Friday, August 23, 2019

Reuters — World needs to end risky reliance on U.S. dollar: BoE's Carney

Bank of England Governor Mark Carney took aim at the U.S. dollar's "destabilizing" role in the world economy on Friday and said central banks might need to join together to create their own replacement reserve currency.…
Boom!!! (Sound of heads exploding.)

Reuters
World needs to end risky reliance on U.S. dollar: BoE's Carney
Writing by William Schomberg; Editing by David Milliken

Whither Central Banking? Lawrence H. Summers

In an environment of secular stagnation in the developed economies, central bankers’ ingenuity in loosening monetary policy is exactly what is not needed. What is needed are admissions of impotence, in order to spur efforts by governments to promote demand through fiscal policies and other means.
Throwing in the towel (but not endorsing MMT). Politically, this is about control of the Democratic Party after the transition from Clinton-Obama-Third Way. Summers is on the side of the Establishment, while Stephanie Kelton is Bernie's advisor and in league with The Squad.

Project Syndicate
Whither Central Banking?
Lawrence H. Summers & Anna Stansbury

Top 1% Up $21 Trillion. Bottom 50% Down $900 Billion. — Matt Bruenig

The insights of this new data series are many, but for this post here I want to highlight a single eye-popping statistic. Between 1989 and 2018, the top 1 percent increased its total net worth by $21 trillion. The bottom 50 percent actually saw its net worth decrease by $900 billion over the same period.…
People's Policy Project
Top 1% Up $21 Trillion. Bottom 50% Down $900 Billion.
Matt Bruenig

Manufacturers Want to Quit China for Vietnam. They’re Finding It Impossible. Nobody has China's scale, infrastructure, experience, and supply chains — Niharika Mandhana

“China has a 15-year head start—whatever you want, someone’s doing it,” said Wing Xu, the operations director for Omnidex Group, which helps make large pumps for Pennsylvania-based industrial equipment manufacturer McLanahan Corp....
Checkpoint Asia
Manufacturers Want to Quit China for Vietnam. They’re Finding It Impossible. Nobody has China's scale, infrastructure, experience, and supply chains



Niharika Mandhana, The Wall Street Journal

Axios — In tweets, Trump tells American businesses to leave China

"Our great American companies are hereby ordered to immediately start looking for an alternative to China, including bringing your companies HOME and making your products in the USA."
The bottom line: It should go without saying that Trump doesn't have the authority to order U.S. companies to look for alternatives to China....
Axios
In tweets, Trump tells American businesses to leave China

See also at Axios

With deficit rising, worries grow the U.S. may be out of tools if recession hits


Nice figurative language metaphor here "out of tools!" like "out of money!" blah, blah, blah... no adjustment being made...  or no one "changing their minds!" either... above the fold Washington Post...



Thursday, August 22, 2019

Three Reasons To Be In Favor Of A Payroll Tax Cut — John T. Harvey

For at least a few moments this week, President Trump suggested a payroll tax cut to stimulate the stalling macroeconomy. Although it appears that he has already changed his mind, it’s worth taking a look at the strategy...just in case.
Let’s say for sake of argument that the negative signals we have received of late are accurate. What should we do if we slip into full-fledged recession? Cut interest rates? Lower the budget deficit? Decrease payroll taxes? It turns out that the last one is the clear and easy winner. Why?
Forbes — Pragmatic Economics
Three Reasons To Be In Favor Of A Payroll Tax Cut
John T. Harvey | Professor of Economics, Texas Christian University

The Federal Reserve’s new Distributional Financial Accounts provide telling data on growing U.S. wealth and income inequality — Raksha Kopparam

Wealth disparities between the rich and the poor in the United States have broadened over the past 30 years, according to a new dataset released earlier this month by researchers at the Federal Reserve Board. Their Distributional Financial Accounts is the new dataset that provides quarterly estimates of wealth distribution in the country from 1989 to 2019. 2 The new dataset was created by integrating the Federal Reserve Board’s Financial Accounts with the Survey of Consumer Finances. Together, they contain reliable measures of the distribution of household-sector assets and liabilities from 1989, which gives policymakers and economists alike new insight into how the distribution of wealth has changed since the 1990s.

The new Federal Reserve Board dataset confirms that wealth concentration has been growing, consistent with other data series such as the World Inequality Database assembled by academics worldwide. Indeed, the Fed’s new Distributional Financial Accounts open up new opportunities to study close to real-time changes in the U.S. wealth distribution. It provides the necessary data to study fluctuations in the wealth distribution over short time periods, while accounting for changes that occur between times of survey measurement for less frequently collected datasets....
WCEG — The Equitablog
The Federal Reserve’s new Distributional Financial Accounts provide telling data on growing U.S. wealth and income inequality
Raksha Kopparam, Research Assistant at the Washington Center for Equitable Growth

On Demagogues and Democracy — Eric Schliesser


Some social & political theory. Focuses on Walter Lippmann, The Good Society.

Although Eric Schliesser doesn't mention it in this post, Aristotle discussed these issues in detail in his Politics.

Digressions&Impressions
On Demagogues and Democracy
Eric Schliesser | Professor of Political Science, University of Amsterdam’s (UvA) Faculty of Social and Behavioural Sciences

Our Money: Modern Monetary Theory Must Dominate Democratic Debate — PR Newsletter

This Labor Day, Our Money will gather 500 participants to host a march for Full Employment and Economic Justice in commemoration of the Civil Rights Movement legacy of advocacy for a Federal Job Guarantee. The march will begin at the MLK Memorial in Washington DC at 11 am and end at the Marriner Eccles Building of the Federal Reserve around 2 pm. 
Our Money founder, Rev. Dr. Delman Coates, will use this opportunity to draw the connection for lay audiences between the Civil Rights struggle for Full Employment and Economic Justice, and the importance of understanding our public power of money creation, as illuminated by insurgent school of economic thought, Modern Monetary Theory (MMT). Dr. Coates will call on Congress to pass a Federal Job Guarantee, as well as hold hearings on MMT in order to allow the public to formally interrogate the implications of our public power....
Grassroots MMT.

Yahoo Finance
Our Money: Modern Monetary Theory Must Dominate Democratic Debate
PR Newsletter

Just do nothing...


Kashkari going to State Fair... Fed in Jackson Hole... these people not doing much work these days... kicking back here in August this month...

Pretty good indicator that they wont be doing anything before September meeting... good sign...

 #JustDoNothing



Powell: “Treasury is responsible for exchange rate policy -- full stop"


Looks like a political impasse between these 2 Monetarist morons:





Bill Mitchell — The EU pronouncement of a Greek success ignores the reality

I keep reading ridiculous articles about Brexit in the UK Guardian. The latest was comparing it to pre-WWI Britain and suggesting there were no signs of a “Damascene moment remainers hoped for”. I thought that reference was apposite – given the reference invokes St Paul’s conversion after he was struck blind. Good analogy – blind and remainer. The Brexit imbroglio is all the more puzzling because it seems to be a massive mismatch of scale – a currency-issuing nation and an organisation with no currency and no democratic legitimacy. And that is before one even contemplates the nature of that organisation. On August 20. 2019, the European Union provided us with a perfect example of why no responsible government would want to be part of it. In its – Daily News 20/08/2019 – there were three items. The last item told us that construction output in the EU28 had declined by 0.3 per cent in June 2019. The first item was a sort of cock-a-hoop boast about how great Greece is after the EU saved it from disaster. Parallel universe sort of stuff. Britain will thank its lucky stars after October 31, 2019 when it goes free from that madness. Even though the remainers remain ‘blind’ without their Damascene moment”….
Bill Mitchell – billy blog
The EU pronouncement of a Greek success ignores the reality
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

Wednesday, August 21, 2019

Links — 21 Aug 2019

The Vineyard of the Saker
U.S.-UK Deep State Tries to Grab Hong Kong
Eric Zuesse

NEO
Roots of Chaos in Hong Kong were Planted in Washington
Salman Rafi Sheikh

CGTN
179 officers injured, Hong Kong police urge public to stay rational

The Unblanced Evolution of Homo Sapiens
John Pilger: Breaking up the Russian Federation is an American objective

Sic Semper Tyrannis
Joseph Mifsud, British "Joe", Not Russia's Boy by Larry C Johnson
Larry C. Johnson | CEO and co-founder of BERG Associates, LLC, an international business-consulting firm with expertise combating terrorism and investigating money laundering, formerly Deputy Director in the U.S. State Department’s Office of Counter Terrorism (1989-1993, and CIA operations (1984-1989)

Moon of Alabama
Anti-China Cult Gets U.S. Government Money - Runs Large Pro-Trump Ad Campaign

Reminiscence of the Future
As Was Totally Expected.


AlterNet
This passage was deleted from the Declaration of Independence — here’s what it reveals about motivation for the American Revolution
Cody Fenwick


Trump HAMMERING the Fed


He mutilated them today:







Helicopter presser:



Planetary Thinking — Eric Berglöf

As policymakers, academics, and activists prepare for next month's United Nations climate summit in New York, they should consider precisely what it will take to build a truly sustainable global economy. First and foremost, the world needs a new multidisciplinary approach that is broad enough to tackle the challenge....
Project Syndicate
Planetary Thinking
Eric Berglöf

‘Was Goebbels unavailable?’: ABC blasted for ‘normalizing fascism’ by putting Sean Spicer on ‘Dancing With the Stars’ — David Badash

I am purposefully avoiding overtly political stuff now that we are in the throes of another campaign.

However, when one faction of the country sees the other faction as fascist and names it, political discourse has descended about as far as it can go in that direction other than upping the amps.

The opposite extreme when one side sees the others a socialist and even communist, political discourse has descended about as far as it can go in that direction other than upping the amps.

This is a political issue that is being reflected in societal problems that have wide-ranging impact on social, political and economic life.

At the extreme, this will surface as the campaign being represented as between Hitler and Stalin.

AlterNet
‘Was Goebbels unavailable?’: ABC blasted for ‘normalizing fascism’ by putting Sean Spicer on ‘Dancing With the Stars’
David Badash | The New Civil Rights Movement

It’s official: Parts of California are too wildfire-prone to insure — Nathanael Johnson

California is facing yet another real estate-related crisis, but we’re not talking about its sky-high home prices. According to newly released data, it’s simply become too risky to insure houses in big swaths of the wildfire-prone state.
Last winter when we wrote about home insurance rates possibly going up in the wake of California’s massive, deadly fires, the insurance industry representatives we interviewed were skeptical. They noted that the stories circulating in the media about people in forested areas losing their homeowners’ insurance was based on anecdotes, not data. But now, the data is in and it’s really happening: Insurance companies aren’t renewing policies areas climate scientists say are likely to burn in giant wildfires in coming years....
I had friends burned out in the recent fires and insurance paid for it. With insurance it was still a disaster, not only materially but also psychologically. Without insurance?

The Midwest is affected by the opposite issue — flooding. And the coasts are being threatened by sea level rise.

Big changes coming economically and financially.

Grist
It’s official: Parts of California are too wildfire-prone to insure
Nathanael Johnson

The Gold Standard Fell As All Currency Pegs Do — Martin Armstrong

The fate of pegs is always the same because there is this thing we call the business cycle.
Armstrong Economics
The Gold Standard Fell As All Currency Pegs Do
Martin Armstrong

Completing The Euro: The Euro Treasury And The Job Guarantee — Esteban Cruz-Hidalgo, Dirk H. Ehnts, Pavlina R. Tcherneva

Abstract
The problems with the design of the Eurozone came into focus when, late in 2009, several member nations– notably Greece – failed to refinance their government debt. The crisis that followed was not entirely asurprise. When the Euro was launched in 1999, many economists warned that the single currency was unworkable. Even Eurozone optimists argued that the Euro project would eventually need to be completed. More than 10 years after the crisis, unemployment rates remain elevated and continue to threaten the social, political and economic stability of the Eurozone. The institutional constraints of the single currency however preclude bold action to address these challenges. In this paper, we suggest that tackling the twin problems of the Eurozone – its institutional flaws and mass unemployment – could be addressed by creating a Euro Treasury that would finance a Job Guarantee program, which would eliminate mass unemployment, enhance price stability, and foster social and economic integration across Europe.
COMPLETING THE EURO: THE EURO TREASURY AND THE JOB GUARANTEE
Esteban Cruz-Hidalgo, Universidad de Extremadura, Dirk H. Ehnts European University of Flensburg, Pavlina R. Tcherneva Bard College

Solar Power Is Now As Inexpensive As Grid Electricity In China Charles Q. Choi

Researchers found that PV systems could produce electricity at a lower price than the grid in 344 cities.
Good news for air quality and climate. China has been relying on coal-fired plants (72% in 2016).

Two anecdotes. I have a friend that teaches for six-weeks in Beijing on occasion. I once said to him that it must be a great experience. He answered that it was terrible, the pollution was so bad. I have another acquaintance that is Chinese, now living in the US. He's been here about 20 years. I asked him if he thought ever of returning to China. He shook his head and pointed upward. I asked him what he meant, and he said, "blue sky." 

China is not alone in this in the developing world. Electrification is a big deal, and cost is a major consideration.

China Could Overwhelm US Military In Asia In Hours — Brad Lendon


Arms race watch. It's on.

CNN
China Could Overwhelm US Military In Asia In Hours
Brad Lendon

Research finds the domestic outsourcing of jobs leads to declining U.S. job quality and lower wages — Kate Bahn

The domestic outsourcing of jobs in the United States is fast becoming a dominant explanation for the destruction of the social contract of work, a historic concept in which norms of fairness and solidarity between firms and their employees played a major role in wage setting and workplace standards for some U.S. workers—though of course many others such as African American workers were consistently more marginalized. The destruction of this social contract, detailed in Brandeis University economist David Weil’s book The Fissured Workplace, describes a labor market structure in which workers are employed at firms with core competencies and then those firms subcontract out all other duties or specific functions in the production process.
Within daily work activities, U.S. workers may directly interact with other workers across a variety of firms with different levels of job quality. One prototypical example is janitorial work, where most office cleaners today are employed by a janitorial services company that is contracted by the building owner where individual office places lease their space. These kinds of fissured employment patterns have led economists and other social science researchers to examine a variety of empirical research questions about what has caused domestic outsourcing, what the impacts have been and for whom, and what the future of the firm will be.

This body of research lays the groundwork for U.S. policymakers to understand the impact of this domestic outsourcing phenomenon and what sort of policy solutions can ensure that economic prosperity is broadly shared as workers and firms alike consider “the future of work” in the United States....
The bottom line is that "the American dream" was based on a significant portion of the population being employed in relatively secure and well-compensated in manufacturing. Foreign outsourcing changed that and the US economy has been in flux ever since. The trend is toward concentration at and near the top, that is, the upper quintile, while the rest of the population available for work either stagnates or sinks. Another trend is domestic outsourcing, which has disrupted the previous concept of a secure job, essentially for life.

These are obvious trends in a liberal economic model ("capitalism") since they reduce costs and increase efficiency. However, they are also having a profound social impact, and therefore a political one as well, as life for many becomes more precarious. 

WCEG — The Equitablog
Research finds the domestic outsourcing of jobs leads to declining U.S. job quality and lower wages
Kate Bahn

Econometrics and the problem of unjustified assumptions — Lars P. Syll


This is important but may be too wonkish for those who are not intimately familiar with econometrics. So let me try to simplify it and universalize it.

The basic idea in logical reasoning is that an argument is sound if and only if the premises are true and the logical form is valid.  Then the conclusion follows as necessarily true.

This is the basis of scientific reasoning.

In modeling, a set of assumptions, both substantive and procedural, is stipulated, that is, assumed to be true. In a well-founded model all the assumptions that make substantive claims are known to be true empirically on the basis of evidence. This is called semantic truth. The logical truth of logical form is formal proof. This is called syntactical truth. Only the former contains substance. The latter is purely procedural.

A key methodological assumption of the scientific method is naturalism. Being "scientific" signifies being based on observation, rather than say, intuition or "common sense," that is, self-evidence. No self-evident first principles — that's doing philosophy, not science. Not that such speculation is not useful. It's just not science and should not be conflated with science. There is often a tendency to do so.

This presents two major difficulties with scientific modeling versus philosophical speculation. The first is the empirical warrant of the starting points, the stipulations that are assumed to be true and serve as the premises of the argument. The second is knowing that all relevant information is included in the assumptions. This is called identification.

Paraphrasing Richard Feynman, we do science in order to avoid fooling ourselves and we are the easiest ones to fool (owing to confirmation bias, for example). This requires following scientific method scrupulously when substantial claims are made.

Keynes pointed out to Roy Harrod that econometrics did not conform to this strict procedure and that owing to the nature of the subject matter, economics was "moral science," which at the time signified what we would now call "philosophy." The social sciences and much of psychology fall into this category. They are basically speculative exercises that employ some formal methods that may be scientific, or not. 

Accounting is a formal method that is proto-scientific in the sense that double entry it is made up of tautologies. But the entries can be checked for substance against journals and inventories. It is a method to prevent fooling ourselves on one hand, and to prevent cheating on the other.

When accounting tautologies (identities) are interpreted causally, then causal explanation demands empirical corroboration through data, e.g., measurable changes in stocks and flows.

Lars P. Syll’s Blog
Econometrics and the problem of unjustified assumptions
Lars P. Syll | Professor, Malmo University

See also

Bond Economics
Comments On "Business Cycle Anatomy"
Brian Romanchuk

Bill Mitchell — The rich are getting richer in Australia while the rest of us mark time

Only a short blog post today – in terms of actual researched content. Plenty of announcements and news though, a cartoon, and some great music. I have been meaning to write about the household income and wealth data that the ABS released in July, which showed that real income and wealth growth over a significant period for low income families has been close to zero, while the top 20 per cent have enjoyed rather massive gains. These trends are unsustainable. A nation cannot continually be distributing income to the top earners who spend less overall while starving the lower income cohorts of income growth. A nation cannot also continually create wealth accumulation opportunities for the richest while the rest go backwards. These trends generate spending crises, asset bubbles and social instability. That is what is emerging in Australia at present.
While Bill's analysis in this post is Aussie-centric, the rationale is applicable to the whole neoliberal world. It's basically what neoliberalism is about. The contemporary difference is that now the domestic populations of the neoliberal nations are being colonized as well. Even some of the top tier that are receiving most of the benefits are getting squeamish, realizing that an unsustainable process cannot go on forever and that eventually the bill will come due.

Bill Mitchell – billy blog
The rich are getting richer in Australia while the rest of us mark time
Bill Mitchell | Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at University of Newcastle, NSW, Australia

The Grayzone - Obama official and Venezuelan coup lobbyist wrecked by Max Blumenthal

Max Blumenthal is so direct here. An official says that Obama considered Venezuela to be a security threat to the US, but Max asks for evidence, for which there is none. A Guaido official says Venezuela supports terrorists, like Al Quada, but Max asks again for the evidence, and then says that we know that the US arms ISIS in Syria.


Tuesday, August 20, 2019

Trump says White House looking at payroll tax cut — Brett Samuels


Another reversal of position, but this time definitive, coming from the Oval Office.

Unfortunately, the Democratic Establishment will probably paint this as 1) an attack on Social Security, which is "funded" by the payroll tax, and 2) a further "blowing out" of the deficit, both of which are nonsense in terms of MMT.

Actually, a payroll tax cut would be redistributive, which would bolster the president's support among the middle class, and it would increase the purchasing power of all working people that pay the tax, likely leading to consumer spending that would be stimulative. 

The later is the expectation of the Trump administration to ward off the onset of a recession that isn't coming anyway. Trump is correct in claiming that the media is wrong in predicting an immanent recession. Data do not support this, government spending liberally, increasing the deficit year over year, and bank credit increasing, also adding to purchasing power. Inflation remains low, and the labor bill is not increasing markedly.

The threat of recession for the US comes mostly from coupling to the global economy, which the president's own policies are affecting negatively, and there is evidence that the global economy is sluggish, as the Chinese economy consolidates and Chinese resource appetite reduces. However, there is enough uncertainty about the global economy, e.g., owing to exogenous shock (war) and the emerging challenge of climate change, that markets are skittish and the media is doing well selling fear.

The president is also encouraging the Fed to cut the interest rate by 100 bp and restart QE, which he believes would be stimulative, failing to grasp that cutting interest rates lowers government spending on interest payments. The reason he want a resumption of QE is to stimulate asset prices in the face of a stock market sell-off.

MMT economists have been recommending reduction or abolition of the payroll tax as a matter of principle, since it doesn't actually fund Social Security, only appearing that way for those who don't understand the actual operations and accounting. But the Trump administration is not proceeding on that basis.

The GOP has pretty consistently acted in terms of MMT principles when it suits their agenda, while espousing fiscal responsibility and discipline when it comes to funding social welfare.

The Hill
Trump says White House looking at payroll tax cut
Brett Samuels

Modern Money and the War Treasury — Sam Levey

Abstract: Using historical sources, we attempt to unravel and elucidate the economic worldview held by the United States Treasury Department during World War II. We analyze the Treasury’s view of taxation, bond sales, and interest rates. We consider whether and in what ways this worldview is compatible with Modern Monetary Theory, finding that, in most regards, the two align closely, the differences being primarily attributable to the peculiarities of war finance. Finding a less clear view of national debt, an interpretation is offered based on Treasury’s statements. We also offer evidence that this view had a foothold in the era’s news outlets.
Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity
Modern Money and the War Treasury
Sam Levey | Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity Graduate Student, University of Missouri – Kansas City

The magic money does exist - but can we trust politicians to use it? — Paddy Dear

In 2017 when a nurse pointed out that her wages had not increased for several years, then-prime minister Theresa May quipped: “There is no magic money tree.” Well, maybe Mrs May was wrong. I believe there is a magic money tree and it is coming to western economies very soon. I am talking about MMT. And strangely, MMT doesn’t stand for “magic money tree”; it’s Modern Monetary Theory....
The question, "Can we trust politicians," is really a question about the viability of democracy. The answer of the liberal faction is, yes. The response of the conservative faction is a resounding, no. Safeguards are required to protect from the excesses of democracy, e.g., descent into "rabble rule."

So after the economic/financial issues are settled, the political questions emerge. This boils down to different worldviews with different value systems and ideologies.

The Telegraph is a Tory paper.
So MMT is flawed, not by economics but by human nature. They say central bankers should take away the punch bowl just as the party gets going. While we may trust central bankers to do so, I haven’t been to a party yet where the party goers themselves elected to remove the punch bowl.
Democracy needs grownup supervision, you see.

The Telegraph (Registration required)
The magic money does exist - but can we trust politicians to use it?
Paddy Dear | co-founder of Tetragon, a closed-end investment company where he serves on the board of directors and investment committee

The Economist Who Believes the Government Should Just Print More Money — Zach Helfand

I’d been stewing for a few months in the melange of blogs and YouTube videos and white papers that make up much of the M.M.T. world. Some intricacies lay beyond me—a hazy blur of literature about floating exchange rates and reserve currencies addled my brain. But the basic principle of M.M.T. is seductively simple: governments don’t have to budget like households, worrying about debt, because, unlike households, they can simply print their own money....
This illustrates a major difficulty in public education about MMT. On one hand, the financial and economic concepts are beyond many laypersons, while on the other, the body of literature with which one must be familiar is daunting to non-specialists. So the commonly held view is that MMT is about "printing money," which sounds irresponsible to much of the public.
I asked Ann whether she found Kelton convincing. “I mean, kind of!” she said. “I know what she said was brilliant, I just can’t believe her. She’s gotta be wrong.”
It's not just the public either.
Still, most mainstream economists view M.M.T. as the Cult of the Magic Money Tree, deriding what they see as its theorists’ preference for analogy over mathematical modelling or empirical evidence. “What most concerns me is I can’t actually quite figure out what it is,” Paul Krugman, the Nobel Prize-winning economist and Times columnist, told me. Krugman is a political progressive, and he agrees with many of the spending programs that M.M.T. proponents support. But, he said, “I’ll be damned if I can figure out what it is exactly that they think.”
But this is a whole article on MMT that focuses on Stephanie Kelton as MMT's chief media spokesperson, and "there's no such thing as bad publicity." Free publicity is always a gift, especially in an environment in which the media tends toward marginalization of politically incorrect ideas and people that espouse them.

Zach Helfand concludes on a hopeful note:
I asked Kelton if she worries at all about these fights, further over the horizon. “At the end of the day, what I really hope for is just a better debate,” she told me. “Let both sides put forward their best ideas.”
This is the ultimate dream of M.M.T.: freed from false financial shackles, we could debate, on honest terms, the most fundamental political questions. If money weren’t an issue, would we want to scrub carbon from the atmosphere? Pay for reparations? Expand ice? Maybe we just want to be left alone, with our tax money in our pockets and some Social Security checks when we age. M.M.T.’s architects describe their vision as encompassing not just a better economy but a better, healthier body politic—a goal that is, given the state of things, almost certainly doomed, but is admirable nonetheless. Deficits do matter—not just the financial ones.
The critique is "fair and balanced," with the proviso that the author admits limited knowledge of MMT as a macroeconomic theory. Actually, not a surprising limitation when Paul Krugman admits that he can't figure it out either, based on conventional economic training.

The hurdle seems to be MMT's simplicity:  A currency sovereign funds itself through issuance; the real constraint is availability of real resource, and the financial constraint is price and exchange rate stability. Simple, but it seems to boggle minds. But it is not as simple as it may look, either. It contains the most salient features of macroeconomics as a policy science when unpacked through the theory.

Zach Helfand, New Yorker editorial staff member