Thursday, May 7, 2020

Bill Mitchell — MMT critiques need to get more inventive – it’s getting boring


Talking points. 

The so-called MMT critics need to read more MMT in order to actually criticize MMT. They are criticizing MMT based on straw man arguments. I, too, am getting bored with plodding through it to see if anyone has come up with anything substantial. 

Without doing the necessary prep, criticism appears not only unprofessional. In this case, it also leads to the question of whether the criticism is an ideological attempt to control the narrative by influence based on supposedly "expert opinion."

MMT needs better critics. Positions grow stronger when faced with informed criticism that is constructive rather than destructive or dismissive.

The good news is that now most critics are admitting than major points of MMT are correct and seek to deflect it with spurious premises that are still widely held, mostly "inflation." MMT economists are quite nuanaced  in their analysis of inflation and how to address it should they begin building.

Bill explains some nuance.
Let me state clearly, at the outset, there may be an inflationary spike coming out of this diabolical mess....
Bill Mitchell – billy blog
MMT critiques need to get more inventive – it’s getting boring
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

9 comments:

Matt Franko said...

"MMT needs better critics."

lol the critics are the ones the top policy people are actually listening to...

S400 said...

”lol the critics are the ones the top policy people are actually listening to...”

Doesn’t change that the critics are at crap level.

Matt Franko said...

Well they dont think they are crap level...

S400 said...

Duh!

Peter Pan said...

A critic isn't necessarily someone who tells you what you want to hear.

S400 said...

A critic isn’t necessarily someone you want to listening to. Listening to repeated critique which doesn’t hold water is as fruitful as listening to whining.

Matt Franko said...

"doesn't hold water..."

S, your solid B average is in serious jeopardy....

S400 said...

Trump grading again. Don’t count in the real world.

S400 said...

“Well they dont think they are crap level...”

Your Trump grades are going down.

You have to earn an art degree in the real world not just envy those who have them.