Commentary by Roger Erickson
Americans Gambling on Rates With Most ARMs Since 2008
Quicken Pitches ARMs as Borrowers Balk at Higher Rates
Misfit Borrowers Attracting Lenders as Housing Revives
Chicago wants to lead the way ... to where?
And did I mention variable rate car loans? You heard that right.
A foolish population and it's assets are soon separated? Again, and again, and again? Anyone noticing a boom/bust/pitchfork/boom/bust/pitchfork cycle at work?
Ask your grandparents if this all looks a little familiar. They saw it all in the 1920s-1930s. And before that, in the 1910s-1910s too. And countless times before that.
When do grandkids get to stop relearning lessons their grandparents learned the hard way, and their parents either forgot, or never learned? You might want to rethink how YOU "educate" YOUR kids. You know, in case THEY ever become parents someday.
An economics, investment, trading and policy blog with a focus on Modern Monetary Theory (MMT). We seek the truth, avoid the mainstream and are virulently anti-neoliberalism.
Tuesday, August 13, 2013
Monday, August 12, 2013
Alexander Reed Kelly — Capitalism Is Changing Our Language: Study
Researchers at UCLA put 1.5 million English-language books into a tool that catalogs phrase usage and found that “over the last 200 years there has been an ever-increasing use of particularly acquisitive words: ‘get’, ‘unique’, ‘individual’, ‘self’, ‘choose’; while over the same period ‘give’ and ‘obliged’ decreased,” Owen Hatherley writes at The Guardian.
The pattern only changed briefly during the relatively egalitarian Western period between the 1940s and the 1970s.
“What has happened over those 200 years was the rise to dominance of capitalism, which obviously changed, and changes, our language and thinking,” Hatherley continues. The results suggest that the English language has long been in the process of becoming a class language, where words that are sympathetic with capitalist values and perspective are accepted as “standard....
As this tendency strengthens, it becomes increasingly obvious that society is not controlling its economic life, but is in part being controlled by it.”Truthdig
Capitalism Is Changing Our Language
Alexander Reed Kelly
Rick Santorum: ‘There’s no class in America’
Former Republican presidential candidate Rick Santorum attempted to shame Democrats for using socio-economic barometers like the term “middle class” during an appearance at the Iowa State Fair on Saturday. “When Republicans get up and talk about…
Labels:
class,
GOP,
MMT,
Rick Santorum,
sociology
The Sweet Smell Of Cynical Success. Smells Like Teen Irony
Commentary by Roger Erickson
U.S. Budget Deficit Shrinks as Revenues Rise
Be still my beating heart! These idiots don't grasp that:
1) pubic "deficit" = private financial savings?
2) public "revenue" = claw back of it's own currency, previously issued to citizens?
See p.35 here; to a fiat currency issuer "Taxes for Revenue are Obsolete" WRITTEN IN 1946!!! We weren't always this ignorant!
To err is human. To really screw up requires willful institutional ideology?
U.S. Budget Deficit Shrinks as Revenues Rise
Be still my beating heart! These idiots don't grasp that:
1) pubic "deficit" = private financial savings?
2) public "revenue" = claw back of it's own currency, previously issued to citizens?
See p.35 here; to a fiat currency issuer "Taxes for Revenue are Obsolete" WRITTEN IN 1946!!! We weren't always this ignorant!
To err is human. To really screw up requires willful institutional ideology?
Privatization Of Protection Rackets
Commentary by Roger Erickson
Lynn Wheeler: "20yrs ago, open security literature would have implied security procedures in place would have pretty much precluded a Snowden-type event ... but possibly with the privatizing of intelligence by for-profit corporations ... all that went by the wayside.
Private contractors like Booz Allen now reportedly garner 70 percent of the annual $80 billion intelligence budget and supply more than half of the available manpower?
Former head of IBM leaves and becomes chairman of Carlyle Group - which then does private equity buyout of Booz Allen.
The rest is history. How Booz Allen Hamilton Swallowed Washington."
...
Is this a story of how Innocent Control Frauds went legit? The confluence of Innocent Fraud and Control Fraud? How serendipitous! Why is it that looters are the only ones willing to invest in the return-on-coordination?
Lynn Wheeler: "20yrs ago, open security literature would have implied security procedures in place would have pretty much precluded a Snowden-type event ... but possibly with the privatizing of intelligence by for-profit corporations ... all that went by the wayside.
Private contractors like Booz Allen now reportedly garner 70 percent of the annual $80 billion intelligence budget and supply more than half of the available manpower?
Former head of IBM leaves and becomes chairman of Carlyle Group - which then does private equity buyout of Booz Allen.
The rest is history. How Booz Allen Hamilton Swallowed Washington."
...
Is this a story of how Innocent Control Frauds went legit? The confluence of Innocent Fraud and Control Fraud? How serendipitous! Why is it that looters are the only ones willing to invest in the return-on-coordination?
Let's see, waddya get when you cross an Innocent Fraud with a Control Fraud? A little flock of NeoCons?
There Are Truly No Enemies
Commentary by Roger Erickson
... only failure to see group options offering orders of magnitude higher stakes.
Can't we all just get along on our way, in pursuit of those colossal returns?
The best way to get more than we can possibly imagine ... is to share what we've got? There's no "I" in team? I'm confused. Didn't we all learn that in kindergarten ... or before?*
... only failure to see group options offering orders of magnitude higher stakes.
Can't we all just get along on our way, in pursuit of those colossal returns?
The best way to get more than we can possibly imagine ... is to share what we've got? There's no "I" in team? I'm confused. Didn't we all learn that in kindergarten ... or before?*
Who's been teaching too many of us otherwise? Ayn Rand? You're joking. Whom else? Seriously. Where the hell is the stupid coming from?
* Ever seen the Amish do a barn raising ... by warning everyone to stay off THEIR property?
Warren Mosler — Steve Moore’s WSJ piece
My old buddy Stevie still up to making a nice living by spewing propaganda he knows is at best misleading and subversive.
Serious call out and well-deserved smackdown.
We frequently argue here at MNE over whether neoliberals are ignorant or disingenuous. Warren gives good reason to prefer the latter explanation in this case.
Steve Moore’s WSJ piece
Warren Mosler
Why Do We Do These Things? Good question. For The Answer, Look In Your House of Mirrors ... VERY Carefully.
Commentary by Roger Erickson
RM Mitchell says ...
"we asked the following [five] questions:
1. What does [public policy] do in the years leading up to recessions? (Answer: Cut growth in deficit spending)
2. What does [public policy] do that cures recessions? (Answer: Increase deficit spending growth)
3. What is [public policy] doing now? [Answer: Cutting growth in deficit spending]
4. Why is [public policy] cutting deficit spending growth, despite overwhelming evidence this causes recessions? (Because of the false premises that the federal government can run short of dollars, or by creating dollars, could cause inflation.)
5. Why do we allow Congress and the President to [curtail national growth]?"
The Recession Clock
Why indeed? What distributed remedies can we explore, and select from?
While you ponder that, please remember that Public Policy is the result of OUR highly distributed cascade of choices. We get the governance patterns which our votes create, including the unintended complications.
RM Mitchell says ...
"we asked the following [five] questions:
1. What does [public policy] do in the years leading up to recessions? (Answer: Cut growth in deficit spending)
2. What does [public policy] do that cures recessions? (Answer: Increase deficit spending growth)
3. What is [public policy] doing now? [Answer: Cutting growth in deficit spending]
4. Why is [public policy] cutting deficit spending growth, despite overwhelming evidence this causes recessions? (Because of the false premises that the federal government can run short of dollars, or by creating dollars, could cause inflation.)
5. Why do we allow Congress and the President to [curtail national growth]?"
The Recession Clock
Why indeed? What distributed remedies can we explore, and select from?
While you ponder that, please remember that Public Policy is the result of OUR highly distributed cascade of choices. We get the governance patterns which our votes create, including the unintended complications.
To examine how this occurs, everyone looks in their mirror and initially sees THEIR personal inter-dependencies, wants and desires. Yet how many see the looming, unintended inter-dependencies? What happens when your mirror doesn't also reflect frequent-enough interactions with a wide-enough distribution of co-citizens? Then what? In that case, no matter how hard everyone personally works at making voting selections ... the collective effort may keep missing the point altogether? So that nothing changes?
Why are we constantly confused about the nature of emerging coordination tasks at different scales?* Simply because they're unpredictable, and we keep insisting that they're not? Gotta admit, we're stubborn, if nothing else.
Does progress track agility in switching between different paradigms for different contexts? Especially when scale is the dominant context change?
Why are we constantly confused about the nature of emerging coordination tasks at different scales?* Simply because they're unpredictable, and we keep insisting that they're not? Gotta admit, we're stubborn, if nothing else.
Does progress track agility in switching between different paradigms for different contexts? Especially when scale is the dominant context change?
If local, county, state and national policy developments are parallel kabuki theaters, whether intentional or not ... how do you discover what attributes in a collection of representatives will help, not hinder, all the unpredictable interaction patterns once all the selected representatives get into policy committees at various levels (from local to national)?
Are we running MULTI-LEVEL KABUKI? In multi-level kabuki, diverse audience members all try to select unseen kabuki-masters, to indirectly guide the kabuki-plot in the diverse directions they all want? Do the audience members ever get together and actually improve group agility at multi-level kabuki? Sounds tediously difficult.
What would multi-level kabuki look like on a personal level? If looking in your personal mirror isn't enough, what should you do next? Stack up a series of additional mirrors behind you, so that you're always looking at the multiple reflections in a little house of mirrors? That way you might hope to see inter-dependency images that appear purely as the interactions between two or many reflections? Is that a metaphor for sensing the perspectives of many people simultaneously, not just your own?
* Max Planck, a physicist writing about newly-discovered, "quantum" scale interactions, noted that: a "dilemma crops up from an incorrect understanding of the relation between the microlevel and the macrolevel." In practice, are our biggest tasks always related to staging, linking and sequencing coordination on a scale even bigger than what we did last year? Learning that is NEVER predictable. Rather, it takes trial & error practice - which we resist because we always think that we're "running out of" the public initiative - aka, fiat currency - needed to pay ourselves, to practice on a more massive scale?
Are we running MULTI-LEVEL KABUKI? In multi-level kabuki, diverse audience members all try to select unseen kabuki-masters, to indirectly guide the kabuki-plot in the diverse directions they all want? Do the audience members ever get together and actually improve group agility at multi-level kabuki? Sounds tediously difficult.
What would multi-level kabuki look like on a personal level? If looking in your personal mirror isn't enough, what should you do next? Stack up a series of additional mirrors behind you, so that you're always looking at the multiple reflections in a little house of mirrors? That way you might hope to see inter-dependency images that appear purely as the interactions between two or many reflections? Is that a metaphor for sensing the perspectives of many people simultaneously, not just your own?
* Max Planck, a physicist writing about newly-discovered, "quantum" scale interactions, noted that: a "dilemma crops up from an incorrect understanding of the relation between the microlevel and the macrolevel." In practice, are our biggest tasks always related to staging, linking and sequencing coordination on a scale even bigger than what we did last year? Learning that is NEVER predictable. Rather, it takes trial & error practice - which we resist because we always think that we're "running out of" the public initiative - aka, fiat currency - needed to pay ourselves, to practice on a more massive scale?
Sarah Palin: ‘I’m on team Rand Paul’
(Ed: FD, I'm on 'Team Human"...)
Fireworks erupting within the GOP between the chaos fomenting libertarians and the others. Story at the Washington Times:
“I’m on team Rand,” she said on Fox News Saturday. “Rand Paul understands. He gets the whole notion of don't-tread-on-me government. Whereas Chris Christie is for big government and trying to go-along-to-get-along in so many respects.”
No, ya know he’s got a shtick going there where he’s got a YouTube videographer following him around, kind of these set up situations sometimes so he can be seen as perhaps going rogue,” she said. “But Chris Christie’s for more government and his record proves that, whereas Rand Paul with that healthy libertarian streak that we need more of, in our politicians, team Rand Paul.”She's wrong imo in asserting that Christie's actions are not "rogue". Libertarian moronism has become so entrenched in the contemporary GOP that when a politician like Christie proposes or takes action that in any way seems "authoritarian" these days, it has to be truly looked at as "rogue activity" in reality.
I have to root for Christie in this battle though even he still doesn't get it 100%.
Sunday, August 11, 2013
Eric W. Dolan — Larry Kudlow wonders if Pope Francis understands freedom
CNBC host Larry Kudlow isn’t confident that Pope Francis understand freedom. During a segment last week, the advocate of laissez-faire capitalism questioned some of the Pope’s comments on the economy. “Pope John Paul II, I think, had a much more…
John Perr — The Real Reason for the GOP's All-Out War on Obamacare
At its core, the Republicans' scorched-earth opposition to Obamacare has never been so much about "freedom" or "limited government" or any other right-wing ideological buzzword as it has been about political power, pure and simple. Now as for the past 20 years, Republicans have feared not that health care reform would fail the American people, but that it would succeed. Along with Social Security and Medicare, successful health care reform would provide the third and final pillar of Americans' social safety net, all brought you by the Democratic Party. To put it another way, the GOP was never really concerned about a "government takeover of health care", "rationing", "the doctor-patient relationship" or mythical "death panels," but that an American public grateful for access to health care could provide Democrats with an enduring majority for years to come.
But what Utah Senator Orrin Hatch called a "holy war" to block health care reform didn't start when Barack Obama took the oath of office in January 2009, but instead when Bill Clinton was inaugurated in 1993. It was then that former Quayle chief of staff and Republican strategist William Kristol warned his GOP allies that a Clinton victory on health care could guarantee Democratic majorities for the foreseeable future. "The Clinton proposal is also a serious political threat to the Republican Party," Kristol wrote in his infamous December 3, 1993 memo titled "Defeating President Clinton's Health Care Proposal," adding:
"Its passage in the short run will do nothing to hurt (and everything to help) Democratic electoral prospects in 1996. But the long-term political effects of a successful Clinton health care bill will be even worse--much worse. It will relegitimize middle-class dependence for 'security' on government spending and regulation. It will revive the reputation of the party that spends and regulates, the Democrats, as the generous protector of middle-class interests. And it will at the same time strike a punishing blow against Republican claims to defend the middle class by restraining government."
And that, for Kristol, meant it had to be stopped at all costs:PERRspectives
"The first step in that process must be the unqualified political defeat of the Clinton health care proposal. Its rejection by Congress and the public would be a monumental setback for the president; and an incontestable piece of evidence that Democratic welfare-state liberalism remains firmly in retreat."
The Real Reason for the GOP's All-Out War on Obamacare
John Perr
The market state versus the welfare state.
In this endeavor, the right worked very diligently to recast the framing so that welfare state would be perceived as living on the dole instead of its original meaning of public purpose being oriented toward the "general welfare," in the words of the Preamble to the US Constitution. Even if you were not taken in by the framing, many people have been.
The strategy in this endeavor was to use wedge issues and inter-group conflict to dupe the rubes into voting against their economic and social interests by creating a tribal mindset of "us versus those people." They even frame it in terms of "the real Americans" versus those people who aren't real Americans.
Jan Hatzius — 2013 Economic Forecasts: Mid-Year Update (Video 5min)
Goldman Sachs
2013 Economic Forecasts: Mid-Year Update (Video 5min)
Jan Hatzius, Chief Economist, Global Investment Research, Goldman Sachs interviewed by Allison Nathan, Senior Strategist, Global Investment Research, Goldman Sachs
Ha-Joon Chang and Mariana Mazzucato: Rethinking the State
Chang, who has written best sellers including Kicking Away the Ladder and 23 Things They Don’t Tell You About Economics, debunks the notion that politics and economics can be separated. The state and markets are inherently intertwined.The problem is, that while “there is no scientifically defined boundary of the market, economists have been convincing people that they know where the boundary should be,” Chang says.
Defining the boundaries of markets within economic systems is impossible because of the variety of the systems themselves, especially between nations. The American capitalist system is fundamentally different from other capitalist systems, Chang says. Each system is “propped up” by its own network of regulations, participants, and currencies. With such variety, it is impossible to define a true market boundary.
...political arguments are being passed off as objective truths....INET — The Institute Blog
Ha-Joon Chang and Mariana Mazzucato: Rethinking the State
Ha-Joon Chang, Reader in the Political Economy of Development at the University of Cambridge, and Mariana Mazzucato, RM Phillips Professor of Science and Technology at the University of Sussex
I think it is clearer to say that economics and law are inherently entwined rather than economics and the state. From a broader perspective, it is more correct to say that economies are inherently entwined with institutional arrangements of which government is a major one in that so many institutional arrangements are grounded in law and legal agreements, and carry legal implications.
Dean Radin — Show Me The Evidence
Selected Peer-Reviewed Journal Publications on Psi Research
Downloadable articles published mainly in the 21st century, with some papers of historical interest and other resources.Entangled Minds
Show Me The Evidence
Dean Radin | Chief Scientist at the Institute Of Noetic Sciences (IONS) and Adjunct Faculty in the Department of Psychology at Sonoma State University. Before joining the research staff at IONS in 2001, he held appointments at AT&T Bell Labs, Princeton University, University of Edinburgh, and SRI International, where he worked on a classified program investigating psychic phenomena for the US government. He is author or coauthor of over 200 technical and popular articles, a dozen book chapters, and three books including the award-winning The Conscious Universe(HarperOne, 1997), Entangled Minds (Simon & Schuster, 2006), and most recently, Supernormal (Random House, 2013).
Jan Hatzius — Goldman Admits Payroll Data Is "Economically Meaningless"
Latest from Jan Hatzius on GIGO.
Zero Hedge
Goldman Admits Payroll Data Is "Economically Meaningless"
Goldman Sachs letter
Read in conjunction with David Little, Economic observations of Oskar Morgenstern.
Morgenstern: This book addresses itself to both the general reader and the professional economist. The former will see that decisions made in business and in public service are based on data that are known with much less certainty than generally assumed by the public or the government. The second will discover that even most widely accepted figures frequently have error components of unexpected magnitude, and consequently cast doubt on many currently accepted analyses in economics.
Weekend Reading: Mathew Forstater — Toward a New Instrumental Macroeconomics: Abba Lerner and Adolph Lowe on Economic Method, Theory, History and Policy
This paper argues that the ideas of Abba Lerner and Adolph Lowe contain overlapping and complementary insights and themes that may contribute to the development of a new approach to macroeconomics, and that have rather specific practical policy implications. This approach might be called Instrumental Macroeconomics, after Lowe's instrumentalism, but it could be termed Functional Macroeconomics after Lerner's functional finance without changing the intended meaning. 1 Terminology aside, what is required today is a macroeconomics that considers macro-policy goals at the ground level of theoretical practice (a political macroeconomics), a macroeconomics that recognizes that the system is dynamic and transformational, with major features changing over time (an historical macroeconomics), a macroeconomics that pays careful attention to institutional frameworks and arrangements (an institutional macroeconomics). What is required is a macroeconomics rid of neoclassical microfoundations, but that considers sectoral as well as aggregate relations (a structural macroeconomics), technological change as well as monetary production, and that avoids the unacceptable mechanism of aggregate models that bypass the complex problems of human agency by slipping in unacceptable motivational and behavioral assumptions.Abba Lerner and Adolph Lowe on Economic Method, Theory, History and Policy
The works of Lerner and Lowe serve as an interesting point of departure in thinking about such a new approach to macro theory and policy. While there are some important areas of overlap in their work and thought, Lerner and Lowe also have some important differences in areas of emphasis, which, it shall be argued, are strikingly complementary. Lerner's functional finance deals with aggregate proportionality and balance, while much of Lowe's work additionally emphasizes sectoral relations. While full employment and price stability were lifetime concerns of both, Lerner–following Keynes--focused more on monetary factors, while Lowe emphasized issues of structural and technological change. A Lowe-Lerner synthesis offers a powerful starting point in fleshing out an alternative approach to macroeconomic theory and policy, one which–because of its careful attention to historically changing social and institutional structures–is as fresh and relevant today as it was when Lerner and Lowe began formulating their historical and institutional approach to macroeconomic theory and public policy.
Mathew Forstater | Professor of Economics, Director of CFEPS, UMKC
Robert Solow— Good Hayek v. the Bad Hayek
The Bad Hayek emerged when he aimed to convert a wider public. Then, as often happens, he tended to overreach, and to suggest more than he had legitimately argued. The Road to Serfdom was a popular success but was not a good book. Leaving aside the irrelevant extremes, or even including them, it would be perverse to read the history, as of 1944 or as of now, as suggesting that the standard regulatory interventions in the economy have any inherent tendency to snowball into “serfdom.” The correlations often run the other way. Sixty-five years later, Hayek’s implicit prediction is a failure, rather like Marx’s forecast of the coming “immiserization of the working class.”Lars P. Syll's Blog
Good Hayek vs. Bad Hayek
Excerpt from Robert M. Solow
Read the whole review, Hayek, Friedman, and the Illusions of Conservative Economics, at The New Republic.
Not only does Hayek not make the cut in today's GOP, neither do Nixon or Reagan. And even Barry Goldwater rejected this level of extremism.
Saturday, August 10, 2013
Kevin McKenna — Scotland has the most inequitable land ownership in the west. Why?
Scotland still operating under the manor system of late feudal times?
The Guardian | The Observer
Scotland has the most inequitable land ownership in the west. Why?
Kevin McKenna | The Observer
Philip Pilkington — Gunnar Myrdal’s Prescient Criticisms of Keynes’ General Theory
More on saving and investment, static and dynamic in historical time, and ex ante and ex post, and Gunnar Myrdal's contribution to understanding it. Giving credit where credit is due.
Fixing the Economists
Gunnar Myrdal’s Prescient Criticisms of Keynes’ General Theory
Philip Pilkington
Bloomberg News — China Factories Turn to Undocumented Labor as Local Wages Jump
China’s embrace of higher wages to help bolster consumer spending has sparked a jump in factories along the east-coast export corridor bringing in undocumented and lower-paid workers from Myanmar and Vietnam.Bloomberg News
China Factories Turn to Undocumented Labor as Local Wages Jump
(h/t Lambert Strether at Naked Capitalism)
Gaius Publius: IRS is Using NSA Data Too. Who in Town Isn’t?
Summary of the sorry state that has come to pass in the US by trading faux security for liberty and constitutional rights.
Naked Capitalism
Gaius Publius: IRS is Using NSA Data Too. Who in Town Isn’t?
Bill Moyers with Richard Wolff on Inequality, Wage Slavery, and Economic Justice
Video (45 min) and transcript.
Naked Capitalism
Bill Moyers with Richard Wolff on Inequality, Wage Slavery, and Economic Justice
Richard Wolff | Professor of Economics Emeritus at the University of Massachusetts
Friday, August 9, 2013
Del Mar: "The Plunder of America"
Another not-so-brief excerpt from one of Alexander Del Mar's books; History of the Precious Metals.
This from the introduction to Chapter 40 (page 136), "The Plunder of America":
The History of the Precious Metals in America can best be told after clearing the ground with a brief review of the monetary condition and circumstances of the states of Europe at the time when America was discovered. Strictly speaking, these circumstances would carry us back quite to the beginning of metallic money in Greece; but of this event a full account will be found in the author's previous works.
Suffice it to say in this place that after many experiments with coins of gold and silver in the Greek and Roman republics, these metals had been so far abandoned as money that the measure of value in those states was eventually made to depend less upon the quantity of metal contained in the coins, than upon the number of coins emitted and kept in circulation by the state.
The integer of these systems was called in Greek, nomisma, in Latin, numisma both of which terms relate to that prescription of law which conserved and emphasized the numerical feature of the system in each state.
Such integer consisted of the whole sum of money; not upon any fraction of it. '
Upon the relinquishment of these systems, both the Greek states and the republic of Rome again committed themselves to metallic systems, this time with open mints or private coinage ; the consequence of which was the gradual concentration of wealth in the hands of a few persons, a circumstance which powerfully assisted the downfall of the state.
Upon the assumption of imperial power over the European world by Julius Caesar and especially by Augustus, private coinage, or the issuance of "gentes" coins, was at once forbidden and the state once more assumed the control of money, which, although the pieces were still made of the precious metals, was so regulated as to constitute a more or less equitable measure of value: the principal means employed in this regulation being the imposition of mine-royal- ties and a seigniorage or "retinue" upon coinage, coupled with a localization of the bronze and sometimes also of the silver issues.
This highly artificial system, though it lasted several centuries, gave way when the subject kingdoms and provinces of Rome revolted from her control and established themsefves as independent or partly in- dependent states ; a movement that began with the so-called Barbarian uprisings of the fifth century and was completely consummated when Constantinople fell in 1204.
At this period the quantity of money in circulation, outside of the Moslem states, was extremely small ; according to Mr. William Jacob, the vast acquisitions of the Empire had disappeared chiefly through wear and tear, coupled with the lack of fresh supplies of the precious metals from the mines.
Much of these metals had been taken as spoil by the Moslems and transported to their various empires in the Orient ; much had been absorbed and sequestered by the temples and religious houses of the West ; and much had also been hidden and lost in secret receptacles. It was estimated by Gregory King in 1685 that the whole stock of the precious metals, in coin and plate, in Europe, at the period of the Discovery of America in 1492 did not exceed ^35,- 000,000 in value; and to this estimate Mr. Jacob, after the most careful researches, lent his full support. The population of Europe at that period could hardly have exceeded thirty millions; so that the quantity of coin and plate did not much exceed in value ^i, or say $5 per capita. Of this amount it could hardly be supposed that more than one-half consisted of coins.
The low level of prices at this pe- riod fully corroborates this view. Moreover, there was nothing to alleviate the scarcity of money ; no means of accelerating its move- ment from hand to hand, and so of increasing its velocity or efficiency ; no substitutes for coins; no negotiable instruments; no banks ex- cept those of the Italian republics; few or no good roads; no rapid means of communication; little peace or security; and no credit.\
Since the fall of the Roman empire every device by means of which this inadequate and always sinking Measure of Value could be en- larged had been tried, but in vain. The ratio of value between gold and silver in the coins had been altered by the kings of the western states with a frequency that almost defies belief. The coins had been repeatedly degraded and debased; clipping and counterfeiting were offences so common that notwithstanding the severest penalties, they were often committed by persons of the highest respectability, by prelates, by feudal noblemen and even by sovereign kings.
The emission of leather moneys had been repeatedly attempted, but the general insecurity was too great and the condition of credit too low to admit of any extensive issues of this kind of money. Bills of ex- change known to the East Indians as hoondees and familiar to the Greeks and Romans of the republican periods, had from the same cause almost entirely fallen into disuse.
The cause was the low state of credit.
The social state itself, so far as it depended upon that exchange of labour and its products which is impossible without the use of money, was upon the point of dissolution, when Columbus of- fered to the Crown of Castile his project for approaching the rich countries of the Orient by sailing westward.Then we can pick it up with Columbus arrival in the western hemisphere and the resultant human carnage born of this out-of-control metal-love that took place in this previous post.
But we can see here from this excerpt, how the fate and success of what Del Mar terms the "social state", in my view best facilitated via the institutions of our human civil government, was directly tied to the ability of the state to successfully claim monetary authority; and then take the action to "spend first and then tax" for public purpose, and in the process facilitate a robust monetary economy within the society.
This is the same situation we find ourselves in today here in the west. The "social state", indeed in ways modern civilization itself, is currently threatened by this same inability and continued failure of those currently occupying positions of authority within our government to successfully view, receive and implement this same monetary authority.
In my view our current cohort of leaders here in the west for some reason, repeatedly and manifestly repudiates any such human authority.
It remains to be seen how the west will fare at this time in what I believe will be looked at some day as an important historic juncture.
I'm pulling for 'team human'.
The Keynesian Formula Will Not Solve Our Fundamental Growth Problem: Raghuram Rajan
Poor India, and the people of any other government that listens to him.
If this diagnosis is correct, advanced countries need to focus on reviving innovation and productivity growth over the medium term, and on realigning welfare promises with revenue capacity, while alleviating the pain of the truly destitute in the short run. For example, Southern Europe’s growth potential may consist in deregulating service sectors and reducing employment protection to spur creation of more private-sector jobs for retrenched government workers and unemployed youth.
In the US, the imperative is to improve the match between potential jobs and worker skills. People understand better than the government what they need and are acting accordingly. Many women, for example, are leaving low-paying jobs to acquire skills that will open doors to higher-paying positions. Too little government attention has been focused on such issues, partly because payoffs occur beyond electoral horizons, and partly because the effectiveness of government programs has been mixed. Tax reform, however, can provide spur retraining and maintain incentives to work, even while fixing gaping fiscal holes.
Rajan's prescription: join the race to the bottom.
Economy Watch
The Keynesian Formula Will Not Solve Our Fundamental Growth Problem: Raghuram Rajan
Raghuram Rajan
(h/t Vassilis Serafimakis on FB)
Michael Snyder — The US Economy Grew Fastest With No Fed And No Income Tax
Here is a particularly naive post at Zero Hedge, which is noted for naive posting. Michael Synder provides data showing that the US grew at a much faster rate as it was approaching the apex of development as an emerging economy, just like China and India are reporting similarly spectacular growth. However, there is a point at which emerging economies transition to developed economies, called the Lewis turning point, when abundant cheap labor begins to dry up,wages increase, and the consumer economy develops.
At this point the economy begins to switch from an investment driven export economy to a consumer economy in which the service sector increases more quickly than the industrial sector. Then the rate of growth cools down and hopefully stabilizes with the purchasing power of a prosperous middle class. If that doesn't happen at the Lewis turning point, then the economy develops into a have and have-not economy with high inequality.
Synder correlates this with the institution of central banking and an income tax instead of recognizing the obvious correlation in terms of developmental stages. For example, during the developmental stage when the country was a net exporters, it protected developing industry with tariffs, and tariffs, which are taxes on the external sector, were the principal source of funding. As the country developed and trade became less crucial to development when the domestic economic bagan to take off, tariffs began to be replaced by taxes as the chief source of public funding.
The other point that Synder overlooks is the explosion of the domestic economy as well as exports post-WWII. Even though public debt was in the triple digits, there was low inflation and explosive development of the consumer economy lead by the baby boom, which continued to influence the US economy ever since and will continue to do so for another generation. And this with a central bank and a progressive income tax with a top bracket of over 90%. In fact, as the tax rate was reduced, GDP growth rate dropped.
Michael Snyder is blowing smoke. Read it if you want a good laugh.
Zero Hedge
The US Economy Grew Fastest With No Fed And No Income Tax
Michael Snyder | The Economic Collapse blog
Labels:
Fed,
growth,
MMT,
US income tax
Dave Altig — Myth and Reality: The Low-Wage Job Machine
Charts.
Importantly, the animation also clearly illustrates that the growing wage disparity is a trend, not a unique feature of the postcrisis period. There are lots of interesting things being written about the reasons for this trend, and it is a vitally important topic. But I'm pretty sure the answers to the important policy questions lie well beyond the current business cycle.FRB Atlanta — Macroblog
Myth and Reality: The Low-Wage Job Machine
Dave Altig
US economy changing structurally? Looks like it.
Noah Smith — Thinking out loud: Do government deficits equal private surpluses?
(Shaking head) Noah Smith is a professor of finance and he doesn't know the answer to this — although granted it is not very clearly stated as "government deficits equal private surpluses," as Jan Hatzius does, whom Noah quotes.
It is clearer to say that the government fiscal deficit equals the consolidated nongovernment fiscal surplus in aggregate, since the government balance plus the consolidated domestic private sector balance plus the external balance must sum to zero as an accounting identity. Transposing, the government balance will be the inverse of the consolidated nongovernment balance in aggregate.
If the external balance is zero, then the government balance and the domestic private sector balance must sum to zero, therefore, must be in inverse relationship. In this case, if government net spends by running a deficit, then the domestic private sector saves the same amount in aggregate wrt net financial assets. And vice versa.
If the both the external sector and the government sector are in balance, then the domestic private sector must also as an identity. There can be net savers but not net savers in aggregate, since accounts within the sector must balance, i.e., net to zero.
Hint to Noah: Read Godley and Lavoie, Monetary Economics for an explication of stock-flow consistency in sectoral balance accounting. Jan Haztius learned this from Wynne Godley, and it is the basis of MMT SFC macro modeling. This is really simple when you do the accounting properly.
While accounting identities don't say anything about the causality, they do reveal what is necessary and what is impossible in terms of stock flow consistency. Mixing up stocks and flows is a novice error.
Noahpinion
Thinking out loud: Do government deficits equal private surpluses?
Noah Smith | Assistant Professor of Finance, Stony Brook University
No Wonder They're So Keen On Lowering Tariffs & Expanding "Free Trade" Zones
Commentary by Roger Erickson
America's Biggest Companies Continue To Move Factories Offshore And Eliminate Thousands of American Jobs
Good idea. How 'bout we swap "Turd-World" Industries for 3rd-World Labor? Sounds like God's work for sure!
How? Hmmm, maybe our Middle Class should just remove all tariffs on TBTF turd-banking activity, outsource all of turd-Wall St to Grameen grandmamas with mobile phones, in "financial sweatshops", and finally disintermediate a domestic turd-industry that is more trouble than it's worth?
Stone 3 turds with one kill shot? (thrown by grandmothers?)
Buddha might approve of that Middle Way with Class.
America's Biggest Companies Continue To Move Factories Offshore And Eliminate Thousands of American Jobs
Good idea. How 'bout we swap "Turd-World" Industries for 3rd-World Labor? Sounds like God's work for sure!
How? Hmmm, maybe our Middle Class should just remove all tariffs on TBTF turd-banking activity, outsource all of turd-Wall St to Grameen grandmamas with mobile phones, in "financial sweatshops", and finally disintermediate a domestic turd-industry that is more trouble than it's worth?
Stone 3 turds with one kill shot? (thrown by grandmothers?)
Buddha might approve of that Middle Way with Class.
With Public Servants Like This, Who Needs Enemies? Or Frauds?
Commentary by Roger Erickson
Save fiat by combining the functions of Public Servants & Frauds, into one office? BRILLIANT! :(
In fact, that's so ****ing, brilliantly NOT right, that it's not even wrong. It's just totally out of the paradigm of any form of human evolution whatsoever.
Meanwhile, our pragmatic, useful public servant, Bill Black - banned from official public service for the clan sin of serving our public too well - is hoisting our current Faux Public Servants on their own petards.
Bill Black - "Is B of A the Most Embarrassing Department of Justice Suit Ever?"
Bill Black - The Fraud Shotgun: The Overlapping Fields of Fraudulent Fire that Drove the Crisis
Bill Black - Bank of America Escapes Criminal Charges for Securities Fraud
Save fiat by combining the functions of Public Servants & Frauds, into one office? BRILLIANT! :(
In fact, that's so ****ing, brilliantly NOT right, that it's not even wrong. It's just totally out of the paradigm of any form of human evolution whatsoever.
Meanwhile, our pragmatic, useful public servant, Bill Black - banned from official public service for the clan sin of serving our public too well - is hoisting our current Faux Public Servants on their own petards.
Bill Black - "Is B of A the Most Embarrassing Department of Justice Suit Ever?"
Bill Black - The Fraud Shotgun: The Overlapping Fields of Fraudulent Fire that Drove the Crisis
Bill Black - Bank of America Escapes Criminal Charges for Securities Fraud
Kathleen McKiernan — Historical Echoes: Off the Charts!
The visual representation of information, knowledge, or data has been around since the time of the caveman. But it wasn’t until 1786, when William Playfair, a Scottish engineer, published The Commercial and Political Atlas, illustrating for the first time how economic data could be represented by charts. Playfair’s work preceded that of Florence Nightingale—broadly acknowledged as the founder of modern nursing—who used information graphics in the 1850s to convince Queen Victoria that reform was needed in the British military health service. Nightingale developed the Coxcomb chart—a combination of stacked pie and bar charts—to assess mortality among soldiers during the Crimean War.
Excerpted below from a report by the Committee for Economic Development, a Washington, D.C., nonprofit think-tank, this 1943 chartpresents a long-range record of booms and depressions (the chart is available through the Federal Reserve Archival System for Economic Research, or FRASER). It offers a picture of the more important events that have tended to shape our economic and fiscal curves since 1775. Business activity, price inflation, federal debt, national income, and stock and bond yields are traced in a single spread. The study of “postwar periods” is spotlighted in this edition.Federal Reserve Bank of New York — Liberty Street Economics
Historical Echoes: Off the Charts!
Kathleen McKiernan
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)