Showing posts with label group practice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label group practice. Show all posts

Monday, August 12, 2013

Why Do We Do These Things? Good question. For The Answer, Look In Your House of Mirrors ... VERY Carefully.

Commentary by Roger Erickson

RM Mitchell says ...

"we asked the following [five] questions:

1. What does
[public policy] do in the years leading up to recessions? (Answer: Cut growth in deficit spending)

2. What does 
[public policy] do that cures recessions? (Answer: Increase deficit spending growth)

3. What is 
[public policy] doing now? [Answer: Cutting growth in deficit spending]

4. Why is 
[public policy] cutting deficit spending growth, despite overwhelming evidence this causes recessions? (Because of the false premises that the federal government can run short of dollars, or by creating dollars, could cause inflation.)

5. Why do we allow Congress and the President to
[curtail national growth]?"

The Recession Clock

Why indeed? What distributed remedies can we explore, and select from?

While you ponder that, please remember that Public Policy is the result of OUR highly distributed cascade of choices. We get the governance patterns which our votes create, including the unintended complications. 

To examine how this occurs, everyone looks in their mirror and initially sees THEIR personal inter-dependencies, wants and desires. Yet how many see the looming, unintended inter-dependencies? What happens when your mirror doesn't also reflect frequent-enough interactions with a wide-enough distribution of co-citizens? Then what? In that case, no matter how hard everyone personally works at making voting selections ... the collective effort may keep missing the point altogether? So that nothing changes?

Why are we constantly confused about the nature of emerging coordination tasks at different scales?* Simply because they're unpredictable, and we keep insisting that they're not? Gotta admit, we're stubborn, if nothing else.

Does progress track agility in switching between different paradigms for different contexts?  Especially when scale is the dominant context change? 

If local, county, state and national policy developments are parallel kabuki theaters, whether intentional or not ... how do you discover what attributes in a collection of representatives will help, not hinder, all the unpredictable interaction patterns once all the selected representatives get into policy committees at various levels (from local to national)?

Are we running MULTI-LEVEL KABUKI? In multi-level kabuki, diverse audience members all try to select unseen kabuki-masters, to indirectly guide the kabuki-plot in the diverse directions they all want? Do the audience members ever get together and actually improve group agility at multi-level kabuki? Sounds tediously difficult.

What would multi-level kabuki look like on a personal level? If looking in your personal mirror isn't enough, what should you do next? Stack up a series of additional mirrors behind you, so that you're always looking at the multiple reflections in a little house of mirrors? That way you might hope to see inter-dependency images that appear purely as the interactions between two or many reflections? Is that a metaphor for sensing the perspectives of many people simultaneously, not just your own?


* Max Planck, a physicist writing about newly-discovered, "quantum" scale interactions, noted that: a "dilemma crops up from an incorrect understanding of the relation between the microlevel and the macrolevel." In practice, are our biggest tasks always related to staging, linking and sequencing coordination on a scale even bigger than what we did last year? Learning that is NEVER predictable. Rather, it takes trial & error practice - which we resist because we always think that we're "running out of" the public initiative - aka, fiat currency - needed to pay ourselves, to practice on a more massive scale?