Friday, July 26, 2013

Andrew Lainton — A Simple Post-Keynesian Alternative to IS-LM

I have a pdf of this post here, I will be posting in on SSRN once I have had some feedback.
If you have constructive feedback, please post it at Andrew's place.

Decisions, Decisions, Decisions
A Simple Post-Keynesian Alternative to IS-LM
Andrew Lainton

Chris Dillow — The Transition To Socialism

...the creation of non-capitalist forms of organization in the interstices of capitalism which, if they can expand, could eventually marginalize capitalism itself....
It's already happening in the alternative economy, where it has been possible to live peripheral to the mainstream. Alternatives have been for some time as new frontier, so to speak. Now we are seeing a new push.

Stumbling and Mumbling
The Transition To Socialism
Chris Dillow | Investors Chronicle (UK)

Jen Alic — Why the CIA Is Worried About Geoengineering

The CIA is worried about the national security implications of climate change, and it’s also concerned about the potential implications of geoengineering—large-scale deliberate intervention in the Earth’s climate system.
The US National Academy of Sciences (NAS) has launched a study of geoengineering as a way to fight climate change, bringing together experts and getting the CIA involved as one of the study’s financers.
For the purposes of the NAS study, geoengineering is the process of removing carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere or reflecting solar radiation away from the Earth to reduce global warming effects.
While this is great fodder for conspiracy theorists who can imagine geoengineering as a weapon of mass destruction, that is exactly one of the CIA’s concerns—so it’s not so far out there.
Interesting article. The GOP is blocking financing, of course, since climate change is only a hoax that NSA and the CIA have apparently fallen for, too.

Oil Price
Why the CIA Is Worried About Geoengineering
Jen Alic
(h/t Yves Smith at Naked Capitalism)

Bill Mitchell – The IS-LM framework – Part 1

I am now using Friday’s blog space to provide draft versions of the Modern Monetary Theory textbook that I am writing with my colleague and friend Randy Wray. We expect to complete the text during 2013 (to be ready in draft form for second semester teaching). Comments are always welcome. Remember this is a textbook aimed at undergraduate students and so the writing will be different from my usual blog free-for-all. Note also that the text I post is just the work I am doing by way of the first draft so the material posted will not represent the complete text. Further it will change once the two of us have edited it.

NOTE: Randy and I discussed at length how much mainstream analysis we would include in the textbook. Clearly, we have a responsibility to provide students with an understanding of the tools that are used in the profession including those that are frequently referred to in the policy debate.
As you will see from the Table of Contents (information below), I think we have been fairly generous in how much of the mainstream material, which we see as having no analytical veracity or policy relevance, we have included.
This Chapter is about IS-LM analysis, a framework we also reject outright. However, during the current crisis, it has been used by notable economists who have held it out as an approach that still has relevance. In that vein we have decided to include it as a separate chapter even though, at first, we had excluded it from the book.
However, we don’t go the next step and derive and utilise the full AD-AS model that flows from the IS-LM approach and is the main organising framework for the orthodox exposition.
The Home Page for the Textbook is now available but the material is still being added and the site won’t be fully functional for some months yet. We have nearly agreed on the Table of Contents, which defines the order of exposition of the pedagogy. You can find the site at http://www.mmtonline.net and the Table of Contents is available there.
Note I still haven’t finished the British-IMF Case Study but the sequencing needs for a class that is using the book this semester requires I get the IS-LM Chapter completed first – over the next couple of weeks.
Chapter 16 – The IS-LM Framework
16.1 Introduction
Bill Mitchell – billy blog
The IS-LM framework – Part 1
Bill Mitchell

Al Jazeera — Pope sends message of hope to Brazil's poor

Pope Francis has issued the first social manifesto of his young pontificate, telling slum dwellers in Brazil that the world's rich must do much more to wipe out vast inequalities between the haves and the have-nots.

History's first Latin American pope, in a speech on Thursday to residents of Manguinhos, blasted the "culture of selfishness and individualism" that persists in the world and encouraged efforts in Brazil to end hunger and poverty.
"No one can remain insensitive to the inequalities that persist in the world," he said.
Al Jazeera
Pope sends message of hope to Brazil's poor

Al Jazeera — Japan plans marine force and drone fleet

The Japanese government has said it needs to create a US Marines-style force and a fleet of drone aircraft as it faces territorial threats from China and North Korea.
Japan re-militarizes, signaling that the US umbrella is not enough. Pretty clear that eventually Japan will have to nuke up. Things are going in the wrong direction.

Al Jazeera

Japan plans marine force and drone fleet

Max Blumenthal — Shocking 'Extermination' Fantasies By the People Running America's Empire on Full Display at Aspen Summit



A close up look at the scary people in charge. Well-intentioned but severely misguided about civil rights, human rights, the US Constitution and Bill of Rights, law, and democracy.

The military mind at work in the context of empire — the end justifies all means regardless of unintended and unforeseen consequences that the CIA calls "blowback." Frighteningly short-sighted and crass.

This is a big reason that there is civilian control of the military and separation of military and domestic security forces. The lines are now extremely blurred, and the wall of secrecy is so thick that it is difficult for the public to know what is going on or what their fate is.

AlterNet
Shocking 'Extermination' Fantasies By the People Running America's Empire on Full Display at Aspen Summit

Max Blumenthal



Sen. Ron Wyden On NSA Spying: It's As Bad As Snowden Says — Transcript of speech


Transcript from a speech given on Tuesday, July 23, at the Center for American Progress in Washington

AlterNet
Sen. Ron Wyden On NSA Spying: It's As Bad As Snowden Says
Ron Wyden


Thursday, July 25, 2013

Jonathan Larson — Status emulation as a change agent


Status emulation as a driving force in modern capitalism. Looks to be the harnessing of an evolutionary trait, although Veblen saw it as not only powerful but often also nutty.

Real Economics

Status emulation as a change agent

Jonathan Larson

Dirk Ehnts — Survival of the least skilled?

Recently I have been thinking whether intelligence is aimed at finding the truth or aimed at survival. I came to the conclusion that the latter was right, but that we can use reason to build a society where the two coincide. Institutions matter....
...the lesson is to create institutions that bring out the best behavior of human beings. And for those that say that this suppresses freedom: we already have lots of institutions that influence us. Think of school, families and so on. These are not natural, so we might as well think about how to improve those institutions. The result could be a survival of the most social.
econoblog 101
Survival of the least skilled?
Dirk Ehnts | Berlin School for Economics and Law

"Survival of the fittest" is about species survival through natural selection, not individual survival through competition as social Darwinism has it wrongly. The most "fit" supposedly have more chances at leaving offspring, hence their DNA, which on balance favors the survival and spread of a species over time through adaptation to emerging environmental challenges.


Philip Pilkington — Even the Statisticians Are Highly Dubious of Applying Their Methods in Economics!

Lars Syll just ran a rather amusing quote from a handbook on mathematical statistics in which the author — a mathematical statistician — lays out all the cop-out arguments used by those who apply these methods in a dubious manner in the social sciences. I looked up the original book and I think that it might be worthwhile outlining another quote which is, in a sense, even more damning to those who try to use these methods in socials sciences and, most especially, in economics.
Fixing the Economists
Even the Statisticians Are Highly Dubious of Applying Their Methods in Economics!
Philip Pilkington

Matias Vernengo — Krugman is right: "Macroeconomics is all wrong"


Excellent takedown of Paul Krugman along with conventional macro, in just a couple of paragraphs.

Naked Keynesianism
Krugman is right: "Macroeconomics is all wrong"
Matias Vernengo | Associate Professor of Economics, University of Utah

Matias Vernengo — Why the crisis didn't discredit mainstream (neoclassical) economics?


Simple answer — star power sell out. Philip Mirowski's critique is short and to the point.

Naked Keynesianism

Why the crisis didn't discredit mainstream (neoclassical) economics?

Matias Vernengo | Associate Professor of Economics, University of Utah

Yves Smith — Michael Hudson Shreds Obama’s Orwellian Speech on Middle Class Prosperity

Michael Hudson was so incensed by what he called a “Blairesque” speech by Obama on Wednesday that he took it upon himself to comment on its all-too-frequent sleights of hand and outright fabrications. However, you’ll also notice that the speech contained so much bullshit (in the Harry Frankfurter sense of indifference to the truth) that eventually Hudson’s comments thin out a bit.
The original speech is in black. Hudson’s remarks are in red. You’ll see he took mercy on you and edited the speech down a bit and also bolded some of the, erm, remarkable parts. I’ve added a few observations, in blue. I hope readers in comments will join in the fun by extracting sections or phrases from the speech and explaining what they really mean.
The worst is that Obama apparently plans a series of Big Lie speeches on his “vision for rebuilding an economy that puts the middle class — and those fighting to join it – front and center.” That’s at best an afterthought, since he’s given the economy over to an at best indifferent and at worst predatory elite that have no interest in giving it back.
Naked Capitalism
Michael Hudson Shreds Obama’s Orwellian Speech on Middle Class Prosperity
Posted by Yves Smith

Randy Wray — Wall Street’s Rent Seeking Vampires Kill Innovation


I can't tell you how excited I am to see Randy going after rent-seeking. I had though that was missing as an MMT emphasis previously, although Michael Hudson has been on it for a long time. As Randy pointed out in his previous post, "euthanizing the rentiers" in the sense of ending parasitical economic rent and extractive rent-seeking was high on the policy agenda of Keynes at the conclusion of the General Theory.

While there are moral arguments against economic rent, rent-seeking is inefficient and constitutes an unnecessary drag on circular flow that inhibits productive investment and innovation. It also leads to inequality that also becomes an economic drag, as well as increasing the political power of wealth.

Perhaps most significantly in the long run, without addressing rentierism and rent-seeking, capitalism becomes increasing incompatible with democracy and distributive justice, and leads to corporate statism.

Even from the side of capitalism, economic rent and rent-seeking are also disruptive to price discovery in markets by favoring vested interests that able to extract rents and thereby to exact privilege as well. This leads to artificially imposed market power and artificial scarcity, as well as exclusion of disruptive innovation that would shift the status quo.

Economonitor — Great Leap Forward
Wall Street’s Rent Seeking Vampires Kill Innovation
L. Randall Wray | Professor of Economics, UMKC


Steve Roth — Not Spending is Not Investment

I see this logical error so constantly, almost every day, that I feel the need to reiterate. Personal saving, virtuous and useful as it is for individuals, does not increase investment. This is what I call the “lump of money” fallacy (a.k.a. the loanable funds model)....
Asymptosis
Not Spending is Not Investment
Steve Roth

Michael Stephens — The “Success” of the Greek Bailouts

Along with ideology and pet economic theories, C. J. Polychroniou suggests another (far more cynical) interpretation [than the failure of austerity as a policy]. The bailout programs, he says, aresucceeding in some respects; the problem is that we may be incorrectly assuming what the main priorities are:
"Amazingly enough, in the face of this ongoing and uncontrolled catastrophe, and despite the IMF’s admission that it misjudged the impact of austerity on Greece’s economy and its people, IMF and EU officials remain as committed as ever to the policies responsible for Greece’s collapse. But while many seem surprised by this apparently contradictory posture, they shouldn’t be. The austerity “shock treatments” administered by the IMF and the EU have two explicit goals: (1) to ensure that the loans are paid back no matter what the cost, and (2) to roll back the average standard of living in order to create highly favorable conditions for international business-investment opportunities and to increase the rate of profit for the corporate and financial elite at home. It is an avowedly class-warfare approach, cloaked in the organization’s holier-than-thou rhetoric about the overall benefits of a neoliberal economic order and the economic drag created by organized labor and workers’ rights, social welfare provisions, and decent wages."
Doh. That was the neoliberal goal from the get-go and it hasn't changed a bit. It's straight up "disaster capitalism" as laid out by Naomi Klein. In fact, although the context is different, the policy is actually quite similar to the assassination of President Allende and installation of General Pinochet in Chile. Neoliberalism is antithetical to democracy and treats workers as a commodity in "the labor market." When C. J. Polychroniou says "roll back the average standard of living," this means reduction in the real wage, and lowering of benefits and protection for workers as well as public services. This is also an opportunity to privatize public resources and enclose more of the commons in order to monetize it "for greater efficiency" through market disciline.

Multiplier Effect
The “Success” of the Greek Bailouts
Michael Stephens

Greg Palast shows how this was the intention of the creators of the EZ, Robert Mundell, evil genius of the euro — For the architect of the euro, taking macroeconomics away from elected politicians and forcing deregulation were part of the plan


Robert E. Prasch — The Next Chair of the Federal Reserve Must be a Regulator

If we go by the rumors circulating in the financial press, the Obama Administration is on the verge of selecting a proven failure – Lawrence Summers – to be the next Chair of the Federal Reserve System. This is the man, let us recall, whose greatest success in office was to work for the repeal of Glass-Steagall in 1999 and the nudge along the passage of the Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000 (which forbade any agency from regulating Credit Default Swaps). These profoundly mistaken decisions provided the nation’s largest and most irresponsible financial institutions with the bulk of the permission they needed to leverage up their balance sheets, hide the risks inherent in the mortgage-backed securities they were pushing onto unsuspecting investors, all while enabling them to become Too Big To Fail (and, as no less than the Attorney General of the United States has affirmed, Too Big To Prosecute)....
New Economic Perspectives

The Next Chair of the Federal Reserve Must be a Regulator
Robert E. Prasch | Professor of Economics at Middlebury College

Of course, Wall Street will get the Fed chairperson that it wants, since Wall Street provides a large share of campaign finance for the Democratic Party. The GOP is somewhat less beholden to Wall Street since they are also heavily funded by other wealthy donors. So count on President Obama caving to the financial sector.

From what I have been reading, Larry Summers is well-known to the White House and Democratic insiders, while they hardly know Janet Yellin at all. This gives Summers a big leg up politically.

And if Obama chooses Summers, Wall Street is not going to say no. The only big issue with Summers is his approval by the Senate, where he would likely run into more GOP opposition that Yellin due to his support of the President's "Keynesian" policies while serving in the administration. Of course the progressive base would be livid, but that has never bothered the president before and he seems to see that as positive, proving his bipartisan centrist credentials and showing him to be a Very Serious Person.


Looks like the choice is going to be made chiefly politically by White House political operatives weighing the pros and cons against a political calculus of donations and votes.

Bill Mitchell — Austerity fails – its in the numbers


Not only the numbers, as Bill also reports. Neolilberals are shuttering democracy with militarized police in order to impose their failed policy without having to the people. Neoliberalism again shows that it is antithetical to democracy as workers are no longer permitted freedom of expression.

Bill Mitchell – billy blog
Austerity fails – its in the numbers
Bill Mitchell – billy blog


Wednesday, July 24, 2013

Sam Adler-Bell And David Segal — Why NSA Surveillance Should Alarm Labor

If unions are not speaking out against PRISM, it is because they have short memories.
Good history lesson. You don't have to be libertarian to understand that government often either colludes with the wealthy and powerful, or is captured by vested interests. There is along history of government being used to go against labor.

In these times with liberty and justice for all
Why NSA Surveillance Should Alarm Labor
Sam Adler-Bell And David Segal

Melissa Hogenboom — Psychopathic criminals have empathy switch

Psychopaths do not lack empathy, rather they can switch it on at will, according to new research....
Christian Keysers from the University of Groningen, the Netherlands, and senior author of the study, said it could change the way psychopathic criminals were viewed.
"The predominant notion had been that they are callous individuals, unable to feel emotions themselves and therefore unable to feel emotions in others.
"Our work shows it's not that simple. They don't lack empathy but they have a switch to turn it on and off. By default, it seems to be off."
The fact that they have the capacity to switch empathy on, at least under certain conditions, could have a positive side to it, Prof Keysers said.
"The notion psychopaths have no empathy at all was a bleak prospect. It would make it very hard for them to have normal moral development 
"Now that we've shown they have empathy - even if only in certain conditions - we can give therapists something to work with," Prof Keysers told BBC News.
But he explained that it remained unclear how this wilful capacity for empathy could be transformed into the spontaneous empathy most of us have.

BBC News
Psychopathic criminals have empathy switch
Melissa Hogenboom | Science reporter


Hunter — Crackpot Pennsylvania police chief makes good case for town quarantine


It gets worse, or funnier, depending on how you look at it. 

This is rural Pennsylvania, after all. Your remember the Whiskey Rebellion that George Washington himself put down at Alexander Hamilton's urging in order to enforce the federal whiskey tax? (Got that? "Enforce the tax law.") 

I guess rural Pennsylvanians have either forgotten about it or are game for a re-match in the hope of winning this time. Maybe they think Barack Obama is no George Washington.

Daily Kos
Crackpot Pennsylvania police chief makes good case for town quarantine
Hunter


AFP — Tech firms say they are losing business over NSA surveillance

Revelations about the US government’s vast data collection programs have already started hurting American technology firms, according to an industry survey released this week.
The Cloud Security Alliance said 10 percent of its non-US members have cancelled a contract with a US-based cloud provider, and 56 percent said they were less likely to use an American company.
Doh. Ya think?

The Raw Story
Tech firms say they are losing business over NSA surveillance
Agence France-Presse

Saving Fiat, That Should Work Wonders For A Fiat Currency Issuer!!!

Commentary by Roger Erickson

Door-to-door mail delivery on chopping block
"The House Wednesday is considering a proposal that would end door-to-door mail delivery and save the cash-strapped U.S. Postal Service billions of dollars per year."

ESPECIALLY if the issuer of cash is "cash-strapped." *

Wow. If you start off propaganda with total bullshit, where else can the conversation go?

Supposedly, if we don't act now, even Congress could run out of fiat!!!

Where does the fiat buck stop? If we got too low on fiat, might citizens lack even the initiative to vote? Might they also curtail how often they simply read, look, interact, learn .... even think? Can't do nuttin' without fiat, you know. Good thing it's free ... at least to those who still bother to think.

What happens when a nation quits bothering to think?



* If a US Public Agency could actually be cash-strapped, then why would pernicious lobbyists work so long and hard on getting it separated from government? So it'll be eligible for unlimited Corporate Welfare programs? :(

Our strategy is now clear, in this topsy-turvy world. If we're going to embrace Orthodox Economics, then just make SocialSecurity a Corporation! Brilliant!!


You can't make this stuff up fast enough. Lily Tomlin remains un-refuted.




Limbaugh: "Economic Recovery Is Not Caused By The Middle Class"


Close but no cigar for Limbaugh here (I'm sure he can afford his own Cubans...).

Summary of a recent Limbaugh rant at Media Matters here.

RUSH LIMBAUGH: Now, here's the next New York Times story. This one -- this one is unbelievable. It's by Annie Lowrey. "President Obama says prosperity does not trickle down and that a rising tide does not lift all boats. The conservative policies predicated on those ideas, Obama maintains, amount to a you're-on-your-own economics, when the country really needs a we're-in-this-together approach."
In short, what Obama is gonna say in these speeches -- I want you to look at me, I want you to hear this so that you know what's coming, because when the press amplifies this and applauds it, you are going to become enraged. The president is going to say that prosperity comes from the middle out.
"Prosperity needs to come from the 'middle out' rather than the top down." Never mind that this has never, not once, worked. It has never succeeded, this formula of the middle class leading the economic rebound. It's not possible. The middle class benefits from it, but an economic recovery is not caused by the middle class. An economic expansion is not caused by the middle class. The middle class, by and large, are consumers.
In order for the middle class to consume to the level that economic growth takes place, they must be paid a lot of money. And in order for that to happen, the businesses where they work must grow. The places where they are employed must do well. They must be making more. They must have more customers they're servicing. Whatever the enterprise is, it has to grow so that people working there earn more, get raises, get more benefits, and so that new people get hired.
This idea that the economy bubbles up from below is absurd.
That's what Obama's gonna sell, though. Obama is gonna sell "we've gotta take more money from the rich and we've gotta raise taxes on businesses and we gotta get that money to the middle class where it will cause the economy to grow." That's not how this happens.
You start taking money away -- just like the government takes from the private sector -- the private sector shrinks. You take money away from the rich and business owners and entrepreneurs, you get less of what they do, including employment.
Limbaugh has some points correct, as far as how he asserts that the middle class is not "the source" of economic growth, as this is not possible.  But he, just like the President who he is trying to criticize here, cannot see that it is not "the rich" or "the middle" who create conditions that result in economic growth, but it is rather the government sector that provides the increase in fiscal flows that provide the leading $NFA flows to the non-government sector that allows for increased consumption, savings and investment within that sector.

Close but no cigar Rush.

Both you and the President have it all wrong, and you both appear blind to our government's real fiscal authority.





Robert Johnson — The Real Story of Detroit's Collapse


State underfunds its pension system and puts the funds into corporate welfare. Then the fiscal scolds blame it all on poor people.

And not just Detroit. This is SOP.

INET
The Real Story of Detroit's Collapse
Robert Johnson

Robert Oak — Over 15% of America was on Food Stamps in April 2013

Lately there have been claims from some in the press and Congress that SNAP, the food stamp program is ripe with fraud and abuse. This is simply false. The economic realities of the new America are the reason food stamp usage has risen so dramatically. Next time you go to the grocery, watch for the food stamp cards. You will be surprised just how many are using them and fraud has nothing to do with it. Most people are broke and the wages statistics back that fact up.
The Economic Populist
Over 15% of America was on Food Stamps in April 2013
Robert Oak

Eric Dolan — Archbishop: Right wing of the church not happy about Pope Francis

Archbishop: Right wing of the church not happy about Pope Francis (via Raw Story )
Conservatives in the Vatican are less than pleased with the election of Pope Francis, according to Archbishop Charles Chaput of Philadelphia. In an interview with the National Catholic Reporter published Tuesday, Chaput said right wing officials in…

Eric Dolan — Pennsylvania police chief: F*ck all you libtards out there, you take it in the a**

Pennsylvania police chief: F*ck all you libtards out there, you take it in the a** (via Raw Story )
The mayor of Gilberton, Pennsylvania is standing by her city’s police chief despite a series of profanity-laced and threatening videos. In a video that has received wide attention, police chief Mark Kessler repeatedly tells those upset by his use…

Tuesday, July 23, 2013

Ali Watkins — Sen. Wyden says he tried to warn of massive surveillance program

“If we do not seize this unique moment in our constitutional history to reform our surveillance laws and practices, we will live to regret it,” [Sen Wyden] said.
“Sen. Mark Udall and I tried again and again to get the executive branch to be straight with the American public, but under the classification rules observed by the Senate, we are not even allowed to tap out the truth in Morse code,” he said. “And we tried just about everything else we could think of to warn the American people.”
Wyden blasted the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, the body that must approve surveillance requests, saying that the veil of secrecy behind which it functions negates the concept of balanced oversight. The court’s secret interpretations of the Patriot Act and the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act are too broad, he said, and render the legislation unrecognizable.
“I tell Oregonians that there are effectively two Patriot Acts,” he said. “The first is the one they can read on their laptop in Medford or Portland, analyze and understand,” Wyden said. “Then there’s the real Patriot Act – the secret interpretation of the law that the government is actually relying on.”
McClatchy News
Sen. Wyden says he tried to warn of massive surveillance program
Ali Watkins | McClatchy Washington Bureau