Wednesday, June 7, 2017

Daniel Luban — The Elusive Karl Polanyi

Karl Polanyi had thought of calling his magnum opus Origins of the Cataclysm, or The Liberal Utopia, or Freedom from Economics. His publisher, worried about the book’s marketability, instead gave it the title by which it eventually became famous: The Great Transformation. It was an ambiguous phrase. Readers might imagine that “the great transformation” refers to the history the book traces: the imposition, equally utopian and violent, of the market economy upon a recalcitrant society, spreading from England to encompass the globe and ultimately bringing on the collapse of world order in the twentieth century. But for Polanyi the great transformation lay not in the past but in the future. It referred not to the coming of market liberalism but of socialism, understood as “the tendency inherent in an industrial civilization to transcend the self-regulating market by consciously subordinating it to a democratic society.” And this transformation would be the culmination of the dynamic that he famously called the “double movement,” in which the ravages of the market inevitably lead society to “protect itself” against depredation....
Dissent — Spring 2017
The Elusive Karl Polanyi
Daniel Luban, postdoctoral associate in the humanities at Yale University
ht David Fields at Radical Political Economy

2 comments:

Andrew Anderson said...

And this transformation would be the culmination of the dynamic that he famously called the “double movement,” in which the ravages of the market inevitably lead society to “protect itself” against depredation....

What market? Instead, we have government-subsidized private credit creation whereby the richer, the more so-called credit-worthy, exploit the poorer, the less so-called credit-worthy.

But yes, the predation will lead to a backlash. Let's hope that THIS TIME, the proper diagnosis will be reached and that we'll have genuine reform wrt fiat and credit creation as well as proper restitution and not government-provided wage slavery for the victims (i.e. let's have a UBI or BIG rather than a JG and not to rule out large asset redistribution either).

AXEC / E.K-H said...

ICYMI

Does Asad Zaman fly with POL or SCI Airlines? Comment on ‘Meta-theory and pluralism in the methodology of Polanyi’
http://axecorg.blogspot.de/2017/05/does-asad-zaman-fly-with-pol-or-sci.html

Egmont Kakarot-Handtke