Showing posts with label Bernanke. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bernanke. Show all posts

Thursday, October 5, 2017

What, if anything, does Kevin Warsh understand?

I came across this article by Kevin Warsh that appeared in the Wall Street Journal last August, 2016. The article was re-posted by GATA.ORG.

As you may know, Warsh is the currently the favorite to take over as Fed Chair when Janet Yellen's term expires next February.

If you read the article you will find that Warsh sort of understands that Fed policy is confused and focused on either the wrong things or, things which the Fed has no set of tools to accomplish. On the other hand he seems to lack any ideas of his own on how to reform the Fed or, even what policies outside of monetary policy would be useful. In addition he appears to not understand the primary function of the Fed as rate setter.

First he says,

"Can't explain current inflation readings below their targets."

He might be alluding to himself here. That's because Warsh was spectacularly wrong back in 2008 and 2009 when, as a board member of hte Bernanke Fed, he predicted soaring inflation as a result of ZIRP and Quantitative Easing. It was almost as if Warsh was reading from one of Peter Schiff's scripts at the time. He's still really confused on this.

Next
"A numeric change in the inflation target isn't real reform. It serves more as subterfuge to distract from monetary, regulatory, and fiscal errors. A robust reform agenda requires more rigorous review of recent policy choices and significant changes in the Fed's tools, strategies, communications, and governance."

Warsh gets this correct. Central banks seem to conflate inflation with growth. Inflation targets are not the same as growth targets. The Bank of Japan is a good example. It's been on a 25 year quest to bring inflation up. It's growth that they need in Japan, not inflation. Meanwhile all of the BOJ's policies are deflationary, such as negative rates and trillions upon trillions in asset purchases.

He makes this observation, which is a an obvious and good observation.

"Two major obstacles must be overcome: groupthink within the academic economics guild, and the reluctance of central bankers to cede their new power."

He its the nail on the head with the "groupthink" within the academic guild as he calls it. Unfortunately, he is a card carrying member of that guild.

"First, the economics guild pushed ill-considered new dogmas into the mainstream of monetary policy. The Fed's mantra of data-dependence causes erratic policy lurches in response to noisy data. Its medium-term policy objectives are at odds with its compulsion to keep asset prices elevated. Its inflation objectives are far more precise than the residual measurement error. Its output-gap economic models are troublingly unreliable."

He's correct here, too. The Fed looks at data, which is notoriously lagging. Furthermore, there's not much the Fed can do other than set prices via the interest rate channel and make loans. It needs to use those tools in a leading fashion to whatever extent they can help achieve its mandate. The "data" follows.

"The Fed seeks to fix interest rates and control foreign-exchange rates simultaneously -- an impossible task with the free flow of capital."

With this statement he appears completely ignorant of the Fed's rate setting role. He sounds like Jim Rogers or, Schiff, again. He thinks the market sets rates. Does he not understand that all the Fed has to do would be to set the fed funds rate at zero, permanently, and all rates along the term structure would converge there? It has nothing to do with capital flows. (Whatever that means.) Similarly, negative rates would strengthen the dollar while high interest rates would fuel inflation and erode the dollar's  exchange value.

"The Fed often treats financial markets as a beast to be tamed, a cub to be coddled, or a market to be manipulated. It appears in thrall to financial markets, and financial markets are in thrall to the Fed, but only one will get the last word."

For a Harvard trained lawyer his wording is quite colorful here. A bit flowery even. However, it's true that the Fed is a slave to the markets. Yellen won't do anything unless Fed fund futures tell her to do it. Bernanke would "poll"  market participants as to the size of QE the Fed should perform.

I come away with the sense that Warsh knows the Fed needs reform, but he doesn't know in what fashion, exactly. He also doesn't understand the Fed's power as a monopolist. He mentions "fiscal errors," but doesn't say what they are. He probably thinks too much debt and deficits.

Bottom line is, we can make a lot of money off this guy if he gets in.





Friday, October 30, 2015

Here is the maximum level that the Fed can raise rates and no further. Your question is answered.


A lot of people have been saying the Fed can't raise rates that much or, the market won't let the Fed raise much or the economy won't or whatever. That's all bunk. None of those things matter, however, we can construct a model of just how far the Fed can raise rates, based on the knowledge that they must pay interest on reserves OUT OF THEIR OWN EARNINGS!

First let me mention that the Fed turned over $100 billion to the Treasury in FY 2015, so we know how much the Fed earns: $100 billion. That's how much it earns so that's how much it can pay.

On a portfolio of assets of $4.5 trillion, the Fed is earning about 2.2%. Actually, maybe a little bit more because its making most of its money on holdings of government securities ("those babies" in the words of Alan Simpson) and that amounts to $4.2 trillion so that's a return of 2.4%.

There's $4.5 trillion in reserves (equivalent to the Fed's assets by definition).

So the answer to how high the Fed can raise is 2.4%. That's it. After that it's out of money and you know DAMN WELL that there is no way Janet Yellen would go to Congress to ask for money to pay interest. NO WAY.

When the Fed didn't have to pay interest on reserves it was the Treasury's expense, but Ben Bernanke, in all his wisdom, convinced Congress back in 2008 that HE wanted that expense for some reason. Not exactly a Donald Trump, art of the deal, move. Before that, the Fed had the power to raise to infinity. Again, Treasury was on the hook to pay.

So, there's the answer to that question for anyone who is wondering. The maximum the Fed can raise is 2.4%. After that, it's literally out of money.

Feel free to distribute.

Tuesday, July 28, 2015

Was I right or was I right? Stupid eventually sinks to the bottom.

Back in 2012 I wrote an article about hedge fund little boy, David Einhorn.



(Click on the image above to read the entire post.)

In that post I talked about how Einhron was at some conference and made some really stupid idiotic comments like these:

"Norway is the only country in the world which can finance itself."
"China is misunderstood and is not an investment opportunity because it doesn't have enough money to feed the economy."

Norway can "finance" itself? Yeah, um, is that a revelation? (He's right, but for the wrong reasons.)

And China doesn't have enough yuan? Is he serious?

I think at that conference or shortly thereafter Einhorn announced that he had a huge position in gold because he said that he had dinner with Bernanke and was scared shitless at the answers to the questions he  posed to the former Fed Chairman. His thoughts went something like, "Wow, all this QE and 'money printing' is going to create hyperinflation."

Right...he didn't even BEGIN to understand monetary operations. Nothing. Nada. Zilch. Totally fucking clueless.

And NOW we see this:



Hahahaaha!!!!!!! The gods have delivered!!

Einhorn has deservedely been slaughtered in gold. He's Schiff with a bigger purse and maybe not for long!

These guys are the worst...the absolute, worst. As far as I am concerned they cannot lose money quick enough. If governemnt won't "euthanize" them, which they won't, then maybe they'll just die off from their own stupidity. But that's probably wishful thinking because I'm sure they'll  just get their bought politicians friends to enact laws and policies that force their victims to pay them back for all their losses.

Yes, Einhorn's a billionaire and for the life of me I will never be able to figure out how that happened. If Einstein were alive today he'd have trouble with that, too, and by the way, Albert Einstein was arguably one of the smartest humans to ever walk the planet, but he made like $60k per year in today's money. Just sayin'.

What irony...Einsten and Einhorn. The names sound very similar, but BOY, what a difference.


Wednesday, January 29, 2014

Taper is not the removal of stimulus, it's the opposite













Fed announced it will buy another $10 billion per month in securities. That means monthly purchases down to $65 billion from $85 billion. That means $240 billion of securities remain in the economy, earning interest each year.

At an average of 3% coupon, that means the economy GAINS about $7.5 billion in income. Gaining income is NOT tightening or removal of stimulus.

If the Fed does a $10 billion reduction every month now, that will start to add up quick. For every $10 billion of reduced purchases that equates to about $3.6 billion of new income to the economy. Do the math.

It's stimulus, not removal of stimulus.

The market's got it all wrong.

Thursday, May 30, 2013

Andrew Lainton — No, the Negro DGSE model does not Predict the Great Recession

A great deal of chatter on the blogosphere on a paper by Negro, Giannoni and Schorfheide of the NY Fed that DGSE can predict the great recession. Noahopinion discusses it the day after he musedabout what use was DGSE.
What they do is take the most well known New Keynsian model Smets-Wouters (2007) New Keynesian model and add on the the “financial accelerator” model of Bernanke, Gertler, and Gilchrist (1999). In the Financial Accelerator model credit shocks transmit through the real economy through amongst other reasons undermining the value of collatoral.
Both Noah and Mark Thoma’s reaction is ‘pah’ we could have predicted the Great Recession all along, we knew how we just didnt put two and two together’. But the Negro et al. is not a ‘forecast’ had they had the model in 2007 they would not have predicted the Great Recession. This quite apart from the criticism made by some commentators that they have engaged in post-hoc calibration of parameters to fit the result. I don’t make that accusation simply that the result forecasts nothing because their baseline data....
Decisions, Decisions, Decisions,
No, the Negro DGSE model does not Predict the Great Recession
Andrew Lainton


Wednesday, December 12, 2012

The Fed trying its best to help Jim Rogers, Schiff, Naseem Taleb, Kyle Bass and the other Austrian clowns make money

Boy, the Fed must feel real sorry for Jim Rogers, Peter Schiff, Naseem Taleb, Kyle Bass and all the other clueless, Austrian, debt doomsday, non-MMT types. It looks like the central bank is venturing out with a totally different approach to try to help these poor fools make money.

We all know the aforementioned have been shorting Treasuries mercilessly for at least the past four years, losing vast sums for themselves or their sorry followers, despite the fact that the Fed had been TELLING THEM not to sell the Treasury market at least until 2015. But, noooooo...these geniuses just wouldn't listen.

(Psssssst...they still think it's the bond vigilantes or the Chinese who set U.S. interest rates. We MMTers know better!)

So apparently out of deep concern for their bleeding pocketbooks, Bernanke & Co. is now telling the, "We're a debtor nation" (please say it in the voice of an old prospector) crowd that they can refrain from going short until the unemployment rate falls below 6.5%. Or to put it another way, they can go long until then.

As much as I'd like to think these clueless wonders are going to catch on, something tells me that their philanthropy to the MMT side (read: long side) of the Treasury market is going to continue.

Yes Lauren, it is true what they say about fools and their money. Hey folks, don't feel bad. Just think of it as doing a public service.

Wednesday, August 29, 2012

Senator Bob Corker Whining to British Bankers About the US Fed.

commentary by Roger Erickson

Bernanke should show some humility

Overall, Corker's article causes my hair to stand on end. More than anything else, it makes me feel that there's a banking lobby once again running circles around US policy - a lobby that has Congressmen eating out of their hands. People this confused should NOT be on the Senate Banking Committee.

First off, why on earth would a US Congressman publish a rant in the FT, a bankers rag in a foreign country? That strikes me the same way LIBOR does, catering to a London banking cartel vs your own constituency. We don't need our Congresspeople discussing our policy in foreign newspapers.

Plus, the article is riddled with inconsistencies. (Fed watching is a distraction ... so complain about the Fed! Really?) Maybe we could send Corker some Nike shoes, with a note saying "Just Do It" ?

After reading the article, I'm not sure exactly why Corker is bringing up the issues he mentions, in a letter to a foreign banking newspaper. Classic politics? Bring up a few valid points, but twist their relevance?

For whatever reason, Corker has a problem with the Fed's dual mandate.

'A big part of the problem is that the US Congress has given the Fed an overly broad "dual mandate" of price stability and full employment. In 1978 Congress congratulated itself for “ending unemployment” via its passage of the Humphrey-Hawkins Act, which added full employment to the Federal Reserve’s existing mandate. This approach has not only proved unsound. It undermines the free market system, allows Congress to use the central bank as a scapegoat while avoiding tough policy decisions, and creates Fed addicts in our financial markets.'

He might have had a bit of a point there, if some Congresspeople really thought they'd delegated responsibility by abrogating it! Yet that's only a fraction of the whole story. He's doing the Humphrey-Hawkins Act a sweeping & severe disservice, and pandering to the 1% who would prefer right of first refusal on private ownership of any publicly-funded R&D. I smell a rat!

'[The Fed's Dual Mandate] undermines the free market system, allows Congress to use the central bank as a scapegoat while avoiding tough policy decisions, and creates Fed addicts in our financial markets.'

Perhaps, but that's no excuse for not acting like a Senator! If he were serious, wouldn't he be having this conversation with colleagues behind closed doors? This sort of public rant in a foreign banker's newspaper would irritate me if I were trying to serve on the Banking Committee. So what's the real purpose? Was the rant requested by certain lobbyists? For what reason? Who are Corker's financial advisors and main campaign finance contributors?

"We are one of the only developed countries in the world that has such a mandate. The European Central Bank, the Bank of England and the Bundesbank, to name but a few examples, all have single mandates."

First, wanting to be like the ECB or other CBs is not necessarily a positive!  Second, it's questionable how true his thesis is. And either way, what's the point for a Congressman responsible for shaping domestic banking policy? I have a bad feeling that Corker simply doesn't know what he's talking about, and is being used & abused by his campaign donors.

Comments at the FT article are all over the place, but one raises a killer point:

"This is the gentleman who when he had a chance to question Jamie dimon. Just brushed aside any serious questions and showered praise on the gentleman- these are the same guys who don't want any regulation" [sic]

In publishing his letter to the FT, what is Bob Corker showing?


Tuesday, April 3, 2012

Keystone Cops at the Fed!


Just reported on CNBC that the Fed is running out of short-term securities to sell.

As you know, the Fed has been selling short-term securities as part of Operation Twist (and buying long-term securities).

Where does the Fed get short term securities in the first place?

It gets them when the Treasury sells T-Bills every week. Then the Fed goes and buys back those same bills from the public as part of their normal monetary operations/interest rate setting activity.

Actually, the purchase of T-bills by the Fed is the same thing as the government having never sold them in the first place. (Think about it…the government sells them, then the Fed buys them. It's like the gov't never sold them in the first place.)

Anyway, if the Fed runs out of short-term securities it could just very easily step aside and let the Treasury sell the bills and not worry about it. It’s the exact same thing as the Treasury first selling them, followed by the Fed buying them, followed by the Fed selling them AGAIN. (It’s even simpler, right?)

But, no, they don’t want to do it that way because of the PERCEPTION that if the Fed only bought long-term securities and didn’t sell short-term securities, then somehow that would constitute “printing money” and everyone would jump all over them for that.

In other words they either can’t or are AFRAID to explain the simple mechanics of what is going on. They prefer to go through this whole exercise in obfuscation and I wouldn’t be surprised if they actually even create some new “Fed bond” which will cause the whole world to wonder what is going on, in order for them to avoid having to explain to people how the whole system works.

It’s the Keystone Cops…literally.

If it were not for the fact that these people are in charge of our economy, the whole thing would be hilarious. Instead, it’s just pathetic!