Showing posts with label public economy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label public economy. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 11, 2019

What happened to the public economy in economics? — June Sekera


Important. Demonstrates the need for a return to political economy" to right the balance, which has swung too far in the direction of economic liberalism.

The problem is that the assumptions on which economic liberalism is based are ideological and not empirical, seeming to contradict what actually happens institutionally especially in democratic societies regarding "public goods." Economic liberalism assumes that public goods are only needed as a result of "market failure," so the solution is not to provide public goods but rather to correct the underlying market failure by allowing "free market" to work it magic through liberating natural "market forces" from government interference.

"Socialism" as managed fiscal policy is the target. Neoliberalism want to limit the role of government in economics to monetary policy set by a politically independent central bank. For neoliberals the government's fiscal position should be dictated by "expansionary fiscal austerity" and "sound money," instead of the fiscal stance targeting welfare and distributed prosperity, e.g., through a full employment policy and the provision of public goods by using the power of the government as currency issuer as needed. Thus the preference for rules and the rejection of discretion as interference.

Real-World Economics Review Blog
What happened to the public economy in economics?
June Sekera

Saturday, February 10, 2018

June Sekera — The absence of a theory of public economy in today’s economics

More than a century ago, the effective operation of the public economy was a significant, active concern of economists. With the insurgence of market-centrism and rational choice economics, however, government was devalued, its role circumscribed and seen from a perspective of “market failure.” As Backhouse (2005) has shown, the transformation in economic thinking in the latter half of the 20th century led to a “radical shift” in worldview regarding the role of the state. The very idea of a valid, valuable public non-market has almost disappeared from sight....
Because mainstream economists in the U.S. and elsewhere have been so market-focused for so long, production outside the market has been erased from the equations of economics. So now, government action is regarded as an “intervention” that “distorts” smooth operation of an otherwise beneficent market. Government is considered to have an economic role only (or primarily) in cases of so called “market failure.” Consequently, there is no viable and explanatory concept of an actual, let alone a legitimate, public non-market economy. So pervasive is the creed that government only “intervenes” in what is thought to be the valid, market economy that even literature from the Congressional Research Service (Labonte, 2010) relegates government to an outsider role.... 
As I noted earlier, the “public choice” school has become the framework to which economists default for an explanation of the public economy. Backhouse (2005) outlines the development of the public choice school, which stems from a cluster of works published in the 1950s and 1960s by James Buchanan, Gordon Tullock, Mancur Olson, and Anthony Downs. It became a school, and a movement, when James Buchanan and Warren Nutter found a home for their efforts at George Mason University in Virginia. In the mid-1980s George Mason opened the Center for the Study of Market Processes, with its largest supporter being the Koch Family Foundations. Stretton and Orchard (1994) have demonstrated the anti-government, anti-democratic stance of public choice theorists in their extensive treatment of the school in Public Goods, Public Enterprise, Public Choice; Theoretical Foundations of the Contemporary Attack on Government. After critiquing the theory in economics terms, they suggest that public choice “reasoning seems to arise from the theorists’ reluctance to ‘come out’ and identify themselves as open enemies of democracy or at least of universal suffrage…Governments are viewed as exploiters of the citizenry, rather than the means through which the citizenry secures for itself goods and services that can best be provided jointly or collectively.”...
Real-World Economics Review Blog
The absence of a theory of public economy in today’s economics
June Sekera, researcher, UCL Institute for Innovation and Public Purpose; founder of the independent Public Goods Institute, and Research Fellow at the Global Development And Environment Institute (GDAE) at Tufts University, where she established and leads GDAE’s Public Economy Project