Showing posts with label reason v. cause. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reason v. cause. Show all posts

Friday, June 7, 2013

John Carney — How Home Ownership Causes Unemployment


Before the housing market in the United States went into convulsions, you heard a lot of talk about the positive "externalities" of home ownership. The Bush administration made something of a fetish of the idea, saying its goal was to create an ownership society.
The best-known dissenter was the British economist Andrew Oswald. As early as 1996, Oswald was producing papers that forcefully argued that home ownership causes unemployment. The effect Oswald claimed to have discovered was strong: Every 5 percent rise in home ownership resulted in a 1 percent rise in unemployment. Oswald's original paper set off a cascade of others that largely confirmed his results. 
Oswald is out with a new study, co-authored with David Blanchflower, that sheds more light on the link between unemployment and home ownership rates:
CNBC NetNet
John Carney | Senior editor

An interesting conundrum. 

John proposes an Austrian solution based on "malinvestment." But I tend to regard that kind of explanation as giving a reason instead of showing a causal factor. 

There's a big difference between reasons and causes. There are lots of reasonable explanations. The challenge of scientific explanation is to identify which of the many reasons are actually causal factors.