Showing posts with label erratic Marxism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label erratic Marxism. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 10, 2015

Chris Dillow — Economists! Be more Marxist


Informative post with many links.

I would disagree this: "I'm not at all sure that capitalism has a tendency to ever-increasing monopoly." 

Monopoly and oligopoly power grows with consolidation and centralization. Moreover, class status and power that leads to political power which entrenches institutional power is also a strong force leading to monopoly and oligopoly rents. 

I would also question this: "And his idea that the working class would become an agent of revolutionary change has been wrong." 

It's not over until it's over. For example, liberals are sure that two hundred years of progress provides conclusive evidence that proves the success of the American experiment. The Chinese response is, Are you serious, only two hundred plus years? 

Marx thought that the workers revolution would not emerge until capitalism was globalized, that is, this moment of the historical dialectic was completed. But he also believed that the process could be forced by political activism and consciousness raising. So his hypotheses are not yet disproved by history. 

What would it take to disprove them. The eventual success of neoliberal capitalism locked in by political control. The jury is still out on this and significantly formerly Marxist Russia and presently Marxist China have allied to make sure it doesn't happen.

Stumbling and Mumbling
Economists! Be more MarxistChris Dillow | Investors Chronicle