Tuesday, June 4, 2013

Antoine Reverchon — The Dogmas of the Market Economy under Critical Scrutiny


About Beyond Mechanical Markets: Asset Price Swings, Risk, and the Role of the State by Roman Frydman and Michael D. Goldberg and what the authors call "imperfect knowledge economics."

INET Blog
The Dogmas of the Market Economy under Critical Scrutiny
Antoine Reverchon (translated from French), Le Monde

PDF of the epilogue here.

From the epilogue:
Keynes ... shared Knight’s profound doubts concerning the usefulness of standard probability theory for understanding change in individual decisionmaking and market outcomes: we “cannot depend on strict mathematical expectation, since the basis for making such calculations does not exist” .... The importance that Keynes attached to the role of uncertainty concerning both outcomes and probabilities played a key role in his analysis of financial markets and their influence on the broader economy, particularly investment.
But
Hayek’s admonition was directed at the post- (1945) Keynesian econometric models, which grew out of the purported formalization of Keynes’s ideas and were estimated by statistical methods on the basis of historical data. Around the time of Hayek’s Nobel lecture, the applicability of these models for policy analysis had come under severe criticism, either for portraying market participants’ forecasting behavior with mechanical rules, which did not take into account contemplated changes in policy, or for disregarding such behavior’s eff ects on aggregate outcomes altogether.

While unnamed, the most prominent author of "the post- (1945) Keynesian econometric models" was Paul Samuelson, who integrated some Keynesian principles with neoclassical general equilibrium.

Hayek fared no better.
Rational Expectations models, which were becoming highly influential at the time, were proposed by their advocates as a way to remedy this fl aw in Keynesian econometric models. But the Rational Expectations models were as mechanical as their Keynesian predecessors.

Because their portrayal of individuals' forecasting behavior is woefully inadequate, Rational Expectations models were unsuitable for analyzing how market participants would respond to the contemplated changes in economic policy. Remarkably (given that they were developed by Hayek's successors at the University of Chicago), these models were, moreover, fully predetermined, and thus perpetuated "the pretense of exact knowledge" that Hayek criticized so scathingly in his Nobel lecture.
Behavioral economics, often credited with overturning this did nothing of the sort, since it carried over previous assumptions.
Faith that better fully predetermined models hold the key to
adequately predicting all future changes and their consequences is
puzzling not only with respect to adherents of the Rational Expectations Hypothesis. When behavioral economists, who uncovered
many important empirical failures of Rational Expectations models,
formalized their insights, they followed their conventional predecessors by doing so with fully predetermined models
The authors then outline their approach as qualitative and contingent.
Imperfect Knowledge Economics stakes out an intermediate position between erratic animal spirits and the contemporary presumption that change and its consequences can be adequately prespecifi ed with mechanical rules. In contrast to the contemporary approach, the mathematical models of Imperfect Knowledge Economics explore the possibility that change and its consequences can be portrayed with qualitative and contingent conditions. h ese conditions are context-dependent, and as discussed in Chapter 9, the qualitative regularities that they formalize become manifest—or cease to be relevant—at moments that no one can fully predict.

Imperfect Knowledge Economics therefore does not adopt the extreme view, often associated with Knight, that uncertainty is so radical as to preclude economists from saying anything useful and empirically relevant about how market outcomes unfold over time. Indeed, departing from the position of Knight and Keynes, we make nonstandard use of probabilistic formalism.

This approach facilitates the formalization of qualitative conditions that make up Imperfect Knowledge Economics models and the mathematical derivation of their qualitative and contingent implications. However, Imperfect Knowledge Economics recognizes the importance of early modern arguments that market participants (and economists) have access to only imperfect knowledge of the causal factors that may be useful for understanding outcomes.

Jess Zimmerman — If you don’t feel like cooking your own bugs, opt for an insect energy bar


It's finally here. I've been promoting this for years. It's going to be big.

Grist

If you don’t feel like cooking your own bugs, opt for an insect energy bar
Jess Zimmerman

Philip Pilkington: Paul Krugman and the Fatherless Keynesians


Phil explains the natural rate of interest, and why it is important even though wrong. Lots of very serious (neoclassical) people assume it, many of whom call themselves Keynesians. The bad results of (monetary) policy based on this mistaken assumption is giving Keynesianism a bad name. Paul Krugman is the poster child.

Naked Capitalism
Philip Pilkington: Paul Krugman and the Fatherless Keynesians

system failure — Greek crisis and disorientation operations update

The Greek government tried to persuade about the “success story” of Greece after Greek Prime Minister Antonis Samara's trip to China and Azerbaijan, that is, recovery is imminent, Greece returns to growth and better days are coming. Very difficult to do, as the reality experienced by millions of Greeks is completely different. The dominant bank-occupied media in Greece were mobilized, as always, for this new propagandistic disorientation effort, and the arsenal of propaganda was enhanced by some German media with articles praising Samaras. Wolfgang Schauble also supported this operation by praising Greece and the countries which adopted devastating austerity measures.
the unbalanced evolution of homo sapiens
Greek crisis and disorientation operations update
system failure

Norbert Häring — The ECB sticks to the discredited 90%-debt-threshold-story with pathetic new evidence

If you read the May Monthly Bulletin of the European Central Bank, you could be forgiven for thinking that the ECB has simply missed the widely publicized April debate around the mistakes Carmen Reinhart and Ken Rogoff made in the data analysis which formed the basis for the 90%-debt-level-threshold story.
Real-World Economics Review Blog
The ECB sticks to the discredited 90%-debt-threshold-story with pathetic new evidence
Norbert Häring


Noam Chomsky — The Eve of Destruction

What is the future likely to bring? A reasonable stance might be to try to look at the human species from the outside. So imagine that you’re an extraterrestrial observer who is trying to figure out what’s happening here or, for that matter, imagine you’re an historian 100 years from now -- assuming there are any historians 100 years from now, which is not obvious -- and you’re looking back at what’s happening today. You’d see something quite remarkable.
TomDispatch
Tomgram: Noam Chomsky, The Eve of Destruction
Noam Chomsky

Al Jazeera — France says tests from Syria shows sarin use

Foreign minister says examination of samples make it certain nerve agent has been used in Syria on several occasions.
Al Jazeera
France says tests from Syria shows sarin use

Looks like both sides are using sarin nerve gas, vastly upping the ante. While the choice of weapons is tactical, this choice affects geopolicy and geo-strategy, as well as international order. So this is a potentially a big deal.



John Carney — Goldman Wants You To Forget About Too Big To Fail

Goldman Sachs wants you to believe that Too Big To Fail banks do not actually enjoya funding advantage....
The Goldman researchers are practicing a bit of sleight-of-hand here.
CNBC NetNet
Goldman Wants You To Forget About Too Big To Fail
John Carney | Senior Editor

BTW, thanks to John for moderating Mosler v. Murphy.

Dan Kervick — Do Banks Create Money from Thin Air?

It is sometimes said that commercial banks in our modern monetary system create money “from thin air”.  While there is truth in this metaphorical claim, the metaphor can also be seriously misleading, and leads some to attribute powers to commercial banks that are actually retained by the government alone under our system.  It is worth trying to get clear about all this.
New Economic Perspectives

Do Banks Create Money from Thin Air?
Dan Kervick

Monday, June 3, 2013

Brian Lucking and Daniel Wilson — Fiscal Headwinds: Is the Other Shoe About to Drop?

Federal fiscal policy during the recession was abnormally expansionary by historical standards. However, over the past 2½ years it has become unusually contractionary as a result of several deficit reduction measures passed by Congress. During the next three years, we estimate that federal budgetary policy could restrain economic growth by as much as 1 percentage point annually beyond the normal fiscal drag that occurs during recoveries.
Federal Reserve Bank Of San Francisco Economic Letter
Fiscal Headwinds: Is the Other Shoe About to Drop?
Brian Lucking and Daniel Wilson
(h/t Mark Thoma at Economist's View)

In the debate, Warren was talking about fiscal drag due to a deficit being too small.

Dirk Ehnts — Where I disagree with Michael Pettis

Recently, Michael Pettis has written a book on Chinese rebalancingand published an article at Foreign Policy on the euro zone crisis. While I have read through the first chapters of his book and will publish a critique at a later stage, I want to take issue with his article. While his Saldenmechanik (balance of payments mechanics) is the right approach, his neglect of endogenous money leads to the wrong causalities and therefore the wrong conclusions.
econoblog101
Where I disagree with Michael Pettis
Dirk Ehnts | Berlin School of Economics and Law


AFP — Federal Reserve studying effect of Paypal and Bitcoin on banking

The United States is studying the potential risk from online payment mechanisms like PayPal and Bitcoin, a top US Federal Reserve official told an international conference on Monday.
Some bankers have expressed worries that newer players in the online marketplace could have negative implications for the financial system.
“We have been talking… with banking organisations over the last year or two, trying more carefully to understand what the concerns are with these new payment mechanisms,” Federal Reserve Vice Chair Janet Yellen said.

But she denied the widespread view that such players operate completely unregulated, saying the United States has a stronger regulatory environment than many are aware of, especially in the area of consumer protection.
The Raw Story
Federal Reserve studying effect of Paypal and Bitcoin on banking
Agence France-Presse

Warren Mosler Vs. Robert Murphy Today


MACROECONOMIC DEBATES AMONG THE HETERODOXY
Warren Mosler Vs. Robert Murphy


6.15pm June 3rd, 2013
Room 103, Jerome Greene Hall, Columbia Law School

Livestream: A livestream can be accessed from the home page or at this permanent link.


Ramanan — Trending: #SteveKeen

Go for it Steve Keen. Whatever criticism you are taking – including from me - beat ‘em. 
The Case of Concerted Action
Trending: #SteveKeen
Ramanan

Now if we can just get Steve to fix his accounting. Hopefully, he has read JKH's constructive criticism and is working on it.


Leslie Savan — The Koch Influence

At one point an ITVS vice-president spelled it out: “We live in a world where we have to be aware that people with power have power.” ITVS cancelled the project in April.
The Nation
The Koch Influence
Leslie Savan

Sunday, June 2, 2013

Carl Gibson — Cooperative Economics: Replacing a Capitalism in Collapse

All it takes to form a co-op is a small group of determined people all set on an idea to cooperatively own and operate a facet of the economy and allow them to make decisions in a democratic process. By democratizing society through housing and work, we can start a new revolution in our politics, our economy, and even our environment by choosing to consume sustainably and minimize our impact on the planet.
Truthout
Cooperative Economics: Replacing a Capitalism in Collapse
Carl Gibson, Occupy.com | Op-Ed

JKH — The Accounting Quest of Steve Keen

Steve has written a post on quantitative easing, with an admirable bent towards the importance of accounting in that context:
Steve Keen: Is QE Quantitatively Irrelevant?
He says, “I’m open to correction that I’ve wrongly characterised what banks do or how QE works here.”
I think there is definitely a range of mischaracterizations in Keen’s post about how the banking system responds to QE in both operations and accounting. So I’m going to offer some comments, as invited. While his construction departs from the actual case, I do have respect for the general direction of his pursuit.
Monetary Realism
The Accounting Quest of Steve Keen
JKH

Paul Meli — Does Credit Drive the Economy?

Much of the commentary on the economy seems to assume that it is driven by credit. The statement often made in blogs and news articles is that 90% or more of the money in circulation is private debt, the rest coming through net government spending, so clearly credit (debt) must be the main driver of the system. It's obvious. A caveman could see it.
I believe this is a gross mischaracterization of how the system actually functions.
Where do these claims regarding credit domination of the system come from? Is it truth or fiction. From what I had seen it was nothing more than an article of faith, I had never come across any proof or support that this was actually the case.
Based on the claims, the "money supply" people must be alluding to is the supply of dollars in existence within the domestic non-government. This is pretty simple number to figure out…
The View From Mars
Does Credit Drive the Economy?
Paul Meli

Zero Hedge — It's A "0.6%" World: Who Owns What Of The $223 Trillion In Global Wealth


Lots of charts.

Zero Hedge
It's A "0.6%" World: Who Owns What Of The $223 Trillion In Global Wealth
Submitted by Tyler Durden


Cemal Burak Tansel — The Gezi Park occupation: confronting authoritarian neoliberalism

On May 28 an impromptu occupation began in Istanbul’s central Gezi Park following the news that the metropolitan municipality had sent bulldozers to demolish the park. The park was doomed as it sits on the pathway of a new urban restructuring programme which included the transformation of the green zone into another superfluous shopping complex.
Largely ignored by the outlets of the corporate press, the news travelled quickly on social media, followed by the appearance of a number of protesters at the scene. Four days since the initial mobilisation, Gezi Park has witnessed a continuous influx of protestors who have organised sit-ins and public talks in a largely carnivalesque atmosphere. On May 30, Al Jazeera reported that ‘unconfirmed reports suggest more than 10,000 people are currently gathered in Taksim’s Gezi Park’. But the increasing number of bodies gathered at the location could not make a dent in the AKP government’s commitment to ‘urban renewal’. On the contrary, the government responded to this unexpected public resistance by repeating a time-honoured act of histrionics in Turkish politics: ignore the public, if that does not work, terrorise them....
...the meteoric rise of the occupation and the subsequent public outrage against the government signifies discontent with a broader trend that underpins the AKP’s reign since 2002: authoritarian neoliberalism. 
Open Democracy
The Gezi Park occupation: confronting authoritarian neoliberalism
Cemal Burak Tansel | PhD candidate in the School of Politics and International Relations at the University of Nottingham and a fellow of the Centre for the Study of Social and Global Justice (CSSGJ). His research focuses on the international historical sociology of state formation and capitalist development in the peripheries with particular reference to Turkey.




Pretty much the same as Zucotti, Oakland, etc.

Sell On News — Leverage versus debt

Capitalism, I suspect, is doing its best to follow communism into the grave yard. Its strength was that it was not an ideology, just a practice – markets, after all, have been around for thousands of years. But the capitalist ideology of “financial deregulation” whose fruits are now so evident, the worship of markets as the solution to everything, is threatening the system itself.
Macrobusiness
Leverage versus debt
Sell On News
(h/t Lambert Strether at Naked Capitalism)

Andrew Lainton — Government Debts and Treasury Bonds – Neither Keynesian or Inflationary

This matters because treasury bonds are exactly like corporate bonds, these are in the first instance transfer payments between balance sheets of the existing monetary stock, unlike bank (including central bank) money which involves money creation through crediting of accounts.
This is the key because a ‘Central Bank bond’ adds to monetary base and so the net credit induced demand {change in debt – change in saving)(this is a simplification as any increase in bank lending may require additional capital which requires saving which must then be leveraged) whereas a treasury bond is simply a transfer payment, there is no net increase in money or effective demand. There is no net change in the monetary base – the increase in debt is exactly offset by the increase in saving to purchase the bond.
He mistakes the function of the monetary base and tsys as a reserve drain having to do with central bank interest rate setting and doesn't take into account the difference between consolidated non-government net financial assets in aggregate and endogenous credit-debt relationships in non-government, which necessarily net to zero.

Decisions, Decisions, Decisions,
Government Debts and Treasury Bonds – Neither Keynesian or Inflationary
Andrew Lainton


Tesla Announces new 'Supercharger' system


Tesla's Musk here announces a newer 'super-charging' system that will be provided "free" for Tesla  owners soon all throughout the country.




Uh oh OPEC!


Saturday, June 1, 2013

Daniel Falcone — Noam Chomsky on Democracy and Education in the 21st Century and Beyond

So now, take for example ALEC, the American Legislative Exchange Council. It's corporate funded, the Koch brothers and those guys. It's an organization which designs legislation for states, for state legislators. And they've got plenty of clout, so they can get a lot of it through. Now they have a new program, which sounds very pretty on the surface. It's designed to increase "critical thinking." And the way you increase critical thinking is by having "balanced education." "Balanced education" means that if you teach kids something about the climate, you also have to teach them climate change denial. It's like teaching evolution science, but also creation science, so that you have "critical thinking."
All of this is a way of turning the population into a bunch of imbeciles. That's really serious. I mean, it's life and death at this point, not just making society worse.
Truthout
Noam Chomsky on Democracy and Education in the 21st Century and Beyond
Daniel Falcone | Truthout Interview


Mish — Lowest Core PCE in History; "Flation" Perspective

Inflation, deflation, and disinflation are all in the eyes of the beholder, and all depend on the definition. Still I expect another round of deflation possibly with prices but more importantly with credit, my preferred measure of "flation". 
Regardless of how one measures "flation", the hyperinflationists missed the boat by a mile.
MISH'S Global Economic Trend Analysis
Lowest Core PCE in History; "Flation" Perspective
Mike "Mish" Shedlock

Matias Vernengo — Garegnani on Sraffa, Ricardo and Marx

Note that Sraffa suggested that his solution, based on the standard commodity, could be interpreted as akin to Smith's labor commanded theory of value, and as such could (and I would say should) be seen as a logically coherent version of the labor theory of value (discussed in this previous post).
Naked Keynesianism
Garegnani on Sraffa, Ricardo and Marx
Matias Vernengo | Associate Professor of Economics, University of Utah

Sraffa as a bridge from classical economics including Marx to Post Keynesianism.

Wolf Richter — Lobbying And Gmo Giant Monsanto Buckles In Europe

The “March Against Monsanto” in 52 countries, an unapproved strain of its genetically modified wheat growing profusely in Oregon, cancelled wheat export orders.... A rough week for Monsanto.
But now it threw in the towel in Europe – where its genetically modified seeds have faced stiff resistance at every twist and turn. Even its deep corporate pockets and mastery of lobbying have failed: “It’s counterproductive to fight against windmills,” its spokesman told the Tageszeitung.
Testosterone Pit
Lobbying And Gmo Giant Monsanto Buckles In Europe
Wolf Richter
(h/t Naked Capitalism)


Sasha Breger — How Big Finance is Eating the World’s Lunch Agricultural Wealth

If you hear a kind of whooshing, rushing noise, don’t worry—it’s not US jobs moving to China. Today’s great sucking sound is the sound of agricultural wealth being siphoned off into the global financial system. Dragging poverty and insecurity in its wake, this broad movement of wealth from agriculture into finance is enriching and empowering finance capital at the expense of farmers, traders, consumers, rural communities and the earth. In fact, that sucking sound is really the sound of injustice.
Finance capital globally deploys a huge variety of methods and techniques that generally serve to redistribute wealth from agriculture to finance. These include debt, farmland acquisition, commodity hoarding, and derivative and insurance markets. In the following posts, I outline the wealth transfer mechanism in each of these contexts, focusing largely on new data and evidence from the past several years.
Naked Capitalism
Sasha Breger: How Big Finance is Eating the World’s Lunch Agricultural Wealth


Lars P. Syll — Modern macroeconomics – like Hamlet without the Prince

Simon Nixon: "the most important contribution to the debate is an essay by Claudio Borio, deputy head of the monetary and economics department at the Bank for International Settlements, published last moth and titled: “The Financial Cycle and Macroeconomics: What have we learned?”

"In Mr. Borio’s view, the 'New Keynesian Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium' model used by most mainstream forecasters is flawed because it assumes the financial system is frictionless: Its role is simply to allocate resources and therefore can be ignored. Although many economists now accept these assumptions are wrong, efforts to modify their models amount to little more than tinkering. What is needed is a return to out-of-fashion insights influential before World War II and kept alive since by maverick economists such as Hyman Minsky and Charles Kindleberger that recognized the central importance of the financial cycle."
Lars P. Syll's Blog
Modern macroeconomics – like Hamlet without the Prince
Lars P. Syll

See also Useless stochastic models (John Hicks)

Eleazar David Melendez — Bitcoin Companies Attract Frenzy Of Venture Funding

Bitcoin is becoming such a real and sizable instrument of commerce that investors are now pouring into new ventures aimed at furthering its use, financing new exchanges and payment systems for the virtual currency.
The Huffington Post
Bitcoin Companies Attract Frenzy Of Venture Funding
Eleazar David Melendez