Wednesday, March 22, 2023

William Mitchell — Former Bank of Japan governor challenges the current monetary policy consensus

In the latest IMF Finance and Development journal (March 2023), there is an interesting article by the former governor of the Bank of Japan, Masaaki Shirakawa – It’s time to rethink the foundation and framework of monetary policy. It goes to the heart of the complete confusion that is now being demonstrated by central bank policy makers. With their ‘one trick pony’ interest rate attacks on inflation, not only have they been inconsequential in dealing with that target (the so-called price stability responsibility), but, in failing there, they have undermined the achievement of the other central bank target (financial stability) and probably worsened the chances of sustaining the third target (full employment). Sounds like a mess – and it is. We are witnessing what happens when Groupthink finally takes over an academic discipline and the policy making space. Blind, unidirectional policies, based on a failed framework, steadily undermining all the major goals – that is where we are right now. And not unsurprisingly, those who have previously preached the doctrine are now crossing the line and joining with those who predicted this mess. And, as usual, the renegade position is somehow recast as we knew it all along’ when, of course, they didn’t. When you get to that stage, we need music – and given it is Wednesday, I oblige at the end of this post....
Bill nails it. Central banks have lost the plot. What Bill doesn't draw attention to in the highlighted sentence is that the primary purpose of a central bank and the underlying rationale for having one at all in a free market system based on economic liberalism is to ensure the financial stability of the credit system that underlies modern production economies.

William Mitchell — Modern Monetary Theory
Former Bank of Japan governor challenges the current monetary policy consensus
Bill Mitchell |rofessor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

See also

Naked Capitalism
How Monetary Policy Affects Bank Lending and Financial Stability: A ‘Credit Creation Theory of Banking’ Explanation
Peter Bofinger, Professor for Monetary Policy and International Economics University of Wuerzburg; Lisa Geißendörfer, Research Associate, Chair for Monetary Policy and International Economics University of Wuerzburg; Thomas Haas, Research Associate, Chair for Monetary Policy and International Economics University of Wuerzburg; and Fabian Mayer, Research Assistant and PhD candidate, Chair for Monetary Policy and International Economics University of Wuerzburg. Originally published at VoxEU

3 comments:

Peter Pan said...

If it works, break it.
If it's broke, don't fix it.

- Monetary Policy for Dummies 101

Matt Franko said...

FRA actually says “maximum employment with stable prices”


ie doesn’t say “full employment and no inflation”…

“with” doesnt imply duality it implies complementary…

Powell has testified the other day that we are at maximum employment…

Peter Pan said...

Did Powell testify that Ukraine is winning the war?

Because if he did, it must be true...