An economics, investment, trading and policy blog with a focus on Modern Monetary Theory (MMT). We seek the truth, avoid the mainstream and are virulently anti-neoliberalism.
Friday, August 9, 2013
Yves Smith — Questioning the Underlying Structures of Property and Power is “Off the Table”
Cuts to the chase. Economics is fundamentally about power. Discussion of power, like money, is off-limits in conventional economics.
Money and power are the essence of capitalism, and conventional economics is a myth rationalizing "primitive accumulation" of private property aka expropriation and exploitation.
Naked Capitalism
Questioning the Underlying Structures of Property and Power is “Off the Table”
Yves Smith
Bill Black — Teaching White-Collar Crime
If you never read anything else by Bill Black, please read this and share it widely. It is an excellent summary of Bill's work in documenting control fraud by CEOs as the primary cause of the US financial crisis, and also why nothing has been done about it.
New Economic Perspectives
Teaching White-Collar Crime
William K Black | Associate Professor of Economics and Law at the University of Missouri – Kansas City
Bill Mitchell — The IS-LM Framework – Part 3
I am now using Friday’s blog space to provide draft versions of the Modern Monetary Theory textbook that I am writing with my colleague and friend Randy Wray. We expect to complete the text during 2013 (to be ready in draft form for second semester teaching). Comments are always welcome. Remember this is a textbook aimed at undergraduate students and so the writing will be different from my usual blog free-for-all. Note also that the text I post is just the work I am doing by way of the first draft so the material posted will not represent the complete text. Further it will change once the two of us have edited it.
Previous Parts to this Chapter:
▪ The IS-LM Framework – Part 1 ▪ The IS-LM Framework – Part 2
Chapter 16 – The IS-LM Framework
Bill Mitchell – billy blog
The IS-LM Framework – Part 3
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), Charles Darwin University, Northern Territory, Australia
Labels:
IS-LM,
ISLM,
MMT,
MMT textbook,
Randy Wray
Lockheed Martin is a "Good Investment Target" For Private Investors?
Commentary by Roger Erickson
F-35B STOVL LRIP-5 SHOCKER !
Yet Lockheed Martin's concurrency shop of horrors is considered a "good investment target" for private investors? Touted so by many professional asset managers?
Exactly which kinds of investors and investment advisers? Those that want to briefly hoard fiat, while the country that issues that fiat collapses?
What the hell kind of investment strategy is that?
The kind that Robert Morris would have made? I'll take George Washington's balanced investment strategy over Robert Morris' any day. Absolutely insist on balanced investment in both Democracy PLUS Person - always. Otherwise, neither is sustainable.
You can't lose track of whole + components, especially their interdependencies. They're inseparable, even in private investing.
To write the US Constitution and make a sound investment in the future of our people, we once combined our analyses of sustainable outcomes, common sense, and even morals with short term asset management.
That is, wholistic treatment of dynamic as well as static asset management.
How'd we get away from that combined approach? Is it too late to back up and start thinking more deeply?
Isn't it still true that an ounce of cheap prevention is soon worth more than a pound of expensive repair - always?
Can we invest just a wee bit more in preventing further degradation of the US culture our ancestors worked so brilliantly to start? Maybe even get around to carefully seeing if we can ADD to the brilliance we once demonstrated, not just chip away at it, and consume our own country?
F-35B STOVL LRIP-5 SHOCKER !
Yet Lockheed Martin's concurrency shop of horrors is considered a "good investment target" for private investors? Touted so by many professional asset managers?
Exactly which kinds of investors and investment advisers? Those that want to briefly hoard fiat, while the country that issues that fiat collapses?
What the hell kind of investment strategy is that?
The kind that Robert Morris would have made? I'll take George Washington's balanced investment strategy over Robert Morris' any day. Absolutely insist on balanced investment in both Democracy PLUS Person - always. Otherwise, neither is sustainable.
You can't lose track of whole + components, especially their interdependencies. They're inseparable, even in private investing.
To write the US Constitution and make a sound investment in the future of our people, we once combined our analyses of sustainable outcomes, common sense, and even morals with short term asset management.
That is, wholistic treatment of dynamic as well as static asset management.
How'd we get away from that combined approach? Is it too late to back up and start thinking more deeply?
Isn't it still true that an ounce of cheap prevention is soon worth more than a pound of expensive repair - always?
Can we invest just a wee bit more in preventing further degradation of the US culture our ancestors worked so brilliantly to start? Maybe even get around to carefully seeing if we can ADD to the brilliance we once demonstrated, not just chip away at it, and consume our own country?
Even An Overflowing Crock Eventually Drips A Terse, Accurate Summary?
Commentary by Roger Erickson
Russ Huntley writes: "And damn me, but isn't that a perfect description of cause and effect?"
Why we can kiss the US economy goodbye
Actually, it's an even better illustration & demonstration than it is description.
Why, it nearly mirrors reality!
Makes you wonder what their lobbyists finally looked at, to arrive at the suggestion & order for this particular editorial. The image finally loomed so large that they could no longer see the start of the triggering causality chains?
That's the built in beauty of all biological systems. If they stumble along long enough, they eventually mirror enough context data ... to see themselves in it.
What happens after that is a crap shoot. Depends on whether they recognize their own fingerprints, or just look only for someone else's.
Ask not on whom the crock drips?
It drips on you? (And yours.)
Russ Huntley writes: "And damn me, but isn't that a perfect description of cause and effect?"
Why we can kiss the US economy goodbye
Actually, it's an even better illustration & demonstration than it is description.
Why, it nearly mirrors reality!
Makes you wonder what their lobbyists finally looked at, to arrive at the suggestion & order for this particular editorial. The image finally loomed so large that they could no longer see the start of the triggering causality chains?
That's the built in beauty of all biological systems. If they stumble along long enough, they eventually mirror enough context data ... to see themselves in it.
What happens after that is a crap shoot. Depends on whether they recognize their own fingerprints, or just look only for someone else's.
Ask not on whom the crock drips?
It drips on you? (And yours.)
Thursday, August 8, 2013
Conservatives Used to Mock Ayn Rand -- How Did She Become a Hero to Right-Wing Nerds Everywhere?
Today's doltish conservatives, like Paul Ryan, worship her. But their forebears called Rand's work "preposterous"AlterNet
Conservatives Used to Mock Ayn Rand -- How Did She Become a Hero to Right-Wing Nerds Everywhere?
Michael Lind | Salon
Matias Vernengo — On Austrians and the natural rate of interest
...So, yes Austrians do have a natural rate**, even if they don't know it. Note that the capital debates show exactly that the idea of natural rate of interest inversely related with capital abundance (supply and demand) is not tenable. The poetry on market efficiency depends on being able to prove that. That's why the neoclassical project, and with it Austrians, have been derailed. It is really zombie economics.
** According to Garegnani, in fact, even the inter-temporal Arrow-Debreu models, which supposedly do not have a uniform rate of profit, require a natural rate of interest to bring about the equilibrium of investment with full employment savings.Naked Keynesianism
On Austrians and the natural rate of interest
Matias Vernengo | Associate Professor of Economics, University of Utah
J. Bradford DeLong — Paul Krugman: What Janet Yellen--And Everyone Else--Got Wrong
No, Professor Krugman, "everyone" did not get it wrong. Only the Very Serious People, whom you apparently regard as "everyone."
Grasping Reality...
Paul Krugman: What Janet Yellen--And Everyone Else--Got Wrong
J. Bradford DeLong | Professor of Economics, UCAL Berkeley
Labels:
GFC,
Janet Yellin,
MMT,
Paul Krugman
Furthering my point from yesterday...
http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/08/08/209878158/egypt-may-not-need-fighter-jets-but-u-s-keeps-sending-them-anyway?utm_source=npr&utm_medium=facebook&utm_campaign=20130808
"In all, the U.S. sent more than 1,000 tanks to Egypt since then — valued at some $3.9 billion — which Egypt maintains along with several thousand Soviet-era tanks. "There's no conceivable scenario in which they'd need all those tanks short of an alien invasion," Shana Marshall of the Institute of Middle East Studies at George Washington University, told me"
....
"In fact, he said, at least 200 of the tanks the U.S. has sent to Egypt have never been used. "They are crated up and then they sit in deep storage, and that's where they remain...""
Why Won't the Federal Reserve & Treasury Establish an Insider Threat Program Too?
Commentary by Roger Erickson
As usual, the DoD is way ahead of other public agencies, and setting examples for others to follow. In contrast, the best our present Congress can do is protect Bowles & Simpson's misnamed "Insider Teat Program" designed to protect Corporate Welfare. Talk about a fraud in creep's clothing!
Okay, if we're gonna talk faux modesty here, which threat was responsible for 3 recessions since 1999, including both the largest loss AND TRANSFER of GDP in our history? While we're at it, why hasn't our electorate establish an insider threat program, and used it to remove all the frauds, crooks & bozos from Congress, SCOTUS & POTUS ... or keep 'em from getting there in the 1st place?
All it would require would be a bit of virtual exercise of the space between ears. Don't tell me there's an insider threat program keeping anything significant from penetrating that space too? Code named "Heritage Foundation?" That would explain a lot. [Or is it "No Child Left Behind?" There are redundant "reduncencies," you know.]
Consider us already amply warned. Our own cross-talk constitutes a citizen's insider threat program. Next step is to start listening to our own warnings?
With that step under our belts, rather than tripping ourselves, we could actually turn to some emerging Operational Opportunity Programs? Wow. That sounds novel, fun and enticing. Actually looking forward to an OOPs program? You wish!
To protect us from absolute frauds like Robert Rubin & Larry Summers - not to mention the long list from Alan Greenspan all the way back to his previous employer Charles Keating, and the Keating-5? Instead, just pull a TARP over it all?
Control Frauds. The Mother of all Insider Threats.
Army Establishes Insider Threat Program?
Control Frauds. The Mother of all Insider Threats.
Army Establishes Insider Threat Program?
As usual, the DoD is way ahead of other public agencies, and setting examples for others to follow. In contrast, the best our present Congress can do is protect Bowles & Simpson's misnamed "Insider Teat Program" designed to protect Corporate Welfare. Talk about a fraud in creep's clothing!
Okay, if we're gonna talk faux modesty here, which threat was responsible for 3 recessions since 1999, including both the largest loss AND TRANSFER of GDP in our history? While we're at it, why hasn't our electorate establish an insider threat program, and used it to remove all the frauds, crooks & bozos from Congress, SCOTUS & POTUS ... or keep 'em from getting there in the 1st place?
All it would require would be a bit of virtual exercise of the space between ears. Don't tell me there's an insider threat program keeping anything significant from penetrating that space too? Code named "Heritage Foundation?" That would explain a lot. [Or is it "No Child Left Behind?" There are redundant "reduncencies," you know.]
Consider us already amply warned. Our own cross-talk constitutes a citizen's insider threat program. Next step is to start listening to our own warnings?
With that step under our belts, rather than tripping ourselves, we could actually turn to some emerging Operational Opportunity Programs? Wow. That sounds novel, fun and enticing. Actually looking forward to an OOPs program? You wish!
In your dreams, America! Has some insider been threatening you every time you harbor dreams for the Middle Class? Forbidden dreams like reducing the Output Gap, a bias to action in every child, and two options in every citizens toolkit? Please turn to page 1 of your External Luddite & Control Fraud Defense Program manual ... and vote da bums out. All of them. Even your local party guy.
John Carney — An outdated monetary policy model stirs fears of Fed policy
John Carney debunks the myths about reserves, money supply, bank lending, and inflation. Will will the people who need to hear it, like Rick Santelli and the Zero Hedgies, read it?
CNBC NetNet
An outdated monetary policy model stirs fears of Fed policy
John Carney | Senior Editor
John Carney | Senior Editor
This Actually Crosses The Line ... To An Outright Lie
Commentary by Roger Erickson
Fannie Mae sending $10.2 billion to taxpayers as profit swells
Come again? Is this an anti-SETI message from the R U Sirius? One can't get much more misleading than that statement.
FM may as well mail that fiat currency credit off to a black hole somewhere?
No taxpayer will ever even detect that the returning fiat existed.
For the occasional WalMart & Harvard Econ, novice readers here ... you know, the issuer of fiat don't need to get no fiat back? ...
Fannie Mae sending $10.2 billion to taxpayers as profit swells
Come again? Is this an anti-SETI message from the R U Sirius? One can't get much more misleading than that statement.
FM may as well mail that fiat currency credit off to a black hole somewhere?
No taxpayer will ever even detect that the returning fiat existed.
For the occasional WalMart & Harvard Econ, novice readers here ... you know, the issuer of fiat don't need to get no fiat back? ...
Is that the appropriate speech pattern? Does it contain just enough, but not too many, doubly ideological negatives? Move along folks, nothing either inflated or deflated here except some intellects.
ps: Where do we FIND these people who believe that we're running out of fiat? Among graduates of our fine schools? :( BMHOTK! AND Double Face Palm! This is triggering all known shades of dismay.
ps: Where do we FIND these people who believe that we're running out of fiat? Among graduates of our fine schools? :( BMHOTK! AND Double Face Palm! This is triggering all known shades of dismay.
That, and maybe journalists on the pay of mobsters & Control Frauds? Anyone know whether this reporter, Margaret Chadbourn, has prior experience in the Big House? Or has any ... paying ... contacts there? Giving such people the benefit of the doubt, and assuming that they're frauds is actually less demeaning to their intellects. One has to take the high road in such instances, and appeal to ego over morals. They may be crooks & junior Control Frauds, but they're OUR crooks & Control Frauds. And damn clever ones too!!!
ps: ps: Where's Darth Libellius when we'd actually settle for fighting Dark Side with Dark Side?
Rowena Mason — David Cameron eyes Human Rights Act repeal
Prime minister says Conservative-only government would be able to take 'more sensible steps' on human rights legislationThe Guardian
David Cameron eyes Human Rights Act repeal
Rowena Mason | Political Correspondent
Human rights getting in the way of property rights?
The basic principle of conservatism is, "Some people are better than others." The basic principle of liberalism is, "All people are created equal."
What is Nick Clegg doing associating with David Cameron?
Radley Balko — Shot to Death by Police for Betting on a Football Game? The Rise of Paramilitary Force in America
Heavily armed SWAT teams are increasingly used for such small tasks as raiding poker games and trying to stop underage drinking. How did we get here?AlterNet
Shot to Death by Police for Betting on a Football Game? The Rise of Paramilitary Force in America
Radley Balko
And you wonder why Libertarians are doing well politically?
Jullian Berman — The Rich Are Hoarding Cash And It's Making Us A Lot Worse Off: Experts
America's top 1 percent saved their money at a rate of 37 percent last quarter, according to a recent survey from American Express Publishing and the Harrison Group highlighted by CNBC. That means that during that period, wealthy Americans put away about 37 cents for every dollar they earned, which is more than triple their savings rate in 2007. In addition, a Bank of America study cited in the CNBC report found that more than half of millionaires have a "substantial" amount of cash on hand and of that group, about 60 percent said they didn't plan to invest it in the next two years.
As the recovery struggles to gain solid ground, the findings indicate that even while America's wealthiest households are taking home a larger share than ever of the income pie, they're doing little to put that money to productive use in the economy, experts say. One possible solution: raising taxes on the rich.The Huffington Post
The Rich Are Hoarding Cash And It's Making Us A Lot Worse Off: Experts
Jullian Berman
Simon Wren-Lewis — Bringing economics back into fiscal policymaking
The farce continues. As Simon Wren-Lewis observes, it's about coming up with a better narrative politically. What he does not say is "in opposing the false neoliberal narrative."
Mainly Macro
Bringing economics back into fiscal policymaking
Simon Wren-Lewis | Professor of Economics, Oxford University
Raghuram Rajan — The Paranoid Style in Economics
Yikes. Rajan thinks that R&R just made a coding error and are correct about higher public debt being correlated with slower growth, with the level of debt the causal factor. I guess he didn't bother reading the "heterodox" critique. Poor India.
Project syndicate
The Paranoid Style in Economics
Raghuram Rajan | Professor of Finance at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business, incoming Governor of the Reserve Bank of India.
Lord Keynes — Austrians and the Definition of “Inflation”
Certain Austrians are running to defend their idiosyncratic definition of “inflation” as an increase in the money supply, instead of (as people normally use it) a general increase in prices.Social Democracy For The 21St Century: A Post Keynesian Perspective
Austrians and the Definition of “Inflation”
Lord Keynes
My view is that the term "inflation" is ambiguous and also charged with connotation as to obscure the denotation, whether by technical definition or use in ordinary language contexts. Therefore, "inflation" should be relegated to the dustbin of history as archaic and no longer useful in current discourse.
Peter Radford — Some thoughts on economics
My instinctive entry point into economics is through business....
Economics as it exists today in its mainstream form is of no use whatever to anyone seeking to understand the reality of business. Our extant theories of the firm are failures in that they attempt to see the world through a neoclassical lens whilst that lens obscures anything remotely real from view in an effort to retain the equilibrating perfection of the closed system envisaged by Walras. The contradiction between the pursuit of equilibrium explanations and the open ended nature of the real world defeats neoclassicism at the starting gate and dooms it to subsequent nonsensical irrelevance....
In this context I have to attribute a great honor to the Arrow-Debreu effort to complete the Walrasian episode. Arrow-Debreu deserves our constant indebtedness. It shows, definitively, how the Walrasian tradition cannot be an explanation for a real economy. It achieves completion by imposing such horrendously, and obviously, unreal constraints on itself that it proves Walras wrong. It is thus great science. It is the falsification of a tradition shown to be worthless.
On another matter: mainstream economists have never adequately, in my opinion, responded to Coase’s challenge of 1937. He asked simply: if markets do what classical economists and their followers say they do, why do firms exist? They ought not. That they do suggests something is very wrong at the heart of orthodox thinking. So I add the ‘Coase conundrum’ to Arrow-Debreu as adding weight to the critique. Mainstream economics is alchemy....
Asymmetrical information is another challenge to orthodoxy that is too often ignored. Information about things is patchy in the real world. Very patchy. It is non-existent with regard to the medium and long term future. Yet this never deters the neoclassical theorists. They march along as if asymmetry was an inconvenience that can be assumed away for simplicity’s sake, rather than a dagger in the heart of their work....
Uncertainty and complexity characterize the real world. Certainty and simplicity characterize neoclassical economics. Hence it irrelevance. It is complicated though, as Arrow-Debreu shows. It has to be. Its epicycles weigh it down. But no amount of clever formalism can turn unreality into reality, just as lead is pretty tough to turn into gold. This doesn’t mean that neoclassical economist aren’t very bright. They are. They have to be to to tend to those epicycles. Newton, after all, spent more time on alchemy than on recognizable physics. No indeed, they are very bright. Just wrong.Real-World Economics Review Blog
Some thoughts on economics
Peter Radford
Peter Radford
This is a seminal article. Not much that we haven't said hundreds of time on this blog and in the comments, but Peter Radford ties it together very nicely — concise, precise and clear.
Note also that what is said about economics, order and entropy wrt to management also applies wrt to governing, and as Norbert Weinberg observes in naming cybernetics. It's also the basis of general system theory developed by economist Kenneth Boulding and others from related fields who understood the fundamental role of information in imposing order and overcoming entropy. See A Curriculum for Cybernetics and Systems Theory by Alan B. Scrivener for a summary of the basics.
Why don't conventional economists read this stuff, or if they do, why don't they use it?
Note also that what is said about economics, order and entropy wrt to management also applies wrt to governing, and as Norbert Weinberg observes in naming cybernetics. It's also the basis of general system theory developed by economist Kenneth Boulding and others from related fields who understood the fundamental role of information in imposing order and overcoming entropy. See A Curriculum for Cybernetics and Systems Theory by Alan B. Scrivener for a summary of the basics.
Why don't conventional economists read this stuff, or if they do, why don't they use it?
Where I would quibble with Radford is over his assertion,
"The substitution of labor for capital or vice versa tells us that neither if fundamental. The energy and skill are. Energy and knowledge deployed to order resources for subsequent disordering. That’s the economic process."Is he forgetting that capital goods are also produced by labor? Labor is basic until capital goods can produce capital goods and innovate while doing so. That level of AI is still in the dream stage of development, and even then it seems that knowledge workers will still be required in the Age of Artificial Intelligence.
Lord Keynes — Early Fiat Money in China
China’s earliest historical experiment with paper money is certainly interesting. I am dealing here with the experiments under the Song dynasty (960–1279 AD)....
The Sichuan regional government made qianyin fiat money its monetary standard for tax payments and expenditure, which, as Chartalism and Modern Monetary Theory would predict, stabilised its private sector value and use in exchange (Glahn 2005: 72).Social Democracy For The 21St Century: A Post Keynesian Perspective
Early Fiat Money in China
Lord Keynes
Yves Smith — So Why is the Administration Trying to Look a Smidge More Aggressive About Going After Banks?
In the last few days, the Department of Justice (as well as the SEC) filed a case against Bank of America over a 2008 prime mortgage securitization that takes breaks some new ground in fraud allegations and is also saber-rattling in the form of launching a criminal investigation into JP Morgan’s sale of mortgage backed securities.
So what’s with the new-found religion? The Snowden effect? Perhaps, but given that cases take a while to gin up, this may be Holder trying to rebuild what little he has left in the way of a reputation after confirming remarks made by others in his office that some animals, um, banks, were more equal than others. [allusion to George Orwell's Animal Farm]....
It’s inconceivable that the DoJ would indict JP Morgan at a corporate level. Not only would Holder not risk destabilizing the bank, there’s simply no way the Treasury would let him go there. If any actual criminal charges are contemplated (remember, this is just an investigation), expect a rerun of the UBS Libor strategy, where UBS paid a large fine for Libor rigging and admitted to criminal conduct…in its Japanese unit. I’d be delighted to be proven wrong, but there’s no reason to expect anything other than new and better optics from the Obama Administration at this late date.Naked Capitalism
So Why is the Administration Trying to Look a Smidge More Aggressive About Going After Banks?
Yves Smith
Labels:
DOJ,
Eric Holder,
MMT,
TBTF,
TBTJ
Mark Thoma — What is driving changes in the job market?
A recession causes a corresponding drop in demand for goods and services. In such a cyclical downturn, policymakers can help by replacing the lost demand. But if the changes are structural, such as when unemployment is due to skill mismatches, technological advances, or changes in what people purchase that require resources to be reallocated, policymakers are far less able to help.
So an important question is whether the labor market is being hampered by demand-side cyclical problems, or supply-side structural issues....
The main takeaway is that contrary to speculation about technological change and part-time work, most of the variation is part-time employment appears to be cyclical rather than structural.
That's good news: it means policymakers, if they choose to, could use fiscal as well as monetary policy to bolster the recovery of the labor market.Market Watch
What is driving changes in the job market?
Mark Thoma | Professor of Economics, University of Oregon Eugene
Wednesday, August 7, 2013
Frank S. Dohen — Transcendental Nonsense And The Functional Approach - Columbia Law Review
Rohan Grey: I have probably shared this before, but I highly recommend this legal paper for those who haven't read it - it's the legal functionalist response to Lerner's functional finance.
Frank S. Dohen
Transcendental Nonsense And The Functional Approach
Columbia Law Review Vol. XXXV June, 1935 No. 6
CJ Polychroniou — Austerity's Failure in Greece: Time to Think the Unthinkable?
Further austerity can only worsen Greece's economic plight, particularly already-catastrophic unemployment, warns Dimitri B. Papadimitriou, president of the Levy Economics Institute, according to the Institute's macro-economic model. But "unthinkable" economic policies - suggested by conservative and progressive economists alike - could.Truthout Interview
Austerity's Failure in Greece: Time to Think the Unthinkable?
CJ Polychroniou | President of the Levy Economics Institute
Brahma Chellaney — The Battle for Water
The sharpening international geopolitical competition over natural resources has turned some strategic resources into engines of power struggle. Transnational water resources have become an especially active source of competition and conflict, triggering a dam-building race and prompting growing calls for the United Nations to recognize water as a key security concern.Project Syndicate
The Battle for Water
Brahma Chellaney | Professor of Strategic Studies at the New Delhi-based Center for Policy Research
Zaid Jilani — Exposing the Real Politics of Jeff Bezos: Privatization, Big Business, Lower Taxes on the Rich—Is That the Future of the Washington Post?
Like so many tech billionaires, Bezos is attracted to right-libertarian politics.AlterNet
Exposing the Real Politics of Jeff Bezos: Privatization, Big Business, Lower Taxes on the Rich—Is That the Future of the Washington Post?
Zaid Jilani
Can the US take another
"Fighting" inflation
Some quick thoughts on inflation:
Perhaps an area where modern monetary economics could grow into is about what to spend money on. While MMT states that the federal government's only spending constraint is its ability to cause inflation, I think we should go a little further and explain how and when that could happen.
For example, I think there is tremendous opportunity in making the argument of how our massive military spending does not cause inflation. We now spend over a trillion dollars a year on military, defense, and national security related items. This "welfare state for engineers and computer geeks" is money spent by the government that does not result in any commensurate production of goods and services to absorb to the new spending. Most of what this spending creates are intangible items such as "security"; what physical items it does produce are mostly either consumed abroad (bombs and bullets in wars), or not really used at all (ships, planes, all the other array of high-tech vehicles that we pay millions to design, billions to produce, whiz around the world a few times and then dump in the New Mexico desert). Then, when we spend trillions to pay all the millions of DoD, CIA, NSA, and DHS employees and their contractors, they take this money and use it to consume other goods and services in the American economy, without having produced any of their own for other people to consume. So at least half of what the federal government does is produce low-utility military surplus, and even this does not produce much inflation!
This gives you a sense of how truly large the American economy is, and how much more domestic spending we could be doing. In fact, if anything domestic spending would produce even lower levels of inflation than defense spending, because unlike defense spending, domestic spending does produce a commensurate increase in goods and services for its new dollars to consume. Some government investments, especially infrastructure and education, have enormous returns in the form of future efficiency and productivity. So as long as the new money spent by the government (injection of Net base money) is accompanied by an equal increase in the amount of goods and services available for consumption, there will be no inflation!! In fact, because the modern American economy is so efficient, it may be possible for the money supply to increase, and the price level to actually stay the same or go down! Ha! Take that gold buggers!
Perhaps an area where modern monetary economics could grow into is about what to spend money on. While MMT states that the federal government's only spending constraint is its ability to cause inflation, I think we should go a little further and explain how and when that could happen.
For example, I think there is tremendous opportunity in making the argument of how our massive military spending does not cause inflation. We now spend over a trillion dollars a year on military, defense, and national security related items. This "welfare state for engineers and computer geeks" is money spent by the government that does not result in any commensurate production of goods and services to absorb to the new spending. Most of what this spending creates are intangible items such as "security"; what physical items it does produce are mostly either consumed abroad (bombs and bullets in wars), or not really used at all (ships, planes, all the other array of high-tech vehicles that we pay millions to design, billions to produce, whiz around the world a few times and then dump in the New Mexico desert). Then, when we spend trillions to pay all the millions of DoD, CIA, NSA, and DHS employees and their contractors, they take this money and use it to consume other goods and services in the American economy, without having produced any of their own for other people to consume. So at least half of what the federal government does is produce low-utility military surplus, and even this does not produce much inflation!
This gives you a sense of how truly large the American economy is, and how much more domestic spending we could be doing. In fact, if anything domestic spending would produce even lower levels of inflation than defense spending, because unlike defense spending, domestic spending does produce a commensurate increase in goods and services for its new dollars to consume. Some government investments, especially infrastructure and education, have enormous returns in the form of future efficiency and productivity. So as long as the new money spent by the government (injection of Net base money) is accompanied by an equal increase in the amount of goods and services available for consumption, there will be no inflation!! In fact, because the modern American economy is so efficient, it may be possible for the money supply to increase, and the price level to actually stay the same or go down! Ha! Take that gold buggers!
C.P. Chandrasekhar and Jayati Ghosh — Do wage shares have to fall with globalisation?
So the conclusion must be that — while globalisation certainly unleashes forces that reduce labour’s relative power and tends to reduce labour shares of national income — this outcome is not inevitable. It can be countered by progressive economic policies that work actively to shift both the growth strategy and current public fiscal policies in favour of workers (including both wage workers and the self-employed). In a world in which economic inequalities are becoming a matter of increasing political concern, this lesson is absolutely critical.The Hindu — Business Line
Do wage shares have to fall with globalisation?
C.P. Chandrasekhar, Professor of Economics, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi and Jayati Ghosh, Professor of Economics and Chairperson at the Centre for Economic Studies and Planning, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi
(h/t Yves Smith at Naked Captialism)
See also
Naked Capitalism
C.P. Chandrasekhar and Jayati Ghosh: The Great Jobs Disaster
C.P. Chandrasekhar, Professor of Economics, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi and Jayati Ghosh, Professor of Economics and Chairperson at the Centre for Economic Studies and Planning, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi
Miracle Middle Class Self-Defense Weapon: Take Out a Virtual 2x4, And Bludgeon The SocSec Debate Back To A Semblance Of Reality
Commentary by Roger Erickson
"When you come across a group of people, digging themselves into a hole, and offer to help ... they'll invariably ask you to jump in and help them dig!" [Folk wisdom.]
Several essays from The Polemicist blog illustrate this point - regarding the madness associated with Social Security debates.
TP is a progressive blog reportedly written by Jim Kavanagh, and it certainly does tp a wide range of Luddite illogic masquerading as public policy.
Kavanagh's heart and mind certainly seem directed towards serving public purpose. However, this particular policy battlefield of SocSec, like all battlefields, is clouded with the fog of war, where subterfuge, feint and counter-feint are the rule, and where survival always tracks internal pursuit of indirection while successfully misdirecting opponents.
Therefore, in the final analysis, it's not clear that all of Jim Kavanagh's messages on SocSec help any more than they hurt. Targeting the topic is a necessary but not sufficient start, but we simply have to do better, in order to preserve our nation and help the US Middle Class survive. It's a long, drawn out Class War after all, not just one Pyrrhic battle.
If you read this original memo, re Luther Gulick & SocSec, you'll see clearly that everything that even Kavanagh says is hopelessly out of paradigm. It's therefore very confusing - which is of course, dangerous. Even a moment of confusion can be fatal in any conflict, including in politics, policy and Class War.
What is the source of SocSec confusion?
Opponents of the Middle Class created an enormous Straw Man at the very start - see Gulick's memo on the unnecessary invention of political FICA taxes. Proponents of SocSec not only acquiesced in this initial calamity, they then compounded their mistake and let that Straw Man propagate and multiply. Eventually, the GOP successfully used the multitude of Straw Arguments to keep the electorate hopelessly confused, divided & conquered on what is actually a very simple topic.
In the end, SocSec is simply another public policy, no different from highways, NASA, DoD, the Arts, etc, etc, etc. All the nitpicking details Kavanagh is tied up exploring, dissecting and selectively refuting are smoke and mirrors ... EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM!
We can't win by accepting use of our opponents terms and semantics in this debate!
Invariably, those who are allowed to frame the terms of a debate, have already won. Marriner Eccles himself constantly referred to this hard lesson, learned in his early years in public policy. Those who get the right to introduce the "1st draft" have every opportunity to own the subsequent policy direction!
Jane and Joe Sixpack, it is long past time to get out your logic 2x4, and bludgeon this debate back to a sensible 1st draft. Please set it to one we can build public purpose on, not just Class War.
If not? Then you may as well give up. Accepting the GOP terms & semantics on SocSec discussions is a total waste of time. It constitutes capitulation up front. If you want to shape this twisted situation, just cut 'em off at the pass. Cut right through the Gordian Knotheads, and absolutely insist on keeping the premise of the discussion focused on a semblance of reality - not on Straw Man details.
Otherwise, you may as well submit to discussing how many economists can dance on a downtrodden pinhead named Joe Sixpack!
Why would we bother putting fiat in reserve? What does that even mean? Is it pure sophistry? How COULD we do so even if we wanted to? What on earth are they even talking about? Are they simply baffling us with bullshit? YA THINK?!!
Fiat is, after all, a euphemism for Public Initiative. As always, initiative put off is initiative lost forever. Please turn the discussion away from nonsensical smoke & mirrors like Trust Funds and Tax Rates, and return it to the only parameters we can actually benefit from - as we do for all other public policies. Let's keep the discussion focused on the TANGIBLE, OPERATIONAL CAPABILITIES of current & future electorates, and ways to productively minimize their Output Gaps. Either you use your 2x4 on frauds, or they use their 2x4 on you. There's no benefit from stalemate, only endless economic bruises and loss of National Security.
Even participating in a discussion about squirreling away public initiative (aka, fiat) in mythical "reserved fiat" accounts is insanely inane. Economists actually have a formal term for such insanity - "Demand Leakages." It's still an insane topic to even focus on. The fact that we're discussing such euphemisms at all is our best metric for how dumb, confused, divided and self-conquered we are.
Instead, let's just demand a stop to logic leaks, and focus on building real capabilities and tangible capacity? Can we just be positive, not negative?
For Pete's sake! There is a better way. Let's just get back to American ingenuity? Please? Right now?
"When you come across a group of people, digging themselves into a hole, and offer to help ... they'll invariably ask you to jump in and help them dig!" [Folk wisdom.]
Several essays from The Polemicist blog illustrate this point - regarding the madness associated with Social Security debates.
TP is a progressive blog reportedly written by Jim Kavanagh, and it certainly does tp a wide range of Luddite illogic masquerading as public policy.
Kavanagh's heart and mind certainly seem directed towards serving public purpose. However, this particular policy battlefield of SocSec, like all battlefields, is clouded with the fog of war, where subterfuge, feint and counter-feint are the rule, and where survival always tracks internal pursuit of indirection while successfully misdirecting opponents.
Therefore, in the final analysis, it's not clear that all of Jim Kavanagh's messages on SocSec help any more than they hurt. Targeting the topic is a necessary but not sufficient start, but we simply have to do better, in order to preserve our nation and help the US Middle Class survive. It's a long, drawn out Class War after all, not just one Pyrrhic battle.
If you read this original memo, re Luther Gulick & SocSec, you'll see clearly that everything that even Kavanagh says is hopelessly out of paradigm. It's therefore very confusing - which is of course, dangerous. Even a moment of confusion can be fatal in any conflict, including in politics, policy and Class War.
What is the source of SocSec confusion?
Opponents of the Middle Class created an enormous Straw Man at the very start - see Gulick's memo on the unnecessary invention of political FICA taxes. Proponents of SocSec not only acquiesced in this initial calamity, they then compounded their mistake and let that Straw Man propagate and multiply. Eventually, the GOP successfully used the multitude of Straw Arguments to keep the electorate hopelessly confused, divided & conquered on what is actually a very simple topic.
In the end, SocSec is simply another public policy, no different from highways, NASA, DoD, the Arts, etc, etc, etc. All the nitpicking details Kavanagh is tied up exploring, dissecting and selectively refuting are smoke and mirrors ... EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM!
We can't win by accepting use of our opponents terms and semantics in this debate!
Invariably, those who are allowed to frame the terms of a debate, have already won. Marriner Eccles himself constantly referred to this hard lesson, learned in his early years in public policy. Those who get the right to introduce the "1st draft" have every opportunity to own the subsequent policy direction!
Jane and Joe Sixpack, it is long past time to get out your logic 2x4, and bludgeon this debate back to a sensible 1st draft. Please set it to one we can build public purpose on, not just Class War.
If not? Then you may as well give up. Accepting the GOP terms & semantics on SocSec discussions is a total waste of time. It constitutes capitulation up front. If you want to shape this twisted situation, just cut 'em off at the pass. Cut right through the Gordian Knotheads, and absolutely insist on keeping the premise of the discussion focused on a semblance of reality - not on Straw Man details.
Otherwise, you may as well submit to discussing how many economists can dance on a downtrodden pinhead named Joe Sixpack!
Why would we bother putting fiat in reserve? What does that even mean? Is it pure sophistry? How COULD we do so even if we wanted to? What on earth are they even talking about? Are they simply baffling us with bullshit? YA THINK?!!
Fiat is, after all, a euphemism for Public Initiative. As always, initiative put off is initiative lost forever. Please turn the discussion away from nonsensical smoke & mirrors like Trust Funds and Tax Rates, and return it to the only parameters we can actually benefit from - as we do for all other public policies. Let's keep the discussion focused on the TANGIBLE, OPERATIONAL CAPABILITIES of current & future electorates, and ways to productively minimize their Output Gaps. Either you use your 2x4 on frauds, or they use their 2x4 on you. There's no benefit from stalemate, only endless economic bruises and loss of National Security.
Even participating in a discussion about squirreling away public initiative (aka, fiat) in mythical "reserved fiat" accounts is insanely inane. Economists actually have a formal term for such insanity - "Demand Leakages." It's still an insane topic to even focus on. The fact that we're discussing such euphemisms at all is our best metric for how dumb, confused, divided and self-conquered we are.
Instead, let's just demand a stop to logic leaks, and focus on building real capabilities and tangible capacity? Can we just be positive, not negative?
For Pete's sake! There is a better way. Let's just get back to American ingenuity? Please? Right now?
If NeoCons Can't Find It, They Must Be Hiding It From Themselves?
Commentary by Roger Erickson
In the mirror, no less!
SEC's Hunt for Crisis-Era Wrongdoing Loses Steam
Who says the SEC isn't modernizing? They've successfully grafted pressure-washing onto white-washing - all the while adding their own "leaks" that mysteriously drain off all the reform steam!
These guys wouldn't be allowed to catch a Control Fraud if one was brought to them bound and gagged by Maxwell's Demon! After all, they'd be chasing their own tail. And, they're supposed to be focused on our Output Gap, remember?
In the mirror, no less!
SEC's Hunt for Crisis-Era Wrongdoing Loses Steam
Who says the SEC isn't modernizing? They've successfully grafted pressure-washing onto white-washing - all the while adding their own "leaks" that mysteriously drain off all the reform steam!
These guys wouldn't be allowed to catch a Control Fraud if one was brought to them bound and gagged by Maxwell's Demon! After all, they'd be chasing their own tail. And, they're supposed to be focused on our Output Gap, remember?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)