Showing posts with label mistakes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mistakes. Show all posts

Monday, November 4, 2013

We Need A "Defense_Against_Our_Own_Dis-Organization" Plan?

   (Commentary by Roger Erickson)






Really? Instead, how about a plan to protect grandchildren from having to re-learn tough lessons their grandparents learned the hard way, and their parents either forgot, or never learned?*

Is there an entry for that in ANYONE's economic ideology equations?

I thought not.

We need an Index Fund that allows citizens to invest in Democracy, and common sense, by exploring workable operations with a completely open mind.

The ideology we can discuss each evening, over whatever your particular ideology allows.

As an example, here are some suggested Criteria of a Sensible Grand Strategy.


* call it a Dumb-ass-selves Defense Plan? or just the Our_Own_Mistakes Defense Plan. No Asteroids required.

Friday, September 20, 2013

Precisely Managing Nonsense, With Double-Entry Accounting

Commentary by Roger Erickson

John Maynard Keynes once wrote of Hayek’s book Prices and Production:

“The book, as it stands, seems to me to be one of the most frightful muddles I have ever read, with scarcely a sound proposition in it beginning with page 45 … It is an extraordinary example of how, starting with a mistake, a remorseless logician can end up in Bedlam.” (Keynes 1931: 394).
The Horror of Rothbardian Natural Rights

One has to be aware of the purpose of evolving aggregates before assuming definitions for natural flows, and managing them with double-entry accounting. Otherwise, you end up rigorously managing nonsense.

Sense vs non-sense comes ONLY by the selection pressure of combining feedback from all channels, existing and emerging. There is no adaptive path in the natural world that isn't bounded by dynamic equilibria between locally conflicting forces, and local perspectives.

In the end, you can't square double-entry accounting with quantum mechanics. That should remind us to never lose track of the fact that it's accounting that has to yield to reality, not the other way around.

This reminds me of three, simple, ancient truths.
* Data is meaningless without context.
* The difference between [operations] & theory is greater in practice than in theory.
* Theory soon becomes meaningless if not constantly serving actual aggregate
[not sub-group] operations.

The definition of logic itself is looking for consistency in explaining unpredictable reality. Logic simply maps theory to discovered operations, and in the process selects sense from nonsense.

Interestingly, that seemed to be recognized by members of the Brain Trust who advise the FDR administrations through the astounding number of pragmatic experiments which they utilized, even though it was clear that they, themselves couldn't adequately model a completely new paradigm from the methods which context forced them to adopt, by trial and error. That had to wait for the operational summary called MMT.

STUART CHASE: SEMANTICIST EXTRAORDINARY

Chase, Stuart - Tyranny Of Words [pdf; $9 fee in USA]
  (Ironically, available here too, from Germany, free.)

One lesson is that we always need a survivable ratio of leaders and experimenters in policy offices responsible for our survival, and that we soon die if we instead fill those leadership offices with risk managers. We're always executing experiments on ourselves, no matter what we do. So we may as well have as leaders people able to rapidly learn from many mistakes, rather than those opposed to any change whatsoever, and terrified of making a mistake. The ultimate mistake is to not generate survivable ones as a survivable rate!



Sunday, February 17, 2013

The Long Mistake - and making enough mistakes to correct it

commentary by Roger Erickson

Mistakes are the things we make enough of to outline and define what we call success.  If we make enough mistakes, we fall into the remaining hole called success. You would think that could be easy.  To succeed, just make enough mistakes. Yet, idiots that we are, we invest considerable resources into trying to keep ourselves from actively exploring the very things that define success.

Every scientist learns that asking the right question is more than half way to finding a useful answer. The right question for now is why we keep trying to stop ourselves from making mistakes.  In fact, we set up whole institutions with the express mission of keeping ourselves from doing things that, in past situations, were deemed mistakes.  Where's the logic in that.  Do we really fear that once a person has made a mistake, they'll keep making it, forever?  Has there EVER been any evidence for that, throughout all of evolution, including the last second of it, which we call history?

Is it a mistake to actively demand that we make no mistakes?  The answer seems rather obvious once finally asked - "Yes." Why? Simple statistics. Given zero predictive power, we rely upon massively parallel selective power, aka, rapidly shared feedback about accelerating, distributed trial and error.  In other areas we call it, for example, combinatorial chemistry.  Social species simply practice constantly expanded, highly distributed, group exploration of group options. At present, however, we're actively refusing to explore the rapid trials & errors demanded by every succeeding situation which presents newly unpredictable options? It seems that we've misread our own group logic, and concluded with the oxymoron that assisted group suicide defines progress, while also making it illegal!  Werks fur oos!

How are we supposed to fall into a hole defined as not a mistake, if we systematically refuse to optimize statistical sampling and parsing of "mistake space?" By magic?  In the end, it's our rate of survivable mistakes that auto-defines our Adaptive Rate.

So, if many of our most cherished institutions list the definition of mistakes in one situation, how many things on their lists will usefully project - unchanged - to new and unpredictably altered situations? Specifically when those new situations require unbiased recombination and re-exploration of all options?  What?  Another right question?  The answer is an unequivocal "Exceedingly Few, If Any!"  So, are most of our institutions mistakes?  Yes and no.  They clearly apply to past situations, and must remain as bridges over the situations we've traversed.  Yet we must NOT use them to limit trial and error recombinant re-exploration of new situations.  We haven't carried all this massive skill at physical/chemical/biological recombination, sexual recombination, behavioral recombination, cultural recombination and "options recombination" this far simply to not use it!

In conclusion, our suicidal defense of credentialism is our main weapon for fighting our own evolution.  We use credentialism to secure beachheads to keep but also quickly leave behind in our journey through evolution-space.  In genetics we refer to that accumulation with phrases such as "ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny," or "junk DNA."  In building out virtual cultural variants based on - but projected from - human biology, we may use analogous terms such as "education recapitulates history" and "junk training exercises." The real value in such exercises is not junk, but they're not sufficient, and there is a remaining task.

The real point is tempo.  Our entire evolutionary past is constantly reassembled, in incredibly densely engineered steps, in 9 months of embryonic gestation.

How long does it take to prepare a human fetus and send it out with the skills needed to launch human biology and culture beyond anything it's entire history can predict?  Improving that ontologic/embryonic dance continues, with subtle steps that are incredibly arduous to select.

How long does it take to prepare human student-citizen groups and send THEM out with the skills needed to launch human culture beyond anything our entire cultural history could possibly predict? Are we putting in the arduous work to make, discriminate and select from enough minor mistakes?  Without making enough initial mistakes, and comparing notes widely and quickly enough, how can we "fall" into the next potential cultural success fast enough?

It's not just making permanent aristocracy out of previously temporary "tribal war chiefs" that is an example of a "Long Mistake."  We've also made orthodox economics as a court tool of aristocrats. Further, we've also made institutionalized rather than recombinant religions and other bureaucracies as a residual long-mistake to be manipulated by aristocrats.  And, there are harmonic oscillations of sub_long_mistakes - such as academia - within each of our bureaucracies. How many of our bureaucracies are caught up serving Long Mistakes, instead of serving group Adaptive Rate? Always too many, simply because we delay meaningful assessment and adequately honest group practice.

There are other, uncounted, parallel as well as residual long_mistakes as well, yet they are all example practices that keep us from maintaining the distributed mistake rates required to discriminate stasis from evolution, and accelerate selection of the latter.

Want yet another specific example?  The institutional concept of priests has been "one long mistake" as has, presumably, nearly the entire historical distribution of shamanistic and/or academically tenured mistakes.  They all attempt to help define success by exclusion.  Yet here we are, ritualizing memorization of the mistakes NOT to make, instead of focussing on earliest possible recognition of the successful holes that enough, survivable mistakes always expose.

How, indeed, do we accomplish the difficult task of stopping what we're doing too much of?  Once we've made enough mistakes to fall into success, can we let others get on with making enough NEWLY DISTRIBUTED mistakes,  fast enough, to fall into the new successes we can't possibly imagine?


Monday, December 17, 2012

Group Situational Awareness, and Handling Economic Mistakes

commentary by Roger Erickson


Do "males" vs "females" handle problems differently? If so, why? And what should we do about it?

This topic has come up again, in local discussions addressing the "fiscal cliff" idiocy - of all things. It's worth discussing, however, since it is another root of a situational awareness failure that affects ALL topics - not just "money," finance, budgets and economics.

My brief comment at the time was as follows.

"Simple biology. Females do far more of their work targeting developmental care, and support care - where mistakes are far more costly. Males do more of their work targeting adult-integration, where rampant selection markets apply, and mistakes are supposed to [be] made abundantly, frequently and quickly.

Mistakes during gestation or with newborns, or loss of women? Catastrophic.
Mistakes during hunting forays? Males are expendable."


For simplicity, let's leave aside the fact that there's more diversity within all biological categories than between their stereotypes, and instead just look at the context-dependent difference between those arbitrarily defined stereotypes. Even there, the author's question about women vs men isn't adequately phrased, because genders in a social species deal with every REAL context via teamwork. Who says diverse teammates are SUPPOSED to contribute to addressing group outcomes the same way?

Both mistakes & successes are simply changes in context, and swapping old options for a new set of options. Regardless of momentary judgements, the only relevant question is which of the NEW options to explore next, how soon, and how vigorously. Comebacks and novel paths are always possible, so it's only a question of QUICKLY analyzing ALL available feedback, and maintaining optimism vs pessimism.

Deeper point is that this is another educational example, of how we're grossly under-leveraging long available perspectives from our growing ranks of "professions" (not just genders, and not just in this particular research topic) - thereby leaving the bulk of us far too isolated from what is a VERY complex group situation. All data is meaningless without situational awareness, which today means full group-situational awareness.

The simplistic solution is Outcomes-Based Training & Education - but how do we do OBT&E on a NATIONAL scale? Eh? If that were easy, some culture would have done it. Hell. Let's be first!

Why not soon? To do that, we gotta ramp up the kinetics of both appreciating and then depreciating so-called "credentials" - which are only as useful as the last situation. Say, 5 minutes ago? Given our constantly expanding options, where's our joyfull sense of urgency, and our cheerful bias to action? Is that the biggest "mistake" we're ALL making ... together?

Who now - regardless of their placement in our biological "gender" distribution - is still afraid of the big, imaginary fiscal cliff?  Note to nation:  we got bigger/better/faster options to explore.  If there are people with "credentials" in the way, they have to go ... pronto.