Showing posts with label distributional effects. Show all posts
Showing posts with label distributional effects. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 28, 2019

Lars P. Syll — a primary reason for the rise of inequality


Economic liberalism expressed as "free market capitalism" aka neoliberalism is incompatible with political liberalism as liberal democracy owing to the social effects of the inequality that favoring economic liberalism in the above sense leads.

Lars P. Syll’s Blog
Economics — a primary reason for the rise of inequality
Lars P. Syll | Professor, Malmo University

Wednesday, August 21, 2019

Bill Mitchell — The rich are getting richer in Australia while the rest of us mark time

Only a short blog post today – in terms of actual researched content. Plenty of announcements and news though, a cartoon, and some great music. I have been meaning to write about the household income and wealth data that the ABS released in July, which showed that real income and wealth growth over a significant period for low income families has been close to zero, while the top 20 per cent have enjoyed rather massive gains. These trends are unsustainable. A nation cannot continually be distributing income to the top earners who spend less overall while starving the lower income cohorts of income growth. A nation cannot also continually create wealth accumulation opportunities for the richest while the rest go backwards. These trends generate spending crises, asset bubbles and social instability. That is what is emerging in Australia at present.
While Bill's analysis in this post is Aussie-centric, the rationale is applicable to the whole neoliberal world. It's basically what neoliberalism is about. The contemporary difference is that now the domestic populations of the neoliberal nations are being colonized as well. Even some of the top tier that are receiving most of the benefits are getting squeamish, realizing that an unsustainable process cannot go on forever and that eventually the bill will come due.

Bill Mitchell – billy blog
The rich are getting richer in Australia while the rest of us mark time
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

Wednesday, June 12, 2019

Why it’s important to pay attention to distributional consequences of economic policies — Somin Park

In the decades following the 1980s, free market policies dominated policy agendas across the world. The gains from growth, however, were not broadly shared within countries, as evidenced by the high levels of economic inequality in the United States and most other advanced economies. In a recent paper, a group of economists at the International Monetary Fund argue for a rethinking of the rules—actual or perceived—that guide economic policies, so that the distributional consequences are considered and addressed by policymakers.
In their paper, IMF economists Jonathan D. Ostry, Prakash Loungani, and Davide Furceri argue there are four primary reasons why it is critical to pay greater attention to how economic gains are shared up and down the income ladder. First, their research shows that economic inequality leads to lower and less durable growth. Even when growth is the primary goal, attention to inequality is necessary. Second, they find that economic inequality may lead to social tension and ultimately political backlash against free market policies, including globalization. Third, redistributive policies to curb excessive inequality tend to support, not slow, economic growth. And fourth, many aspects of economic inequality are the result of policy choices made by governments, meaning policymakers should factor in the distributional consequences when designing and evaluating policies.

A disproportionate focus on growth over distribution was solidified among economists during the 1980s with the consensus view that the benefits of growth would trickle down the income ladder. Governments and institutions such as the IMF dismissed questions of distribution as secondary to growth, based on their confidence in markets to reward everyone fairly and their belief that redistributive policies hurt growth.

Ostry, Loungani, and Furceri question this conventional wisdom by showing that high inequality is bad not only for social reasons but also for growth....
Based on their findings about fiscal consolidation and capital account liberalization, the authors ask “why support them if there are scarce efficiency benefits for them but palpable equity costs?” The answer is important because fiscal consolidation and capital account liberalization are two policies that have historically been at the center of the IMF’s economic reform agenda. This paper is one illustration of a shift in policy priorities at the IMF, where leaders increasingly recognize that liberalization and tight fiscal policy are not always suited for sustainable economic growth....
A cardinal rule in conventional economics is to consider only production and consumption and to ignore distribution on the assumption that the "market forces" as "the magic of the market" lead to Pareto optimal distribution (through "trickle down").  That's magical thinking. Turns out to be "black magic," too.

WCEG — The Equitablog
Why it’s important to pay attention to distributional consequences of economic policies
Somin Park | Research Assistant to the Executive Director

Saturday, December 30, 2017

David F. Ruccio — It’s the profits, stupid!


I would phrase it somewhat differently: "It's the distribution, stupid."

The social and political problems arise from grossly asymmetrical distribution and the ensuing distributional effects economically through highly asymmetrical income and wealth.

Occasional Links & Commentary
It’s the profits, stupid!
David F. Ruccio | Professor of Economics, University of Notre Dame

Tuesday, May 2, 2017

Bill Mitchell — The poor are getting poorer in the US

Yes, the ‘politics of envy’. That is one of the epithets that the neo-liberal apologists use to defend the fact that the top-end-of-town are increasingly seizing the major proportion of any growth in wealth. They claim that shifts in the distribution of wealth and income do not matter if the levels of each distributional cohort (say, a decile or quintile) are all moving up. They ask the question: Why should a poor person care if a rich person is getting much richer as long as the poor are becoming less poor in absolute terms? The facts are that in advanced countries, the wealth accumulation of the last three decades has not been particularly beneficial to the poorest members of society. The rich have experienced massive gains in wealth even if the poor have enjoyed modest gains. But in the US, not only has the wealth distribution moved heavily towards the top end, the bottom 50 per cent now have less wealth than they had before the GFC began and have not increased their wealth since 1989 (when comparable data is available). And further, even if the bottom end of the distribution improved their absolute position, it still remains a major problem for wealth to be increasingly concentrated among the rich. It erodes the democratic process and increases social polarisation.
Spillover effects. The social, political and economic aspects of a society are entangled and influence each other.

Bill Mitchell – billy blog
The poor are getting poorer in the US
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

Saturday, July 2, 2016

Branko Milanovic — The greatest reshuffle of individual incomes since the Industrial Revolution

The effects of of globalisation on income distributions in rich countries have been studied extensively. This column takes a different approach by looking at developments in global incomes from 1988 to 2008. Large real income gains have been made by people around the median of the global income distribution and by those in the global top 1%. However, there has been an absence of real income growth for people around the 80-85th percentiles of the global distribution, a group consisting of people in ‘old rich’ OECD countries who are in the lower halves of their countries’ income distributions.
Formerly Lead Economist in the World Bank's research department, Branko Milanovic gets that today doing macroeconomic properly in a connected world of open economies that the only closed economy is the world economy, and it is the proper study of macroeconomics. What passes for macroeconomics conventionally is based on the study of national economies which openness is often an afterthought. This is the study of mesoeconomics rather than actual macroeconomics.

In this scheme, micro-economic is the study of aspects of national economies; meso-economics is the study of national economies, and macro-economics is the study of the global economy as a closed system inclusive of its subsystems. Micro, meso, and macro must of course mesh since they are the whole and its parts. As a complete system these aspects are complimentary and influence each others through the web of relationships that constitutes the global system's intricate network. This system is dynamic and it is also a complex adaptive system characterized by reflexivity and emergence.

It must be further noticed and acknowledged that the global economic system is an aspect the world system, which includes social, political, and economic aspects that are intimately connected so that isolating aspects of them risks oversimplification and distortion.

The challenge is not only to progress but to progress in a way that harmonizes the social, political and economic aspects of the system. Otherwise, not only imbalances but also conflict will be the likely result, owing to winners and losers.

vox.eu
The greatest reshuffle of individual incomes since the Industrial Revolution
Branko Milanovic | Visiting Presidential Professor, Graduate Center, University of New York and Senior Scholar, Luxembourg Income Center

Thursday, April 7, 2016

Bill Mitchell — Distributional conflict and inflation – Britain in the early 1970s

In the previous instalment of this series of blogs I am writing, which will form the input to my next book on globalisation and the capacities of the nation-state, which I am working on with Italian journalist Thomas Fazi, I covered the role of trade unions in a capitalist system where class conflict is a major dynamic. One of the characteristics of the post-modern Left is the denial of the role trade unions play in inflationary episodes. However, once we accept that the unions are creatures of capitalism and embody of the conflictual nature of income distribution within that mode of production, then it is clear that as a countervailing force against capital, unions can precipitate economic crisis if they are ‘too successful’. Too successful in this context refers to the use of their power to control the supply of labour which negative impacts on the rate of profit earned by capital and leads to a decline in investment and a rise in unemployment. Trade unions are a problem for capital. Today, we consider the way in which this ‘problem’ manifested in the inflation in Britain in the early to mid-1970s and the failure by the British Labour Party to fully understand the causation involved. By the mid-1970s, the British Labour government had surrendered to the growing dominance of the Monetarist school of thought, which diverted its gaze from the true nature of the economic crisis. They unnecessarily called in the IMF as a result of this blindness.
Bill Mitchell – billy blog
Distributional conflict and inflation – Britain in the early 1970s
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

Monday, October 5, 2015

John Quiggin — Would a significant increase in the top (US) marginal income tax rate substantially alter income inequality?


Yes. At the tails.
It’s obvious, as the authors note, that the 90-50 measure won’t change, since neither group is affected (there’s no simulation of behavioral responses which might have indirect effects). But, since the 99-th percentile income is very close to $400k, there’s very little impact on this group either. But the tax, as modelled, raises a lot of money from the ultra-rich incomes. As a result, distributing the proceeds at the bottom of the distribution raises incomes substantially, which explains the big changes in the 90-10 and 99-10 ratios.
The real lesson to be learned here, one I came to pretty slowly myself is that old-style measures looking at quintiles or even percentiles of the income distribution are no longer very relevant. The real question, in the economy of Capital in the 21st Century is how much should go to the ultra-rich.
John Quiggin
Would a significant increase in the top (US) marginal income tax rate substantially alter income inequality?

Monday, July 27, 2015

Nick Bunker — Rising U.S. compensation inequality and productivity growth

If the question you want to answer is ultimately how well labor as a whole is being compensated for its productivity, this data choice is the right way to go. Lawrence finds evidence of a break between productivity and average labor compensation around 2000, just as he did in a recent National Bureau of Economic Research working paper. This break means that labor as a whole is receiving a declining share of income, with the gains from productivity go to the owners of capital instead.
But what if we want to think about how productivity growth results in rising standards of living for workers on different rungs of the economic ladder? Then we need to look at what’s happening to the distribution of compensation. It may have been that compensation for labor as a whole tracked productivity until 2000, but it’s not clear how well productivity growth was translating into growth and higher living standards for all workers.
Note: The assumption of trickle down is that higher growth rate per capita implies a higher standard of living for all through distributional effects based on market forces.

WCEG — The Equitablog
Rising U.S. compensation inequality and productivity growth
Nick Bunker

Wednesday, June 24, 2015

IMF Direct — Growth’s Secret Weapon: The Poor and the Middle Class


It's the demand, stupid.
Earlier IMF work has shown that income inequality is bad for growth and its sustainability. Our new research shows that income distribution itself—not just the level of income inequality—matters for growth.
Specifically, we find that making the rich richer by one percentage point lowers GDP growth in a country over the next five years by 0.08 percentage points—whereas making the poor and the middle class one percentage point richer can raise GDP growth by as much as 0.38 percentage points (Chart 2). Put simply, boosting the incomes of the poor and the middle class can help raise growth prospects for all.
One possible explanation is that the poor and the middle class tend to consume a higher fraction of their income than the rich. If more money flows to these segments of society, they will consume rather than save, raising demand and spurring aggregate growth in the short run. What this means is that the poor and the middle class are key engines of growth. But with inequality on the rise, those engines are stalling.
Over the longer run, persistent inequality means that the the poor and the middle class have fewer opportunities to get educated, enhance their skills, and pursue their entrepreneurial dreams. As a result, labor productivity and growth suffer.
Ya think?

IMF Direct
Growth’s Secret Weapon: The Poor and the Middle Class
Era Dabla-Norris, Kalpana Kochhar, and Evridiki Tsounta
ht Mark Thoma at Economist's View

Sunday, March 16, 2014

Brian Romanchuk — Inequality In Savings Drives Wealth Inequality

Paul Krugman discusses the dynamics of wealth inequality in a recent blog: Notes on Piketty (Wonkish).... In it, he uses the standard Solow model to explain rising inequality. Although I do not have a formal model, my reading of a stock-flow consistent models implies that his analysis is not quite correct. The driving force behind wealth inequality is the differential in savings amongst households, and with a second order effect being that larger portfolios may have greater returns on their assets.
Bond Economics
Inequality In Savings Drives Wealth Inequality
Brian Romanchuk

It's the distribution.

Monday, January 20, 2014

Peter Cooper — Unearned Income and its Distribution

In any society, there will be real output (real income) and real wealth that is not produced solely by humans. Some real income is due to the contribution of nature – land, natural resources, beneficial weather patterns, animals and so on. Some real income is produced by machines, robots and other means of production that were created by prior applications of labor in combination with nature. In any given accounting period, this real income is 'unearned' in the sense that it is not due to human effort exerted within the period. Much of it currently flows to industrial capitalists and rentiers on the basis of property ownership rather than productive contribution. Over time, the real productive contribution of means of production can be expected to rise, due to technical progress. In this post, a framework is tentatively suggested for thinking about the distribution of unearned income, both at a point in time and as it grows over time.
Heteconomist
Unearned Income and its Distribution
Peter Cooper

Wednesday, January 8, 2014

Alberto Mingardi — Hayekian arguments for basic income

Matt Zwolinski has an interesting article which attempts to answer the question "Why Did Hayek Support a Basic Income?". His answer is that Hayek did so because such a minimum endowment of economic means grants people the essential freedom to say "no"--thus making up for "real" freedom of contract. Matt stresses that Hayek was more concerned than most libertarians with the idea that "unbalanced" market relationships may also be a source of coercion.
I think Matt brings together a neat summary of some well-pondered arguments for a guaranteed minimum income. I would have thought, however, that the Hayekianarguments for a basic income were different.
I think that a Hayekian argument for the basic income is that it would minimize state interventions and, thus, discretionary powers on the part of lawmakers as opposed to contemporary welfare systems….
Thus, a basic minimum income is a smart solution to (a) keep our allegiance to the idea we shall accept some sort of poverty mitigation device but (b) refuse to accept the bureaucratization and the social and economic planning that inevitably comes with "organised benevolence", as Hayek repeatedly pointed out. By providing people with a basic income you do not play with prices (including the price of labour), and society spares herself the (self-interested) intermediation of a welfare apparatus. A basic income is less paternalistic, and may have seemed to Hayek a good way to avoid what happened in the years when he was writing, particularly in England: that is, increasing redistribution, nationalizations, and regulation of the economy going hand-in-hand.
Of course, the interesting question is: could this version of the idea of a basic income survive the test of the political process? And what about its unintended consequences? Hayek would have been fine with replacing the welfare state altogether with a basic income. In Europe at least, most advocates of the basic income are for adding it to the existing welfare provisions. If this happened, I suspect Hayek would not be very confortable in the position of the useful idiot (neither would Matt, for that matter).
Econolog
Hayekian arguments for basic income
Alberto Mingardi

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Richard Wilkinson: How economic inequality harms societies (TED)



Richard Wilkinson: How economic inequality harms societies
(h/t Dan Lynch in the comments)

Wild! The US is off the charts — in the wrong way.
"If Americans want to live the American dream, they should go to Denmark."
"General social dysfunction is related proportionately to inequality." 
The data is rather shocking. But the causality involved, which Wilkinson elaborares at the end, is encouraging. Inequality is not only correlated with social and psychological dysfunction, it is found to be a cause of it.

Decreasing inequality within a group improves social and psychological functioning. This provides a strong argument for adopting progressive social, political and economic principles for achieving the good society.

Thursday, June 7, 2012

Michael Sankowski — The Distributional Consequences of Monetary Policy


Mike responds to a recent Nick Rowe post. Nice quote from Wynne Godley, too.

Read it at Modern Monetary Realism
The Distributional Consequences of Monetary Policy
by Michael Sankowski

What I would add to it is that cb's running a NAIRU-based monetary policy raise rates to quell inflation, which typically happens as they see wage pressure developing in addition to rising CPI. This provokes an economic contraction that increases the buffer of unemployed and reduces labor bargaining power, decreasing wage pressure.

Then to stimulate the economy when sufficient consolidation has taken place, the cb lowers rates to spur borrowing and spur a new cycle of investment and consumption.

However, as Mike notes the lowering of interest rates translates first into rising asset prices with the distributional effects he notes. The as consumer borrowing increases, price pressures increase, which then results in wage pressure in reaction. Then, the cycle is repeated.

So the outcome is higher asset prices at the beginning of the cycle, then increasing consumer indebtedness, and then falling real wages resulting in increasing worker demands for increased wages to keep up with inflation.

So, yes, monetary policy does have distributional effects. There are winners and losers. See if you can identify them.