, the euro area should focus on completing Banking Union, developing a capital market union, and ensuring that its members have the fiscal space to use automatic stabilisers in a downturn. Doing so would strengthen both financial and fiscal stabilization mechanisms and obviate the need for a central fiscal capacity.
Longish and detailed. Compares EZ rules with US federalism.

Voxeu
A more stable EMU does not require a central fiscal capacity
Michel Heijdra, Tjalle Aarden, Jesper Hanson, Toep van Dijk

Wednesday, July 4, 2018

Lars P. Syll — Why a monetary union cannot work without also being a political union


Nicholas Kaldor foresaw what the would happen if the Eurocrats attempted to force a political union using an monetary economic one on top of the then existing common market.

Lars P. Syll’s Blog
Why a monetary union cannot work without also being a political union
Lars P. Syll | Professor, Malmo University

See also

The mess at the heart of the EU

Tuesday, June 27, 2017

Bill Mitchell — France has received its orders from the masters


Angela Merkel and Bundesbank's Jens Weidmann rain on Charles DeGaulle wannabe Emmanuel Macron's parade. There will be no fiscal union with the North picking up the tab for the South.

This is a long post setting forth the issues standing in the way and why they are unlikely to be overcome. The chief obstacles are cultural and political rather than economic. A federation among sovereign nation states is not possible without restrictive concessions that the German elite reject.
Conclusion
The point is clear.
Macron can say what he likes. But unless he can get it past the masters (Germany) anything he says will be hot air.
And it is clear from history that Germany will never tolerate the creation of a true federal fiscal capacity.
Which tells me the Eurozone is never going to work in the way the leaders claimed it would at the outset – it will always be prone to stagnation and crisis.
Macron destined to be another Hollande? Bill thinks so.
Bill Mitchell – billy blog
France has received its orders from the masters
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

Tuesday, June 20, 2017

Bill Mitchell — Deepening the Economic and Monetary Union – no solution in sight

Periodically, the European Commission puts out a new report or paper on how it is going to fix the unfixable mess that the Eurozone continues to wallow in. I say unfixable because all of the proposed reforms refuse to confront the original problem, which, at inception, the monetary union builders considered to be a desirable design feature – a lack of a federal fiscal capacity. They now know that this is the major issue but cannot bring themselves to deal with it directly. The politics won’t allow that. Everyone knows that Germany will veto such a development immediately and that would be the end of it. The latest report (May 31, 2017) – Reflection paper on the deepening of the economic and monetary union – maintains the inertness that was characteristic of previous ‘grand’ statements, such as the White paper on the future of Europe and the way forward(March 1, 2017) and the The Five Presidents’ Report: Completing Europe’s Economic and Monetary Union (June 22, 2015). So not much has happened in 2 years, despite the unemployment rate still hovering around 9.5 per cent, other than many workshops, conferences, reports, speeches, meetings in salubrious surrounds where the catering is the highlight and the conclusions moribund.
The latest Report – Reflection paper on the deepening of the economic and monetary union – adds another 40 odd pages to the already high pile of talk with little meaningful action....
Macron thinks he can fix this by talking sense to Germany. Ha ha. The euro is a discounted DM without Germany being subject to external responsibilities of a fiscal union in addition to a monetary union, and the German elite like it that way.

Bill Mitchell – billy blog
Deepening the Economic and Monetary Union – no solution in sight
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

Wednesday, November 4, 2015

Bill Mitchell — The Eurozone – being ‘trapped in a dysfunctional monetary system’

On November 6, 2000, the Financial Times correspondent Wolfgang Münchau wrote in his article ‘Weak euro reflects uncertainty of euro-zone’ that “structural reforms alone will not determine whether the Emu is viable … The Europeans have no system of transfer payments and the EU budget is too small for this purpose … the euro-zone countries cannot remain as they are: they must move towards full economic union”. He also observed that the “current is clearly flowing in the opposite direction: EU governments increasingly emphasise inter-governmental co-operation as opposed to a wider role for supra-national institution”. I examined that ‘current’ extensively in my current book – Eurozone Dystopia: Groupthink and Denial on a Grand Scale (published May 2015) – as it was (and is) a major reason the monetary union has failed. And, further, the cultural and national barriers which prevented the creation of a system-wide fiscal union are still insurmountable. Münchau is one of several journalists and commentators who have shifted their positions on the desirability of the common currency yet remains wedded to the idea of retaining it – as if returning to national currency sovereignty would be a disaster. I opposed the Maastricht proposal when it was made public and remain opposed. Restoring national currencies, while initially disruptive will not in the long-term prove to be worse than what Münchau admits is a state where nations are “trapped in a dysfunctional monetary system”.….

Bill Mitchell – billy blog
The Eurozone – being ‘trapped in a dysfunctional monetary system’
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

Monday, July 27, 2015

Dirk Ehnts — Schäuble supports European Treasury, which might fight recessions

The proposal of a Euro Treasury is a first ray of light that the euro zone’s policy makers have learned the lessons from 2010-14. However, it critically depends on the capability to deficit-spend, meaning that a Treasury that can use only taxes would be useless to fulfill its job of fighting recessions in the euro zone.
econoblog 101
Schäuble supports European Treasury, which might fight recessions
Dirk Ehnts | Berlin School for Economics and Law

Sunday, June 28, 2015

Lars P. Syll — Greece and the true purpose of the euro


Robert Mundell devised it that way. It was anti-democratic out of the gate and bound to be disruptive of social democracy in Europe. As Wynne Godley pointed out in Maastricht and All That.

Lars P. Syll’s Blog
Greece and the true purpose of the euro
Lars P. Syll | Professor, Malmo University

Sunday, June 7, 2015

Don Quijones — Germany, France Call for Fiscal and Political Union. Public Ignorance Vital for Success of EU Power Grab


Constructing the United States of Europe obvious to the fact that the contract of the United States of American resulted in the bloodiest civil war in history, the effects of which are still being played out.

What could possibly go wrong this time around with all that experience behind them? Hmm. I can think of lot of things. They can't make the EZ work, the UK is toying with Brexit, and they think that rushing forward to a union will solve the existing problems, let alone the emerging challenges?
“The euro was built on a Franco-German understanding but also on a typically European compromise,” they write. “This gives France and Germany a particular responsibility to straighten what is crooked” — an eminently fitting phrase.
Are these people naive, crazy, or just venal and power hungary?

Wolf Street
Germany, France Call for Fiscal and Political Union. Public Ignorance Vital for Success of EU Power Grab
Don Quijones

Friday, April 10, 2015

Wednesday, January 21, 2015

Ambrose Evans-Pritchard — EU has squandered last chance to make euro workable, warns Ex-Bundesbank chief


Forward or forget it.
The former head of the German Bundesbank has warned that the European Central Bank (ECB) will not succeed in raising inflation for years to come and is almost powerless to revive the fortunes of the eurozone on its own. 
Axel Weber, now chairman of UBS and widely-regarded as Europe's most influential private banker, said Europe's leaders had squandered the chance to rebuild the eurozone's foundations when the going was good and markets were calm. 
In an ominous sign, he appeared to lose confidence in the euro altogether, cautioning that monetary union will be tested repeatedly and may not survive unless EMU leaders agree to bite the bullet on full fiscal and political union.…
Mr Weber warned that central banks are pursuing policies in a narrow self-interest without much regard for the global knock-on effects, though he stopped short of calling it a currency war. "The international system at the moment is seriously unanchored," he said. 
The effect is finally ricocheting back into the US in the form of a surging dollar and rising risks in the US high-yield debt market. Mr Weber said the Federal Reserve may not be able to tighten policy or raise rates as soon as the markets seem to expect. "I don't think the Fed can continue on the path announced," he said.
The Telegraph
EU has squandered last chance to make euro workable, warns Ex-Bundesbank chief
Ambrose Evans-Pritchard

Sunday, February 17, 2013

Harold James — Making the European Monetary Union

Recent policy and academic debates have begun to influence Eurozone reform. But how sound is the advice we give out? This column argues that calls for a Eurozone or full-fledged EU superstate are overstated. Yes, developing an adequate system of European banking supervision is a matter of urgency if we hope to tackle the threat posed by an overdeveloped and opaque financial system. But calling for a superstate misunderstands the reasons politicians introduced the euro in the first place.
VOX.eu
Making the European Monetary Union
Harold James | Professor of History and International Affairs and the Claude and Lore Kelly Professor of European Studies, Princeton University

Thursday, August 16, 2012

Ramanan — Nicholas Kaldor On The Common Market


Ramanan provides a very short explanation by Kaldor of why a European monetary and fiscal union will break down if not preceded by a federal political union similar to the US.

The Case For Concerted Action
Nicholas Kaldor On The Common Market
by Ramanan

Friday, August 10, 2012

Monday, June 4, 2012

Joe Weisenthal — Why People Are Going Nuts Over The New George Soros Speech On Europe

Let's back up for a second. A nagging question that we've had is: Why did it take so long for the Euro to go into crisis? This may seem like an absurd thing to say, since the common currency has barely been around longer than a decade. And yet that seems like a long time, given that from the moment each country gave up fiscal sovereignty, they relegated themselves to, as Paul Krugman has characterized it, the same fiscal status as a third world country, having to borrow in someone else's currency.
But markets ignored this fact for a long time.
Read it at Business Insider
Why People Are Going Nuts Over The New George Soros Speech On Europe
by Joe Weisenthal
(h/t Lambert at Naked Capitalism)

Reuters — Europe 'Fiscal Union' Proposal At Forefront Of Crisis Debate


It is generally agreed that fiscal union is required to create a stable system in the EZ, which is otherwise too asymmetric for a currency union to survive socially, politically and economically. The question is whether tighter fiscal union, which means tighter political union and further abandoning national sovereignty is more workable. In light of the American experiment, which endured one civil war and is in the process of toying with another culturally based on the same issues, one must take pause at the suggestion that Europe is now ready to become the United States of Europe.

Given the entrenched nationalism on the continent, and the separation of the British Isles from the continent, a united Europe seems somewhat of a wishful fantasy. The consequences may turn out to be far worse than those resulting from a failing currency union, which the UK at least had the prescience to foresee and avoid. The United States of Europe could become a failed state, especially if it takes a direction toward a Fourth Reich, as seems to be a danger. The Eurocrats would do well to ponder this deeply and not gloss over either the history or the deep and numerous contemporary challenges.

Read it at The Huffington Post
Europe 'Fiscal Union' Proposal At Forefront Of Crisis Debate
by Noah Barkin and Daniel Flynn