Commentary by Roger Erickson
'Raghuram Rajan, whose 2005 warning of a financial crisis was described as “Luddite” by former Treasury Secretary Lawrence Summers'
That's quite an endorsement!
Hardened criminal calling the whistling teapot black? Indeed!
One has to wonder what Bill Black's view is, on Summers' retrospective claim to be a whistleblower about the danger of whistleblowers to Control Frauds.
How about Brooksley Born's view too! Better sit down. It's likely your head, not reality that is spinning as regressively as a Triumvirate's CFTC "Reform" plan.
What are we to conclude? That Larry Summers remains in charge of Robert Rubin's Counter Whistleblower Propaganda Office? Stalin & Luria might nod in equal parts approval and jealousy.
It's at this point that teenagers across the USA may be collectively realizing that their entire government is criminally insane.
An economics, investment, trading and policy blog with a focus on Modern Monetary Theory (MMT). We seek the truth, avoid the mainstream and are virulently anti-neoliberalism.
Wednesday, August 7, 2013
Tuesday, August 6, 2013
Chris Tackett — Young Republican voters won't support climate denial, poll finds
A new poll conducted for the League of Conservation Votersfound strong views among young voters, including young Republicans, regarding climate change denial. In short: young voters will not tolerate denying science or opposing action to slow climate change.TreeHugger
Young Republican voters won't support climate denial, poll finds
Chris Tackett
Another one the GOP is on the wrong side of demographically, in addition to scientifically.
Lara Farrar — Among China’s students, some hope for a return to Mao-era policies
Students at Fudan University in Shanghai ride past a statue of Mao Zedong located on campus. Chinese academics say more young people are embracing Maoism as a backlash against deepening social inequality
On the campus of Beijing Normal University, professors say they’ve noticed a trend that worries them: students embracing radical leftism. They advocate a return to the socialist state that Communist Party founder Mao Zedong favored and that Chinese leaders for the last generation have tried to put behind them.
The students wear pins with pictures of Mao and carry bags with the former Communist leader’s famous quotations, such as “serve the people.”...
“The new leftists and the neo-liberals, they hate each other,” said Lu Xinyu, a left-leaning professor in Fudan University’s journalism school. “There are a lot of lies told by neo-liberals. A very significant characteristic of them is to always see America as a kind of utopia and that China should meet that standard, but America is facing a serious crisis.”McClatchy
Among China’s students, some hope for a return to Mao-era policies
Lara Farrar | McClatchy Foreign Staff
Mark Weisbrot — How the Media Shields Americans From the Brutality of Empire
The US still has military spending that is higher in real, inflation-adjusted terms than it was during the peak of the Reagan cold war build-up, the Vietnam war and the Korean war. We seem to be in a state of permanent warfare, and – we have recently learned – massive government spying and surveillance of our own citizens. This is despite an ever-receding threat to the actual physical security of Americans. Only 19 people have been killed by acts of terrorism in the US since 11 September 2001, and none or almost none of these was connected to foreign terrorists. Also, there are no "enemy states" that pose a significant military threat to the US – if any governments can be called "enemy states" at all.
One of the reasons for this disconnect is that most of the mass media provide a grossly distorted view of US foreign policy. It presents an American foreign policy that is far more benign and justifiable than the reality of empire that most of the world knows. In a well-researched and thoroughly documented article published by the North American Congress on Latin America (NACLA), Keane Bhatt provides an excellent case study of how this happens.AlterNet
How the Media Shields Americans From the Brutality of Empire
Mark Weisbrot | The Guardian
NOAA warns Arctic ice is melting has reached new ‘striking’ record
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration climate study puts 2012 among the 10 warmest years on record
The Arctic lost record amounts of sea ice last year and is changing at an unprecedented pace due to climate change, a landmark climate study said on Tuesday.
The Raw Story
NOAA warns Arctic ice is melting has reached new ‘striking’ record
Suzanne Goldenberg, The Guardian
George Chidi — Conservative media’s attacks on climate science effectively erode viewers’ belief in scientists
You knew this already, but here is the science. Of course, this won't affect the Fox News audience, which doen't believe in science.
When conservatives come away from Fox News feeling ever more certain that climate change is a hoax, it may have something to do with an overall attack on scientists as authorities to be trusted.
So argues a paper published in the August issue of peer-reviewed journal Public Understanding of Science, which connects the conservative disbelief in man-made climate change to a media-driven effort by conservatives to foment broad distrust of scientists.The Raw Story
Conservative media’s attacks on climate science effectively erode viewers’ belief in scientists
George Chidi
Eric W. Dolan — Obama administration task force wants to make unauthorized streaming a felony
The U.S. Department of Commerce wants to crack down on the unauthorized streaming of video and audio content by reviving a provision of the Stop Online Piracy Act. In a report released last week, the Commerce Department’s Internet Policy Task Force…
Daniel Little — Economic observations
Oskar Morgenstern was one of the founders of mathematical game theory, as co-author with John von Neumann in 1944 of Theory of Games and Economic Behavior. He was also the author in 1950 (revised in 1963) of a book that should be of substantial interest to philosophers of the social sciences. The book was called On Accuracy of Economic Observations, and it called into question the unreasonable level of confidence that economists had in economic statistics in the post-war period.Understanding Society
Economic observations
Daniel Little | Chancellor, University of Michigan at Dearborn
This is a huge issue that has struck me on several occasions. It certainly affected (infected) Reinhart & Rogoff, which became the basis of austerity as neoliberal policy in the US, UK, and EZ.
Philip Pilkington — Routledge’s Karma: Free Stuff Alert!
Routledge, it would seem, are balancing their karma almost perfectly these days having provided a load of free papers on and by one of the worst economists of the 20th century and one of the best. That is, Friedrich von Hayek and Joan Robinson respectively.Fixing the Economists
Routledge’s Karma: Free Stuff Alert!
Philip Pilkington
Matias Vernengo — What killed theory? What theory?
So Noah Smith and Paul Krugman are again trying their hand at the history of economic ideas to understand what happened with the profession in the last three decades....Naked Keynesianism
What killed theory? What theory?
Matias Vernengo | Associate Professor of Economics, University of Utah
Scientific models are (supposed to be) general descriptions of some segment of reality. Their connection with reality is buttressed by correct predictions. But theories are never finally confirmed, since general assertions regarding unbounded sets, and future information is unbounded, are always open to disconfirmation. A single solid disconfirmation is sufficient to falsify a hypothesis, whereas theories are not disconfirmed as such. When problems develop, at first ad hoc solutions are devised within the theoretical framework, but when problems mount or a single issue calls the whole way of looking into question, then theorists look for a better instrument for seeing, i.e., a new theory.
Theories are ways of seeing reality from a particular perspective. The closer they are to a general description that is borne out by testing, with major hypotheses surviving attempts at falsification, the more scientific they can claim to be. Regardless of past successes, anomalies often arise that the theory does not explain, and these become the problem set that defines the cutting edge of the discipline.
No model can be representational for other than a simple bounded system, where anomaly is ruled out. As complexity increases, the potential for representational modeling decreases owing to the uncertainty introduced by unknown unknowns that cannot be foreseen prior to their emergence from analysis of the system based on existing information.
The way of seeing embedded in a theory that attempts to generally describe a complex system is scientific to the degree that it enables accurate prediction and unscientific to the degree it doesn't. The latter condition arises owing to two chief reasons. First, emergence, and secondly, assumptions that are not empirically testable or which testing tends to call into question if not disconfirm. Emergence is not controllable, but assumptions are, at least to a degree.
To the degree that a theory is unscientific and the approach is uncritical, it can be described as mythological. And to the degree that a mythological way of seeing is accepted, the field is dominated by magical thinking.
However, a purely empirical approach focusing only on data is unsatisfactory for it offers no way of seeing the entire data set scientifically, i.e., in terms of a general description. It is not possible to have an integrated field of study without presuming some way of seeing, that is organizing raw data into information. Hence, ignoring the operative way of seeing in using a purely empirical approach invites magical thinking as the method and mythology as the POV.
This is a knotty issue in social science, and conventional economics is deeply affected by it. The assumption of the market as a "natural" phenomenon is a myth based on magical thinking, i.e., "the invisible hand," whose basis is "rationality," functioning as deus ex machina. Homo economicus is a mythological creature.
Three Quotes To Motivate Electorates To Explore Cultural Options At Breakneck Speed
Commentary by Roger Erickson
While, of course, accidentally reaping the payoff from such exploration.

1) military "Never tell people how to do things. [Tempt] them [with something worth achieving] and they will surprise you with their [collective] ingenuity." George S. Patton
(This highlights the issue of LETTING everyone orient - in their own way - to some desired outcome broad enough to encompass everyone's goals.
Let's be pragmatic. Most people rarely need to know all the details of their own context, let alone much about everyone else's local milestone goals. Instead, we only need to know whether or not any action gets the group closer to the group goal - i.e., the desired outcome - which is a Big Tent big enough to encompass everyone's local goals. Sharing one desired, group outcome is exactly what greatly simplifies local selection tasks.)
2) software programming "For every intractable problem .. there is a solution, and that solution will involve yet another level of indirection."
(That's also a pretty good re-statement of the theory of evolution! And of Patton's message too.
While, of course, accidentally reaping the payoff from such exploration.
1) military "Never tell people how to do things. [Tempt] them [with something worth achieving] and they will surprise you with their [collective] ingenuity." George S. Patton
(This highlights the issue of LETTING everyone orient - in their own way - to some desired outcome broad enough to encompass everyone's goals.
Let's be pragmatic. Most people rarely need to know all the details of their own context, let alone much about everyone else's local milestone goals. Instead, we only need to know whether or not any action gets the group closer to the group goal - i.e., the desired outcome - which is a Big Tent big enough to encompass everyone's local goals. Sharing one desired, group outcome is exactly what greatly simplifies local selection tasks.)
2) software programming "For every intractable problem .. there is a solution, and that solution will involve yet another level of indirection."
(That's also a pretty good re-statement of the theory of evolution! And of Patton's message too.
Example, when the front door is blocked, it may be faster to go around & use the side or back doors, or windows. Duh! So WHERE ARE THE PATHS TO CURRENTLY UNKNOWN SIDE & BACK DOORS? Just let people find them. Pronto! And then openly welcome whatever they find, no matter how unexpected. What's your greater interest, personally being right, or seeing national success?)
3) "All people learn best via unbiased experience with the context they must master, BEFORE ever prejudicing their perspective with prior instructions or information."
(Both premises 1 and 2, above, are subsumed in the original premise of early education, by Friedrich Frobel, the founder of Kindergarten. This is now known as OBT&E - or Outcomes-Based Education & Training.)
"Friedrich Fröbel's great insight was to recognize the importance of [operational] activity .. in [any sort of] learning."
That is, when you're trying new stuff, it never matters what "should" or "shouldn't" work, only what's openly observed to work. So avoid the talk, and just trick groups into innocently practicing something worth "doing". Then, as Patton advised, discuss any key details later, if at all. That general approach gets people past all ideology, indirectly. Generally, it is an admirably useful approach, but one used most often by rebel Majors & Colonels! :)
For those of you working in any particular discipline, if you can design some Workshop Exercises to trick [YOUR INDUSTRY] folks into thinking outside their prior-presumption-boxes without actually discussing fiat currency operations, then you'll have added a missing recruitment process to the MMT task - operationally-effective recruitment diversity. Plus, you'll have gained experience designing "Cognitive Illusions" that lead people by the nose, to the dissonance between their locally-unique, ideological-prejudice-traps and their ongoing Operational-Reality. That kind of practical experience is worth it's weight in ... well, something more valuable than gold! :)
Note: Much later, Frobel's outcomes-based, or immersion-training approach to all training eventually led to the awe-inspiring Prussian-Officer-Training-System (1809-1933; finally disbanded by the Nazis) & also to our necessarily recurring revolutions in Mil-Officer training.
"The fundamental principles of education, instruction and teaching, should be passive and protective, not directive and interfering." Friedrich Frobel
[Whoa! A century later, Gen. Patton paraphrased a Kindergarten teacher nearly exactly!]
Sadly, the operational Kindergarten/Prussian educational approach never quite made it out of Kindergarten & Mil-Officer training, and into general Policy and Civics. :( And it's effectively banned from Religion and all Economics!
While operations-based analysis is paramount in Warren Mosler's work, MMT is not economics. Rather, it is pragmatic operations, which COULD be applied to fiscal and monetary policy, if there were even a few more pragmatic people left in the USA.
3) "All people learn best via unbiased experience with the context they must master, BEFORE ever prejudicing their perspective with prior instructions or information."
(Both premises 1 and 2, above, are subsumed in the original premise of early education, by Friedrich Frobel, the founder of Kindergarten. This is now known as OBT&E - or Outcomes-Based Education & Training.)
"Friedrich Fröbel's great insight was to recognize the importance of [operational] activity .. in [any sort of] learning."
That is, when you're trying new stuff, it never matters what "should" or "shouldn't" work, only what's openly observed to work. So avoid the talk, and just trick groups into innocently practicing something worth "doing". Then, as Patton advised, discuss any key details later, if at all. That general approach gets people past all ideology, indirectly. Generally, it is an admirably useful approach, but one used most often by rebel Majors & Colonels! :)
For those of you working in any particular discipline, if you can design some Workshop Exercises to trick [YOUR INDUSTRY] folks into thinking outside their prior-presumption-boxes without actually discussing fiat currency operations, then you'll have added a missing recruitment process to the MMT task - operationally-effective recruitment diversity. Plus, you'll have gained experience designing "Cognitive Illusions" that lead people by the nose, to the dissonance between their locally-unique, ideological-prejudice-traps and their ongoing Operational-Reality. That kind of practical experience is worth it's weight in ... well, something more valuable than gold! :)
Note: Much later, Frobel's outcomes-based, or immersion-training approach to all training eventually led to the awe-inspiring Prussian-Officer-Training-System (1809-1933; finally disbanded by the Nazis) & also to our necessarily recurring revolutions in Mil-Officer training.
"The fundamental principles of education, instruction and teaching, should be passive and protective, not directive and interfering." Friedrich Frobel
[Whoa! A century later, Gen. Patton paraphrased a Kindergarten teacher nearly exactly!]
Sadly, the operational Kindergarten/Prussian educational approach never quite made it out of Kindergarten & Mil-Officer training, and into general Policy and Civics. :( And it's effectively banned from Religion and all Economics!
While operations-based analysis is paramount in Warren Mosler's work, MMT is not economics. Rather, it is pragmatic operations, which COULD be applied to fiscal and monetary policy, if there were even a few more pragmatic people left in the USA.
Peter S. Goodman — Washington Post Purchase Shows Jeff Bezos Is Once Again Using The Web For Traditional Means
Can Jeff Bezos turn The Washing Post around by standing newspaper publishing on its head, as he did with book publishing? We are about to see.
The Huffington Post — The Blog
Washington Post Purchase Shows Jeff Bezos Is Once Again Using The Web For Traditional Means
Peter S. Goodman | Executive Business Editor
Arturo Garcia — RNC chair complains about Hillary biopics: ‘We have to control the referees’
Republican National Committee chair Reince Priebus decried two upcoming biographical film projects involving former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton on Monday, as well as what he and Fox News host Sean Hannity characterized as a “traveling circus…
Robert Locke and David Taylor — The wilfully ignorant?
Reconfiguring economics as information science instead of equilibrium. Gunnar Eliasson and the Information Revolution and “the Experimentally Organized Economy.” Uncertainty and risk arising from complexity. Kenneth Boulding's iconic approach.
Real-World Economics Review Blog
The wilfully ignorant?
Robert Locke and David Taylor
Keith Wagstaff — What should the minimum wage be?
Setting aside the rancor of the political class, several economists argue that $7.25 an hour is far too lowSummary of proposals. Well researched report.
This Week
What should the minimum wage be?
Keith Wagstaff
(h/t beowulf in the comments at Monetary Realism)
Philip Pilkington — Animism and Monetarist Thinking: The Inflation in the US in the 1970s
Investigation of causal factors of inflation based on data instead of theory.
Fixing the Economists
Animism and Monetarist Thinking: The Inflation in the US in the 1970s
Philip Pilkington
Rodger Malcolm Mitchell — The psychological basis for all economics
THE QUESTION
When anyone in power – any rich person, any business superior, any politician, and cleric – speaks about money or economics in general, the first question you should ask is, “Why? What is the motivation? How will this widen the gap between him and those with less power?”
Power corrupts, and the corrupted tell lies to extend their corruption. When any President, any Congressperson, any cleric, any person more powerful than you tells lies, they all lie for the same reason: To maintain or widen the gap between them and you.
THE BASIS FOR ECONOMICS
Money is not the real goal of the rich, nor even of the middle class.The real goal is to widen the gap.
No matter where in the wealth rankings people find themselves, their natural desire is to widen the gap from those having less, and to narrow the gap with those having more. The rich, however, have far more power to widen the gap, which is why the GINI ratio continues to rise.Monetary Sovereignty
The psychological basis for all economics
Rodger Malcolm Mitchell
Ramanan — An Anti-Keynesian Central Bank Governor for India
So the news is that Raghuram Rajan has been appointed as the Governor of the Reserve Bank of India and his three year term will start in September.
This is a bit surprising given that Indian government officials are not too free market fundamentalists as Raghuram Rajan. What is more disappointing is that Rajan completely denies that Keynesianism works....
Instead Rajan offers supply side reasons for the economic mess.As Ramanan says, OMG. Does this signal that India is on the way to neoliberal dystopia?
The Case For Concerted Action
An Anti-Keynesian Central Bank Governor
Ramanan
Common Understanding Can Protect An Electorate's General Welfare - Only If That Electorate Is Motivated To Select Minimal Actions, Carefully
Commentary by Roger Erickson
John Hemington, long time advocate for the Middle Class, writes with a list of recent articles discussing things that most Americans don't know that they don't know.
Doctrine of Mathematical Impossibilities
Why Obama should pick Yellen to lead the Fed
Government: A much-maligned engine of innovation
[Brilliant exploration of new ideas in business?]
Bradley Manning, Surveillance State Creep, and
The Next Way: The Emergence of Post-Constitutional America
John Hemington, long time advocate for the Middle Class, writes with a list of recent articles discussing things that most Americans don't know that they don't know.
Doctrine of Mathematical Impossibilities
Why Obama should pick Yellen to lead the Fed
Government: A much-maligned engine of innovation
[Brilliant exploration of new ideas in business?]
Bradley Manning, Surveillance State Creep, and
The Next Way: The Emergence of Post-Constitutional America
Yes, John, these are all excellent points that should be discussed far more frequently by a supposedly informed electorate. The absence of these topics from most media underscore lack of thought on underlying public purpose. So here's my initial contribution, to help extend the needed conversation.
Regarding math. A nation's currency system is always created by the people, to denominate all the unpredictable transaction chains it may find need to see citizens execute. Such distributed options and agility flows, always, from policy agility - as a publicly mandated choice. The math only comes after the public purpose.
Yellen vs Summers? Such a choice! Is this a policy fraud hoisted by lobbyists? Why not "none of the above?" Who says there is no other alternative? TINA? Who's Tina? Bernays' publicist, or just another straw woman?
"Government" questioned as a source of innovation? This requires no brilliance whatsoever to discern. Our greatest threat is promotion of a Luddite ideology that denies this simple reality, since government of, for & by the people is both the polar opposite of fascism, and it's natural remedy as well. If we remind ourselves that government is never anything other than us, then it's obvious that teamwork in a social species always generates the highest returns and the most innovation. The best way to explore the return on coordination? Evaluate the options possible through teamwork? That's not rocket science. Just honesty.
On Bradley Manning. Ben Franklin nailed this over 200 years ago. "They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Benjamin_Franklin
The next way? All the endless rhetoric here is mercifully summed up by Bill Black's reference to Jonathan Swift. "[Fraud is] a greater crime than theft. For .. care and vigilance, with a very common understanding, can protect a man’s goods from thieves, but honestly hath no fence against superior cunning. . . where fraud is permitted or connived at, or hath no law to punish it, the honest dealer is always undone, and the knave gets the advantage." 1726, Jonathan Swift
[Note that fraud needn't even display superior cunning. It need only proceed unchecked. Keating, Greenspan, Rubin, Summers and Geithner proved that!]
These discussion points all converge to a summary point. Our current criminogenic environment starts as an ill-chosen public policy to reward a few at the expense of the whole. That policy also actively rewards the architects of public looting with further promotions to even higher public policy offices. End that policy, and we end a host of subsequent ills. With even a modicum of discussion, citizens may easily see that a vast amount of daunting activity may be easily replaced by a very few strategic actions, carefully selected to favor Public Purpose over public looting. The benefits of that return-on-coordination outweigh all other temptations, by far. All this is easy, but ONLY if we maintain a bias to carefully selected, minimal action.
Regarding math. A nation's currency system is always created by the people, to denominate all the unpredictable transaction chains it may find need to see citizens execute. Such distributed options and agility flows, always, from policy agility - as a publicly mandated choice. The math only comes after the public purpose.
Yellen vs Summers? Such a choice! Is this a policy fraud hoisted by lobbyists? Why not "none of the above?" Who says there is no other alternative? TINA? Who's Tina? Bernays' publicist, or just another straw woman?
"Government" questioned as a source of innovation? This requires no brilliance whatsoever to discern. Our greatest threat is promotion of a Luddite ideology that denies this simple reality, since government of, for & by the people is both the polar opposite of fascism, and it's natural remedy as well. If we remind ourselves that government is never anything other than us, then it's obvious that teamwork in a social species always generates the highest returns and the most innovation. The best way to explore the return on coordination? Evaluate the options possible through teamwork? That's not rocket science. Just honesty.
On Bradley Manning. Ben Franklin nailed this over 200 years ago. "They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Benjamin_Franklin
The next way? All the endless rhetoric here is mercifully summed up by Bill Black's reference to Jonathan Swift. "[Fraud is] a greater crime than theft. For .. care and vigilance, with a very common understanding, can protect a man’s goods from thieves, but honestly hath no fence against superior cunning. . . where fraud is permitted or connived at, or hath no law to punish it, the honest dealer is always undone, and the knave gets the advantage." 1726, Jonathan Swift
[Note that fraud needn't even display superior cunning. It need only proceed unchecked. Keating, Greenspan, Rubin, Summers and Geithner proved that!]
These discussion points all converge to a summary point. Our current criminogenic environment starts as an ill-chosen public policy to reward a few at the expense of the whole. That policy also actively rewards the architects of public looting with further promotions to even higher public policy offices. End that policy, and we end a host of subsequent ills. With even a modicum of discussion, citizens may easily see that a vast amount of daunting activity may be easily replaced by a very few strategic actions, carefully selected to favor Public Purpose over public looting. The benefits of that return-on-coordination outweigh all other temptations, by far. All this is easy, but ONLY if we maintain a bias to carefully selected, minimal action.
Monday, August 5, 2013
Do You Get The Impression That Some Groups Are Pushing A Propaganda Myth?
Commentary by Roger Erickson
That is, that political economy outcomes are the Fed's - or the finance industry's - to determine?
Can The Fed Prevent The Next Recession?
Are they implying that us simpletons in the Middle Class are supposed to sit back and leave Class War to the Finance Generals? Isn't every process too important to leave to the presumed process owners? Isn't that last lesson what every economic, political or any other "system" means?
That is, that political economy outcomes are the Fed's - or the finance industry's - to determine?
Can The Fed Prevent The Next Recession?
Are they implying that us simpletons in the Middle Class are supposed to sit back and leave Class War to the Finance Generals? Isn't every process too important to leave to the presumed process owners? Isn't that last lesson what every economic, political or any other "system" means?
"MIT economics professor Rudiger Dornbusch famously observed in 1997 -
'None of the U.S. expansions of the past 40 years died in bed of old age. Every one was murdered by the Federal Reserve.'......"
...
'None of the U.S. expansions of the past 40 years died in bed of old age. Every one was murdered by the Federal Reserve.'......"
...
Famously observed? Famously? How about "stupidly opined?" Stupidly? Or cleverly, for reasons tangential to the assertion itself? Clever like a fox, raiding a hen-house?
What happened to Ye Olde Scientific Methode ? i.e., "let's find out" which unpredictable combination of old+new methods will work next, for a growing ensemble traversing unpredictably changing contexts?
500 years after the Scientific Revolution, why are we still caught in this useless clash of superficial opinions - on center policy stage no less? Such clashes offer easy diversion, but only serve to divide & conquer people who ALWAYS have the most to gain by ALL working together - sharing & combining all available feedback into newly adaptive policy paths?
What happened to Ye Olde Scientific Methode ? i.e., "let's find out" which unpredictable combination of old+new methods will work next, for a growing ensemble traversing unpredictably changing contexts?
500 years after the Scientific Revolution, why are we still caught in this useless clash of superficial opinions - on center policy stage no less? Such clashes offer easy diversion, but only serve to divide & conquer people who ALWAYS have the most to gain by ALL working together - sharing & combining all available feedback into newly adaptive policy paths?
Who could the responsible group be? Oh lets see, the idiotic institutional momentum of aristocracy and class? Personally often innocent through ignorance or stupidity, but institutionally guilty as hell. A divine right? Or a mundane wrong?
Remind me please, the many reasons We the People wrote a Constitution? Surely one was to remind ourselves to listen less to megalomaniacs spouting ideology, and more to the sum of diverse, operational feedback?
All this lingering propaganda, despite what we're supposedly taught about democracy, eventually makes sane people wonder whether there aren't whole classes of people who think small is beautiful, simply because it's a pie that's easier for their limited intellects to steal bigger proportions from.
Finally, why on earth would We the People preferentially select people from the Small-Pie-is-Beautiful crowd to represent a democracy of Americans who like big and bigger things?
Philip Mirowski — The Thirteen Commandments of Neoliberalism
Throughout the second half of the twentieth century, the neoliberal project stood out from other strains of right-wing thought in that it was self-consciously constituted as an entity dedicated to the development, promulgation, and popularization of doctrines intended to mutate over time. It was a moveable feast, and not a catechism fixed at the Council of Trent. It is very important to have some familiarity with neoliberal ideas, if only to resist simple-minded characterizations of the neoliberal approach to the financial crisis as some form of evangelical “market fundamentalism.”The Utopian
The Thirteen Commandments of Neoliberalism
Philip Mirowski | Carl Koch Chair of Economics and the History and Philosophy of Science, and Fellow of the Reilly Center, University of Notre Dame
Winterspeak— Intentionality and Accounting
Some weeks ago I had a good back-and-forth with the indomitable JKH in the forums about how useful Mosler's "paradigm shift" approach was vs JKHs "strictly the accounting" strategy. Mosler plays fast and loose with the language a little at time to better get his point across, and my position was (and remains) that if your goal is to knock people out of one way of thinking and into another, then sometimes you need to hit them over the head. But I don't think anyone has quite cracked that nut (no pun intended).
And yes, the term "paradigm shift" is grotesquely over and mis-used, but I think in term of MMT/PK vs standard academic economics, it is the correct term as we really are talking about taking an entire worldview, not just an isolated theory, and all of the implications that come with it; and jettisoning it for something else. This is a multiple-organ transplant procedure here, not a buttock lift, so roll up your sleeves.Conceptualization counts when one is bucking the mainstream model.
Winterspeak
Intentionality and Accounting
The Toughest Task For A Mob To Solve Is Selection Of An Adaptive Leader Rather Than Just A Tyrant
Commentary by Roger Erickson
Isn't it dumbfounding that the level of policy discussion in our country, has fallen so low - from top to bottom? What we're doing now is just embarrassing compared to what our grandparents were doing in the 1930s.
Maybe any remaining of our grandparents should step in and fire literally everyone younger than 90 from gov policy? Everyone younger seems afraid to do anything of any import. Yet it's more complicated than even that. "Milton Friedman’s misfortune is that his economic policies have been tried." Apparently, a few Luddite/Libertarian billionaires liked the general misfortune, and the rest is lobby & campaign-finance history, bought & sold.
Is there any rational comparison between Marriner Eccles in the 1930s and Larry Summers today?
Why such a stark change in the type of presidents and politicians we, the mob, select? In 1938 George Marshall spoke truth to FDR, and rather than being fired, was made Army Chief of Staff, whereupon he quickly fired what, 60-80% of the DoD Flag Officers? As a necessary prerequisite in mobilizing for looming challenges? [And even that was barely enough. We came within a hair's breadth of failing then, and could easily fail now, by other means! Hoover & FDR also launched the Reconstruction Finance Corporation, & conveyed the Pecora Commission, and hired Marriner Eccles among many other, practically aggressive measures. What have either Bush or Obama done except keep the inept in office? What happened to American audacity?]
There's a simple, stark question here. If, in 1938, we could once euthanize over half the DoD brass on a moment's notice, why don't we have an electorate able to select a Pres & Congress ... who have the wit and courage to recognize and hire competent people ... who can euthanize rentier industries which are more trouble than they're worth?
There's a very ancient & well known formula for productively mobilizing adaptive evolution of a mob or a nation, and we're actively avoiding it.
In fact, we're quite actively putting the crooked & inept in charge of keeping themselves out of jail. This could easily destroy the USA. It may have done so already, even if we don't know it yet.
The more I read about Hoover & FDR, the more it seems that they should be viewed as individuals separate from the bureaucracies they fought. Hoover started many things that FDR enlarged and added to. Luckily, they both did what they did ... over the nearly unanimous objection of both of both party bureaucracies. Their most stellar talent was listening to and hiring the few, most vocal, critics who actually made sense. That's a mark of wit, focus and composure.
It's alarming to consider how close the entire USA came to failing by 1932, and what might have happened subsequently if we had.
It's even more alarming to consider how close we are to failing by other means today, and how little, if anything, we're doing about it.
It seems that the toughest task for a mob to solve is selection of an adaptive leader rather than just a tyrant. That rarely happens. Our mob just in the USA today has nearly 3x the population of 1932. Is our group intelligence growing fast enough to keep selecting adaptive leaders from our rapidly growing mob? Not yet, obviously. Mob growth rate alone makes such selection harder every year. The quality of our selection methods is degrading, not accelerating.
And we're not even focused on that as our biggest task!!! Why is our entire government distracted to eavesdropping on trivia? Why aren't citizens eavesdropping on the level of policy discussion among themselves and those they elect to evaluate as leaders? Whatever our school systems are doing, they are not producing citizens who even ask the right questions. Because of that, we're in critically serious trouble.
Isn't it dumbfounding that the level of policy discussion in our country, has fallen so low - from top to bottom? What we're doing now is just embarrassing compared to what our grandparents were doing in the 1930s.
Maybe any remaining of our grandparents should step in and fire literally everyone younger than 90 from gov policy? Everyone younger seems afraid to do anything of any import. Yet it's more complicated than even that. "Milton Friedman’s misfortune is that his economic policies have been tried." Apparently, a few Luddite/Libertarian billionaires liked the general misfortune, and the rest is lobby & campaign-finance history, bought & sold.
Is there any rational comparison between Marriner Eccles in the 1930s and Larry Summers today?
Why such a stark change in the type of presidents and politicians we, the mob, select? In 1938 George Marshall spoke truth to FDR, and rather than being fired, was made Army Chief of Staff, whereupon he quickly fired what, 60-80% of the DoD Flag Officers? As a necessary prerequisite in mobilizing for looming challenges? [And even that was barely enough. We came within a hair's breadth of failing then, and could easily fail now, by other means! Hoover & FDR also launched the Reconstruction Finance Corporation, & conveyed the Pecora Commission, and hired Marriner Eccles among many other, practically aggressive measures. What have either Bush or Obama done except keep the inept in office? What happened to American audacity?]
There's a simple, stark question here. If, in 1938, we could once euthanize over half the DoD brass on a moment's notice, why don't we have an electorate able to select a Pres & Congress ... who have the wit and courage to recognize and hire competent people ... who can euthanize rentier industries which are more trouble than they're worth?
There's a very ancient & well known formula for productively mobilizing adaptive evolution of a mob or a nation, and we're actively avoiding it.
In fact, we're quite actively putting the crooked & inept in charge of keeping themselves out of jail. This could easily destroy the USA. It may have done so already, even if we don't know it yet.
The more I read about Hoover & FDR, the more it seems that they should be viewed as individuals separate from the bureaucracies they fought. Hoover started many things that FDR enlarged and added to. Luckily, they both did what they did ... over the nearly unanimous objection of both of both party bureaucracies. Their most stellar talent was listening to and hiring the few, most vocal, critics who actually made sense. That's a mark of wit, focus and composure.
It's alarming to consider how close the entire USA came to failing by 1932, and what might have happened subsequently if we had.
It's even more alarming to consider how close we are to failing by other means today, and how little, if anything, we're doing about it.
It seems that the toughest task for a mob to solve is selection of an adaptive leader rather than just a tyrant. That rarely happens. Our mob just in the USA today has nearly 3x the population of 1932. Is our group intelligence growing fast enough to keep selecting adaptive leaders from our rapidly growing mob? Not yet, obviously. Mob growth rate alone makes such selection harder every year. The quality of our selection methods is degrading, not accelerating.
And we're not even focused on that as our biggest task!!! Why is our entire government distracted to eavesdropping on trivia? Why aren't citizens eavesdropping on the level of policy discussion among themselves and those they elect to evaluate as leaders? Whatever our school systems are doing, they are not producing citizens who even ask the right questions. Because of that, we're in critically serious trouble.
Frank Rich — The Stench of the Potomac
Washington may be a dysfunctional place to govern, but it’s working better than ever as a marketplace for cashing in. And that’s thanks, more than anything, to the Democratic Establishment.New York Magazine
The Stench of the Potomac
Frank Rich
Hans-Joachim Voth, Nico Voigtländer, Shanker Satyanath — Bowling for Adolf: How social capital helped to destroy Germany’s first democracy
The collapse of the Weimar Republic was a turning point in world history, bringing the murderous Nazi regime to power. This column argues that contrary to most conceptions of social capital, there can be negative outcomes to well-connected societies. Independent of ideology, dense social networks in interwar Germany greatly helped the Nazi party to rapidly and widely disseminate its messages. Putnam’s claims about the benefits of social capital for democracy need to be reassessed.
Of course "social capital" can be used for good or bad. Just look at organized crime, as the authors cite. So social capital is somehow disadvantageous or dangerous, and people need to avoid organizing? Everyone is supposed to "think for themselves"? Out of context?
Physical capital can also be used for good and bad, depending on one's point of view. It was not social capital that made Hitler and the Nazis so dangerous to the world but Germany's physical capital that could be put to military use in producing armaments. Is physical capital therefore potentially negative. Of course. Does that undercut the argument for capitalism?
Social capital is defined as the economic potential of organization and information complexity is social systems. Physical capital is defined as the economic potential of the means of production in social systems. Financial capital is defined as the economic potential of money, credit and other financial arrangements in social systems. Economically, they are amoral to the degree that they are evaluated on money return. But monetary return is not the only consideration, even economically.
The use of the various forms of capital is not amoral from the societal standpoint in that evaluation of effectiveness in human affairs is broader than monetary and economics assumes this at least implicitly. All human societies are governed by law, and rights are key concepts in law. Rights are communal norms. Excluding non-monetary factors from consideration in effectiveness, e.g., limiting consideration to economic efficiency, is itself a normative judgement.
Vox.eu
Bowling for Adolf: How social capital helped to destroy Germany’s first democracy
Hans-Joachim Voth, Nico Voigtländer, Shanker Satyanath
(h/t Mark Thoma at Economist's View)
Bowling for Adolf: How social capital helped to destroy Germany’s first democracy
Hans-Joachim Voth, Nico Voigtländer, Shanker Satyanath
(h/t Mark Thoma at Economist's View)
Mark Buchanan — Why Homo Economicus Might Actually Be an Idiot
The findings could have important implications for policy makers. They suggest that institutions -- that is, the details that define how people interact -- have a big influence. The cooperative Homo socialis emerges only in the right institutional environment and can easily be exterminated by the wrong one. Institutions built on self-interest, such as corporate-governance rules that require executives to place the interests of shareholders over those of society, may perversely prevent more cooperation from emerging only because they take an outdated view of human behavior.
The take-home point is that Homo economicus is an oversimplified caricature who, in many situations, fails to benefit from real possibilities. Greed isn’t good, as Gordon Gekko famously said in the film “Wall Street.” In many cases, it’s not even very smart.
Neoclassical economics is based on methodological individualism — methodological atomism, really — that assumes that individuals are free agents acting rationally in maximizing utility. This supposedly results in the optimal resource allocation through efficiency of resource use guided by the invisible hand of the market through the profit motive and price discovery — the "butcher and baker" thing from Adam Smith.
On the other hand, systems thinkers and institutionalists counter that this is not representational. Reality doesn't work that way. Humans are social animals (as Aristotle observed millennia ago). They hunted in packs rather than as lone wolves, and they lived in communities, participating in community life. Social groups, from families, to clans, to tribes were nested in nations, as different levels of "society."
Activity in these groups as characterized by rituals (conventions, traditions), now called "culture," and formal arrangements now called institutions, such as the form of governance and method of adjudication of disputes, and shared education of the young. Human beings never lived alone, outside of social context, as free agents making decisions independently. The lone hunter is not a human evolutionary trait, as it is for most cat species, for instance. Models based on this myth are bound to fail representationally.
In addition, all wisdom traditions worldwide from time immemorial teach that pursuit of self-interest leads to moral decrepitude and spiritual decay of both individuals and societies, while following the Golden Rule leads to moral integrity and spiritual advancement. While economics in claiming to be a positive science holds that it is amoral, the reality is that utility maximization is not only not representational of humans, it is also normative, specifically license for anti-social behavior.
One of the most successful evolutionary traits is the ability to organize. A smaller but well-organized group will almost always best a larger but less-organized one in competition for resources. Life scientists call this "return on coordination." Even those who are most committed to the principle of maximizing self-interest — thieves — know that organized crime is much more lucrative than hunting alone, even if they have to divide the take.
Mark Buchanan is not an economist, but rather a "real" scientist — theoretical physicist actually. While 19th century physicists were atomists, and neoclassical economics was modeled on 19th century physics, contemporary scientists are system thinkers that look to information systems and energy flow rather than the motion of billiard balls in classical space and time. Conventional economists haven't caught up with the scientific world.
Moreover, the social Darwinism that underlies neoclassical economist misreads even Darwin at that time, and evolutionary theory has developed significantly since then. Again, conventional economists have not kept up, resembling priests and magicians more than contemporary scientists in their ideological commitment to myths long ago debunked.
The odd thing is that there is even any discussion about this. The rest of the scientific world has moved far past the 19th century while conventional economics remains mired in it. The business world has moved beyond it, too. This would be laughable in its stupidity, but it is a tragedy when applied to policy making. The only people more naive than conventional economists are politicians and billionaires advocating laissez-faire. Oh, wait. Maybe there is more to it than stupidity?
Bloomberg
Why Homo Economicus Might Actually Be an Idiot
Mark Buchanan
(h/t Mark Thoma at Economist's View)
Sunday, August 4, 2013
How Many Engineers [or economists] Learn Political Engineering, Not Just Physical Engineering [or mathematical modeling]?
Commentary by Roger Erickson
About the same proportion as that fraction of economists who ever learn much about actual banking and currency operations?
"1904, the Americans' first year in Panama, mirrored the French disaster. The chief engineer, John Findlay Wallace, neglected to organize the effort or to develop an action plan. The food was putrid, the living conditions abysmal. Political red tape put a stranglehold on appropriations. Disease struck, and three out of four Americans booked passage home. Engineer Wallace soon followed. The Americans had poured $128 million into the swamps of Panama, to damned little effect.
The arrival of Wallace's replacement, the rugged and ingenious John Stevens, marked a turn in fortunes for the beleaguered canal. Stevens had built the Great Northern Railroad across the Pacific Northwest. In rough territory from Canada to Mexico, he had proven his tenacity. And his new plan of action would ultimately save the canal.
The kind of work that needed done, Steven reasoned, could only be done by a well-housed, well-fed, disease-free labor force. Stevens began work not by not digging, but by cleaning.
The Panama Canal opened officially on August 15, 1914. The world scarcely noticed. German troops were driving across Belgium toward Paris; the newspapers relegated Panama to their back pages. The greatest engineering project in the history of the world had been dwarfed by the totality of World War I."
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/general-article/tr-panama/
About the same proportion as that fraction of economists who ever learn much about actual banking and currency operations?
"1904, the Americans' first year in Panama, mirrored the French disaster. The chief engineer, John Findlay Wallace, neglected to organize the effort or to develop an action plan. The food was putrid, the living conditions abysmal. Political red tape put a stranglehold on appropriations. Disease struck, and three out of four Americans booked passage home. Engineer Wallace soon followed. The Americans had poured $128 million into the swamps of Panama, to damned little effect.
The arrival of Wallace's replacement, the rugged and ingenious John Stevens, marked a turn in fortunes for the beleaguered canal. Stevens had built the Great Northern Railroad across the Pacific Northwest. In rough territory from Canada to Mexico, he had proven his tenacity. And his new plan of action would ultimately save the canal.
The kind of work that needed done, Steven reasoned, could only be done by a well-housed, well-fed, disease-free labor force. Stevens began work not by not digging, but by cleaning.
...
The Panama Canal opened officially on August 15, 1914. The world scarcely noticed. German troops were driving across Belgium toward Paris; the newspapers relegated Panama to their back pages. The greatest engineering project in the history of the world had been dwarfed by the totality of World War I."
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/general-article/tr-panama/
So why not regain a healthy, well-housed, well-fed, economic-disease-free Middle Class today, by cleaning up Wall St? Too distracted by Class War? ... Again?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)