Friday, June 7, 2013

Robert Vienneau — Haikus

These have been written by authors who have not acknowledged their authorship. (I have written many of them myself.)
Thoughts on Economics
Haikus
Robert Vienneau

Fun.

Lord Keynes — Coercion is the Basis of all Market Societies

This is a simple point, but important. All capitalist systems or systems based on markets – or indeed human society of any sort – require law and order and ultimately force and coercion to back up the law and the enforcement of the law.
Social Democracy For The 21St Century
Coercion is the Basis of all Market Societies
Lord Keynes

Who else got it right? Jan Hatzius, for one. And there were others, too.


Wynne Godley was one of the economists who is credited for getting it right. But Jan Haztius, following Godley's lead did, too, although he is seldom credited for it outside of financial circles. It is well-known that Hatzius brought Wynne Godley's SFC macro modeling to GS. Haztius was named chief economist in 2011, no doubt due his record of many correct calls using the sectoral balance approach to macro modeling.

Jan Hatzius - Der Pessimist, der recht behältm
Financial Times Deutschland - 24.09.2008

'Most Accurate Economist' receives Lawrence R. Klein Award
ASU News - October 05, 2009

ASU News - September 28, 2011



The Got It Right Project of AFEE — the Association For Evolutionary Economics lists many more "nobodies" that got it right, too:

Articles with direct references to key institutional failures of the 2008 meltdown. Listed by Date.

March 1996: Brent McClintock, “International Financial Instability and the Financial Derivatives Market.” Journal of Economic Issues 30(1) pp 13 -32. (Contributed to this site by Eric Hake) http://personal.carthage.edu/bmcclintock/derivativesifi.pdf

1998 Brooksley Born, testimony as as head of the commodity futures trading commission. http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=389x4221335

1999 Senator Byron Dorgan on the senate floor in opposition to the repeal of Glass-Steagallhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/05/11/glass-steagall-act-the-se_n_201557.html

February 1999: Jerry Jordan, member of the FOMC quoted in the FOMC minutes as saying "There are people making real estate investments for residential and other purposes in the expectation that prices can only go up and go up at accelerating rates.  Those expectations ultimately become destabilizing to the economic system."http://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/files/FOMC19990203meeting.pdf (Contributed to this site by Stephanie A. Kelton)

2000: L. Randal Wray, “Can the Expansion Be Sustained? A Minskian View. “http://www.levy.org/pubs/pn00_5.pdf  (Contributed to this site by Eric Tymoigne.)

March 2000: Godley and Wray “Is Goldilocks Doomed?” Journal of Economic Issues 34(1) p. 201 – 206. (Found by Dirk J Bezemer) (prediction of the last downturn before it happened)

July 6, 2000: Wynne Godley, “Drowning in Debt.”  http://www.levy.org/pubs/pn00_6.pdf  (Contributed to this site by Eric Tymoigne.)

October 2001: L. Randal Wray, “Are We All Keynesians (Again)?”http://www.levy.org/pubs/pn01_10.pdf (Contributed to this site by L. Randal Wray)

2002: Dean Baker, “The Run-Up in Home Prices: Is It Real or Is It Another Bubble?”http://www.cepr.net/documents/publications/housing_2002_08.pdf (Found by Dirk J Bezemer)

2006: Michael Hudson, “Saving, Asset-Price Inflation and Debt-Induced Deflation” in Money, Financial Instability and Stabilization Policy Edited by Randal Wray and Mathew Forstater.  (Contributed to this site by Glen Atkinson)

2006 : Wynne Godley and Gennaro Zezza, “Debt and Lending: A Cri De Coeur.” http://www.levy.org/pubs/pn_4_06.pdf (Contributed to this site by Eric Tymoigne.)

May 2006: L. Randal Wray “Can Basel II Enhance Financial Stability? A Pessimistic View.”http://www.levy.org/pubs/ppb_84.pdf (Contributed to this site by L. Randal Wray)

December 2006: Stephen Keen, “The Lily and the Pond.” http://evatt.org.au/news/445.html (Found by Dirk J Bezemer)

January 2007: L. Randal Wray “Demand Constraints and Big Government.”http://www.levy.org/pubs/wp_488.pdf (Contributed to this site by Randal Wray)

2007: Christopher Brown “Financial Engineering, consumer credit, and the stability of effective demand”, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, Vol. 29, No. 3, Spring, pp. 427-53.

August 2007: Eric Tymoigne “A Hard-Nosed Look at Worsening U.S. Household Finance.” Published in Challenge 50(4), P. 88-111.  http://ideas.repec.org/a/mes/challe/v50y2007i4p88-111.html(Contributed to this site by Eric Tymoigne.)

December 2007: L. Randal Wray “Lessons From the Subprime Meltdown.”http://www.levy.org/pubs/wp_522.pdf (Contributed to this site by L. Randal Wray)

April 2008: L. Randal Wray “Financial Markets Meltdown: What Can We Learn From Mynsky?”http://www.levy.org/pubs/ppb_94.pdf (Contributed to this site by L. Randal Wray)

June 2008: Hyman Minsky (Foreword by Randal Wray), “Securitization.”http://www.levy.org/pubs/pn_08_2.pdf (Contributed to this site by L. Randal Wray)

Barkley Rosser — Who Predicted The Crisis-Redux

I probably should not dredge around in this further, but there has been in the last week or so a major outpouring of dicussion about "who predicted the crisis," with a lot of wrangling and some less than pleasant comments being strewn about. I got dragged into it and should probably leave it alone, but more keeps coming, and I also think there might be a link to developments here at this blog.
Econospeak
Who Predicted The Crisis-Redux
Barkley Rosser

For the record.

Mark Gongloff — U.S. Suffers Biggest Pay Drop On Record, As Workers Squeezed Tighter

The economic "recovery" just keeps getting worse for the average worker: U.S. employers squeezed their employees even harder than usual in the first quarter, leading to the biggest drop in hourly pay on record
Hourly pay for nonfarm workers fell at a 3.8 percent annualized rate in the first quarter, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported on Wednesday. This was the biggest quarterly decline since the BLS started keeping track in 1947. Some of the drop was payback for a 9.9 percent surge in hourly pay in the fourth quarter of 2012, as employers shoveled money out the door to avoid tax changes they expected to take place in 2013.
But there have been plenty of such quarterly pay increases in the past. Many were even bigger. Some went on for several quarters at a time. And never has there been such a steep pay drop in response as there was in the first quarter of this year.
Smoothing out the quarterly ups and downs doesn't make the picture look any better....
The Huffington Post
U.S. Suffers Biggest Pay Drop On Record, As Workers Squeezed Tighter
Mark Gongloff

Interesting article on Costco in this regard. They are bucking the trend. Why? For one thing, the CEO is willing to tell Wall Street to take a hike.

Bloomberg Businessweek
Costco CEO Craig Jelinek Leads the Cheapest, Happiest Company in the World
Brad Stone

Frances Coppola — The creeping desert


Economic "desertification" in the EZ periphery?


Coppola Comment
The creeping desert
Frances Coppola

Timothy Taylor — Labor's Falling Share, Everywhere


Labor's falling share means that the "job creators" share has been increasing, as the record of rising inequality shows. So where are the jobs, "job creators"?

Neoliberalism at work, undercutting bargaining power of labor, coupled with the failure to understand Keynesian economics — "It's the demand, stupid."

Conversable Economist
Labor's Falling Share, Everywhere
Timothy Taylor | Managing editor of the Journal of Economic Perspective

Lars Syll — Krugman – more Wicksell than Keynes


More on "the natural rate of interest."

Lars Syll's Blog

Krugman – more Wicksell than Keynes
Lars P. Syll | Professor of Social Studies and Associate Professor of Economics, Malmo University

Ramanan— Flow Of Funds: New Look

The United States Statistical Release Z.1 now has a new look and more data. It now includes the Integrated Macroeconomic Accounts.
The Case of Concerted Action
Flow Of Funds: New Look
Ramanan

John Carney — How Home Ownership Causes Unemployment


Before the housing market in the United States went into convulsions, you heard a lot of talk about the positive "externalities" of home ownership. The Bush administration made something of a fetish of the idea, saying its goal was to create an ownership society.
The best-known dissenter was the British economist Andrew Oswald. As early as 1996, Oswald was producing papers that forcefully argued that home ownership causes unemployment. The effect Oswald claimed to have discovered was strong: Every 5 percent rise in home ownership resulted in a 1 percent rise in unemployment. Oswald's original paper set off a cascade of others that largely confirmed his results. 
Oswald is out with a new study, co-authored with David Blanchflower, that sheds more light on the link between unemployment and home ownership rates:
CNBC NetNet
John Carney | Senior editor

An interesting conundrum. 

John proposes an Austrian solution based on "malinvestment." But I tend to regard that kind of explanation as giving a reason instead of showing a causal factor. 

There's a big difference between reasons and causes. There are lots of reasonable explanations. The challenge of scientific explanation is to identify which of the many reasons are actually causal factors.

Bill Mitchell — Case Study – British IMF loan 1976 – Part 1

I am now using Friday’s blog space to provide draft versions of the Modern Monetary Theory textbook that I am writing with my colleague and friend Randy Wray. We expect to complete the text during 2013 (to be ready in draft form for second semester teaching). Comments are always welcome. Remember this is a textbook aimed at undergraduate students and so the writing will be different from my usual blog free-for-all. Note also that the text I post is just the work I am doing by way of the first draft so the material posted will not represent the complete text. Further it will change once the two of us have edited it.
Case Study – The British IMF loan in 1976
Bill Mitchell – billy blog
Case Study – British IMF loan 1976 – Part 1
Bill Mitchell


Philip Pilkington — Labour's forgotten jobs guarantee

The noises Labour now makes are at odds with a promising proposal early this year to find work for the long-term unemployed
The Guardian (UK)
Labour's forgotten jobs guarantee
Philip Pilkington
(h/t andy Blatchford via FB)

Way to go, Phil!

John T. Harvey — How Fiscal 'Responsibility' Creates Unemployment

It is lost on so many people that our problem today is not related to our inability to produce the goods and services in demand. We have the capacity. Heck, unemployment six years ago this month was only 4.6% and there is zero reason we can’t be there again. Nor could we ever run out of dollars, since we make them! The problem is jobs, and the government can and must create these. The absolute last thing they should be doing is exactly what they are doing: eliminating them.
Forbes | Pragmatic Economics
How Fiscal 'Responsibility' Creates Unemployment
John T. Harvey | Professor of Economics, Texas Christian University

Money and Public Purpose — A Conversation In Response To Usyd Seminar On Macroeconomic Policymaking

Below is a discussion between a number of economists that emerged out of the May 31st MMPPx seminar on Macroeconomic Policymaking in Small, Open Economies: An Australian Perspective, held at the University of Sydney.
Money and Public Purpose
A Conversation In Response To Usyd Seminar On Macroeconomic Policymaking
(h/t Rohan Grey on FB)




Greg Fisher — Beyond the plc

On Monday Civitas published a book written by me and Paul Ormerod entitled “Beyond the plc”. A press release and summary can be found on Civitas’ website here.

In this article I want to provide some background to this work in two broad ways. First, I will frame our thinking in the context of collective action (helping distinguish it from any political ideology). And, second, I’ll mention how our approach takes an evolutionary (or ‘complex’) view of the economy. When discussing political ideologies, I will use libertarianism and statism as reference points, well aware that these do not represent the plethora of views in political philosophy.
Synthesis
Beyond the plc
Greg Fisher

Revisioning the joint stock corporation from a systems POV.

Thursday, June 6, 2013

Steve Keen's presentation on financial instability - Harvard 2013


My presentation on financial instability at the Harvard Law School "Re-theorizing Liquidity" seminar.
Keen Harvard 2013 Financial Intability [sic]
Steve Keen

Paul Meli — Does Credit Drive The Economy Part II

As a follow-up to my previous post on the subject, I decided to try an alternative methodology that compares gross public spending and net private debt on an annual basis in analyzing the composition of new money creation.
The View From Mars
Does Credit Drive The Economy Part II
Paul Meli

Wednesday, June 5, 2013

Stephanie Kelton wows at SF financial planner conference

The keynote speakers provided controversial opinions and research that challenge conventional views and generally accepted beliefs on the broader economy and government policies.
“The most thought-provoking session,” Pitney contends, “was the keynote of Dr. Stephanie Kelton, who introduced Modern Monetary Theory (MMT), which shows how our misplaced fears about government finance are actually costing the US economy trillions of dollars.”
Dr. Kelton, chair of the department of economics at the University of Missouri, Kansas City, presented evidence that strongly suggests that everyone in mainstream economics misunderstands how government finance interacts with the economy. She demonstrated how government finance is part of the domestic and global balance sheet.
“When federal inflows (taxes) and outflows (spending) are viewed as balance sheet items, we clearly see how everyone and everything is connected,” states Pitney. “Dr, Kelton presented a fascinating chart that illustrated the perfect symmetry of inflows and outflows among the US government, businesses, households and other countries,” he continues, “and how the outflows from one of those sectors shows up as inflows somewhere else.”
Dr. Kelton showed that government deficits are an important source of corporate profits. She pointed out, “The fiscal cliff and the sequester are 'customer killers,’ meaning that people have less money to spend and it is creating a massive drag on the economy. We need to cut taxes or increase spending now — debt is only half of the balance sheet.”
The keynote inspired Pitney to learn more and expand his understanding of MMT. He asserts, “If MMT is as robust as seems to be, this could be a game changer and has significant implications for the broader economy and our individual planning clients.”
PRWeb
Financial Coach Attends Nation’s Best Regional Financial Planning Conference
(h/t Senexx Art on FB)

Noah Smith — Should We Trust Economists?

They're fractious, frequently wrong, and have lost much of the public's faith. But their insights are still valuable -- as long as you don't expect them to predict the future.
The Atlantic
Should We Trust Economists?
Noah Smith | Assistant Professor of Finance, Stony Brook University

Tim Duy — Falling Inflation Expectations


Perhaps at best, quantitative easing does not cause higher inflation.  At worst, some argue it is actually deflationary.  The latter argument, however, will not get much support at the Federal Reserve, at least not yet....
My view is that asset purchases would be most effective if coupled with fiscal stimulus.  Working only through financial markets may be simply too restrictive to yield broad-based economic improvement. It is almost as if the Fed is trying to force a fire hose of policy through a garden hose.  Keep turning up the volume, and eventually that hose bursts.  And that might be what we are seeing in Japan.
Bottom Line:  Infaltion expectations are falling, and that by itself should complicate the Fed's expectation that they can start scaling back asset purchases at the end of the summer.  But falling inflation expectations may complicate monetary policy more broadly by revealing the limits to quantitative easing.  And Japan isn't helping.


Tim Duy's Fed Watch

Falling Inflation Expectations
Tim Duy



Hale Stewart — Mortgage Rates Rise; Mortgage Bonds Drop

The Financial Times outlines the the potential problems: "The change could affect the US economy in two ways: by making new loans less affordable, it could damp the recent recovery in house prices; and it could reduce the number of Americans refinancing into cheaper mortgages, eliminating savings that have boosted consumer spending." 
Bonddad
Mortgage Rates Rise; Mortgage Bonds Drop
Hale Stewart



Lord Keynes — Degrees of Laissez Faire



Lord Keynes categorizes economic schools based on the degree of government intervention they incorporate.


Social Democracy For The 21st Century: A Post Keynesian Perspective

Degrees of Laissez Faire
Lord Keynes

Michel Bauwens — Is Bitcoin a system designed to create bitcoin billionaires?

Bitcoin can be described as a deflationary currency, or even a mere (virtual) commodity. Like gold, bitcoins are valuable because of their scarcity — Bitcoin’s money supply is limited to 21 million of units. A feature, according to libertarians and gold standard advocates, yet a bug for many.
P2P Foundation Blog
Is Bitcoin a system designed to create bitcoin billionaires?
Michel Bauwens

Steve Keen — Keen Harvard Seminar Combining MCT and MMT (video)



My presentation at the Harvard Law School "Re-theorizing Liquidity Pro-Seminar". Shows how to use Minsky to model a mixed private-fiat money system.
Keen Harvard Seminar Combining MCT and MMT
Steve Keen

Al Jazeera — Turkey angry at US comments on protests

Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu has contacted US Secretary of State John Kerry to object to recent statements from Washington expressing concern over Turkey's handling of mass anti-government protests, a foreign ministry diplomat said....

Kerry on Monday said he was concerned by reports of excessive use of force by Turkish police to quell the biggest protests since Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan's decade in power, urging all sides to "avoid any provocations or violence."
Davutoglu assured Kerry an investigation was under way into the police response, the ministry source said.
The diplomat added that the foreign minister told Kerry the protests were not "extraordinary", comparing them to the Occupy Wall Street movement that sprang up in the United States in 2011.
Al Jazeera
Turkey angry at US comments on protests

Talk about rank hypocrisy. 

At least Turkey is promising to conduct an inquiry into police actions. In the US, where operations were coordinated by the Department of Homeland Security (read "secret police"), not so much. This would be laughable if it were not so pathetic.

Pepe Escobar — Elite Enrichment and Police Repression: The Sparks That Lead to the Turkish Rebellion

The plan to destroy one of Istanbul's last green spaces is part of a globally tested neoliberal plan to clear the way for economic enrichment at the top.
AlterNet
Elite Enrichment and Police Repression: The Sparks That Lead to the Turkish Rebellion
Pepe Escobar | Asia Time

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

Alasdair Macleod — Why gold is money

The great Austrian economist, von Mises, wrote that true money had to survive the regression test. Put simply, it must be established whether or not money had value before it was used as money; otherwise it is only a money-substitute which ultimately depends for its value on confidence. So we need to ask ourselves two questions: what value did gold have before it was used as money, and what value did modern currencies have before they were used as money?
The answer to the first question is clear. Anyone who has seen the Alfred jewel in the Ashmolean Museum in Oxford (over 1,000 years old), the Snettisham torc in the British Museum (over 2,000 years old), or Tutankhamen’s gold mask in the Cairo Museum (over 3,000 years old), regard these fabulous items with astonishment. They are simply priceless, being desirable beyond reckoning. There is therefore no doubt that gold, the major element in all these objects, survives von Mises’s regression test. Furthermore the Aztecs and Incas in the New World, completely isolated from Eurasian values, held the same human view.
Paper currencies do not survive this test. They started as money-substitutes for gold or silver and over time lost all their convertibility. As a result they now depend for their value on confidence alone.
GoldMoney
Why gold is money
Alasdair Macleod

"The regression test." ROFL



Xinhua Business — China to become top U.S. export destination by 2022: report

China will overtake Canada and Mexico to become the United States' largest export market by 2022, according to a report issued Tuesday.
U.S. exports to China will at least triple from the current level to reach 530 billion U.S. dollars, according to a report compiled by the China-United States Exchange Foundation, the China Center for International Economic Exchanges, China's Ministry of Commerce, and the U.S.-based Center for Strategic and International Studies.
Exports to China will create a GDP worth 460 billion U.S. dollars for the United States, as well as create more than 3.34 million jobs, an increase of 2.63 million compared to 2010.
If the United States loosens its export restrictions on high-tech and energy products, the export volume could be much higher, the report said.


Harald Benink and Harry Huizinga — The urgent need to recapitalise Europe’s banks

Europe has been postponing the recapitalisation of its banking sector. This column argues that it has been doing so for far too long. Without such a recapitalisation, the danger is that economic stagnation will continue for a long period, thereby putting Europe on a course towards Japanese-style inertia and the proliferation of zombie banks.
VOX.eu

The urgent need to recapitalise Europe’s banks
Harald Benink, Professor of Banking and Finance and Fellow of the Centre for Economic Research (CentER), Tilburg University, and Harry Huizinga, Professor of International Economics in the Department of Economics, Tilburg University and CEPR Research Fellow

Giancarlo Corsetti and Luca Dedola — Is the euro a foreign currency to member states?

Spain and Britain have similar debt problems. So why does Spain face far higher sovereign-interest rates? Is this only about Eurozone membership? This column argues that Eurozone membership does not fully explain this discrepancy and that, in fact, it is central banks which cannot provide an effective backstop to national debt that are the root cause of high sovereign-interest rates. Eurozone members are more vulnerable to debt crises to the extent that the ECB cannot count on the joint support of national fiscal authorities.
VOX.eu
Is the euro a foreign currency to member states?
Giancarlo Corsetti, Professor of Macroeconomics, University of Cambridge and Programme Director, CEPR, and Luca Dedola, Adviser in the Directorate General Research, European Central Bank; Research Affiliate, CEPR